Editor’s Note: A version of this story was published in the Fall 2026 issue of Extant, a publication of the Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia.
Trinity Lutheran Church
Location: 5300 Germantown Avenue
Built: 1837, with additions in 1857, 1871, 1915
Threat: Burst water pipe
Founded in 1836 as the English Evangelical Lutheran Congregation of Germantown, an English-language offshoot of St. Michael’s Lutheran Church, the congregation reflected the transition of Philadelphia’s German immigrant communities into English-speaking congregations during the 19th century.
The congregation acquired property on Germantown Avenue that included an 18th-century house built by Christopher Sower, printer of America’s first German-language Bible in 1743, and incorporated it into the church complex as a parsonage. The church sanctuary was constructed in 1837, with a prominent steeple added in 1857 and modeled after the work of Sir Christopher Wren in London. The congregation adopted the name Trinity Lutheran Church that same year. Additional alterations between 1871 and 1873, and the installation of stained glass in 1885, reflect the congregation’s continued growth.
In 1914, the congregation commissioned noted Philadelphia architect Mantle Fielding to design a parish house connected to the church and fronting Penn Street. Completed in 1915, it included a gymnasium, classrooms, and community gathering spaces, with further additions completed in 1917 and 1920.
While the main church was listed on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places in 1957, the parish house remains undesignated. This past winter, a burst water pipe caused severe damage throughout portions of the building, including damaged walls and floors, a compromised heating system, and urgent structural issues. The extent of the damage places the complex at risk of further deterioration and underscores the need for preservation and investment to protect this historically significant Germantown institution.
Hare and Cute Coal Pocket
Location: 106 Jamestown Avenue
Built: 1834
Threat: Demolition
The Hare and Cute Coal Pocket is a surviving reminder of Manayunk’s industrial past. Constructed in 1929 after the elevation of the railroad tracks between the Wissahickon and Manayunk stations, the structure was built by coal merchant Hare and Cute to receive, store, and distribute coal shipments that fueled the neighborhood’s mills, factories, homes, and businesses.
Designed for efficiency, the coal pocket could accommodate three 55-ton hopper cars on a rail spur above. Coal was unloaded into large storage bins and funneled down into street-level loading bays, where carts, and later trucks, could be filled directly. Today, it is one of the few remaining coal pockets along the rail corridor. Faded painted advertisements for Hare and Cute and James Cute and Sons remain visible on the metal siding.
Following the 1976 bankruptcy of the Reading Company, the yard was converted into a parking lot before finding new life as the Pennsylvania Horticultural Society’s (PHS) Pop Up Garden at Manayunk. The former loading bays now house the beer garden bar and gathering spaces, demonstrating how an industrial structure can be successfully adapted for contemporary use.
In the spring, a proposal emerged to demolish the coal pocket and construct a 60-foot-tall apartment building. Although the property is located within the Main Street Manayunk Historic District, the structure is not designated as contributing and can be demolished without review by the Philadelphia Historical Commission. While many residents are concerned about losing the popular PHS garden, the potential loss of this rare industrial landmark should not be overlooked.
Leader Theatre
Location: 4102-04 Lancaster Avenue
Built: 1912
Threat: Vacancy
The Leader Theatre stands as a largely intact reminder of West Philadelphia’s early moviegoing era, now at risk as redevelopment plans seemingly stall and the building remains vacant. Designed by prolific theater architect John D. Allen, the Leader was among the first purpose-built neighborhood cinemas in the city, bridging the gap between vaudeville houses and the streamlined movie theaters that followed. Its design combined a traditional horseshoe seating plan with a cantilevered balcony and unobstructed sight-lines, reflecting a pivotal moment in theater evolution.
Architecturally, the building remains striking. In 2020, decades-old metal cladding was removed and a dignified Classical Revival facade emerged, complete with arched openings, multi-light windows, and terra cotta detailing that distinguished the theater as a prominent community destination.
After closing as a theater in 1968, the building cycled through community and commercial uses, including the Police Athletic League and later retail. More recently, a redevelopment proposal aimed to convert the structure into artist studios and creative workspaces, with initial improvements such as new windows suggesting forward momentum. However, that effort has since stalled, leaving the building in a state of uncertainty.
Without local historic designation or an active project, the Leader Theatre remains vulnerable despite its National Register status. Reviving a viable reuse plan is essential to ensuring this long-hidden building does not once again fade from view.





