Preservation

The Sounds of Philly Reverberate Around the World

February 11, 2025 | by Jack McCarthy

The Met at 858 N. Broad Street. | Photo: Peter Woodall

In 2026, all eyes will be on Philadelphia as we celebrate the 250th anniversary of the nation’s founding and our city’s pivotal role as the birthplace of American democracy. However, for millions of people around the world who know little to nothing about American history, Philadelphia is known more as an incubator of great music than as the place where the Declaration of Independence was written.

The city has produced some of the world’s greatest music and musicians: the sublime sonority of the Philadelphia Orchestra, widely considered one of the greatest symphonic ensembles, the timeless appeal of Philly Soul, the sophisticated rhythm and blues style created by songwriter/producers Kenny Gamble, Leon Huff, Thom Bell, and others, the groundbreaking jazz innovations of Dizzy Gillespie, John Coltrane, Lee Morgan and a host of local greats, and the infectious pop rock sounds of Charlie Gracie, Chubby Checker, Bobby Rydell, and other teen idols who came out of Philadelphia in the late 1950s and early 1960s, when the city was one of the nation’s most influential popular music centers. It is no exaggeration to say that Philadelphia music has changed the world.

The Philadelphia Opera House (now called The Met Philadelphia) received national attention when it opened in 1908. The neoclassical facade and white brick exterior contrasted mightily with the red brick and brownstone houses that neighbored it on North Broad and Poplar Streets. | Photo courtesy of Special Collections Research Center, Temple University Libraries

Philadelphia’s musical prominence began in the late 18th century, when the city was the political and cultural capital of the young United States, attracting the greatest musicians from both America and Europe. These artists created a vibrant musical scene and established traditions that continue to shape American music. At the same time, Philadelphia had the nation’s largest population of free Black people in the 18th century. In the early 20th century it drew hundreds of thousands of African Americans escaping the South as part of the Great Migration. These new arrivals brought their own distinct Southern musical traditions with them. The merging of the various African-and European-derived musical traditions gave rise to an especially rich musical environment, one that produced some of the world’s most beloved, influential music.

Philadelphia’s record of preserving the sites and structures of this rich musical history is a mixed one, however. There have been notable success stories, to be sure: the Philadelphia Orchestra’s stewardship of its original home, the ornate Academy of Music, which opened in 1857 and is the oldest opera house in America still used as such, concert promoter Live Nation’s 2018 restoration of The Met, the massive Metropolitan Opera House that opened on North Broad Street in 1908 and is now an active concert venue once again, and the adaptive reuse in 1997 by business incubator the Enterprise Center of the former studios of WFIL radio and TV at 46th and Market streets, built in 1948 and home of the enormously popular teen music and dance TV program American Bandstand, which broadcasted nationally from the site from 1957 to 1964.

The auditorium of the Royal Theater on South Street in 2017. | Photos: Michael Bixler

Yet, for every success story there have been many losses. Dozens of 19th-and early 20th-century concert halls, opera houses, and theaters have been demolished–structures that were a direct link to a time before the advent of recordings and radio, when live performance was the only way to experience music and audiences flocked to such venues for entertainment. In two cases–Musical Fund Hall on Locust Street and the Royal Theater on South Street–we are left with only the facades of buildings that have important stories to tell.

Musical Fund Hall opened in 1824 and served as the city’s main concert hall until superseded by the Academy of Music in 1857, while the Royal opened in 1920 and was one of the premier venues for Black entertainment in the city into the mid-20th century. Both buildings were on the National Register of Historic Places, but were delisted after their auditoriums–their chief historic features–were replaced by condominiums.

Uptown Theater at 2240 N. Broad Street. | Photo: Michael Bixler

Two important sites in Philadelphia Black music currently face uncertain fates: the Uptown Theater on North Broad Street, where legendary DJ Georgie Woods, “the Guy with the Goods,” produced shows from the late 1950s to early 1970s that featured the biggest names in Black music, and the Sigma Sound Studios building on N. 12th Street in Center City, the recording studio where most Philly Soul hits were created.

The nonprofit Uptown Entertainment & Development Corporation, which owns the long-shuttered Uptown, has ambitious plans for a combined entertainment venue/museum/commercial leasing space. However, some initial fundraising success notwithstanding, it has been unable to raise the millions of dollars necessary. Local music buffs are hoping to do something creative with the Sigma Sound building, but its private owner wants to develop the property. There is better news with the John Coltrane House on N. 33rd Street in Strawberry Mansion, where the legendary saxophonist lived from 1952 to 1958 and where he had a spiritual and musical awakening in 1957 that changed the course of jazz forever. After years of decline and tangled legal issues, there is finally a credible plan to preserve the house and create a museum and cultural arts center around it.

The Paul Robeson House at 4951 Walnut Street. | Photo: Michael Bixler

Other area house museums are preserving important Philadelphia musical legacies as well: the Marian Anderson Museum & Historical Society, Paul Robeson House & Museum, and Mario Lanza Institute & Museum. Sadly, despite strong objections from the community, Lanza’s birthplace and childhood home on Christian Street in South Philadelphia was demolished in 2018 for residential development.

Music is one of Philadelphia’s greatest contributions to the world, a unique part of the city’s heritage that makes it an important cultural center and a special place to live and visit. As we gear up for celebrating the nation’s semiquincentennial, in addition to focusing on places like Independence Hall, let’s also focus on preserving and highlighting the sites and structures of this key part of Philadelphia and American history.



Tags:    

Jack McCarthy
About the Author

Jack McCarthy is a longtime Philadelphia archivist and historian who has held leadership positions at several area historical institutions and directed a number of major archives and public history projects. His chief areas of expertise are Philadelphia music history and Northeast Philadelphia history. McCarthy has served as consulting archivist and historian for the Philadelphia Orchestra, Mann Center for the Performing Arts, and Philadelphia Jazz Legacy Project. He regularly writes, lectures and gives tours on Philadelphia music. McCarthy's book "A Century of Music Under the Stars: A History of the Mann Center for the Performing Arts and Robin Hood Dell" will be published by Temple University Press in 2025. McCarthy was president of the Friends of Northeast Philadelphia History for many years and currently directs the Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia’s Poquessing Creek Trail of History project, which focuses on the Byberry section of Far Northeast Philadelphia.

2 Comments:

  1. Juanda Myles says:

    Perhaps the Uptown Theater needs an infusion of new blood to raise funds for its salvation and resurrection. Maybe a group called the Friends of the Uptown Legacy. They need a group that is experienced in fundraising and get people excited about the massive project. Another of people are waiting for the grand reopening not knowing their time, energy and effort is needed. They are passive participators; The ones who stand back wondering when someone is going to make things happen. I know we can do this if The Apollo was able to do it through the efforts of Mr. Percy Sutton, I believe it was.

    1. TC says:

      A perfect place for an interactive Philadelphia Music Museum that hosts occasional shows to commemorate imporant historical moments in the city’s musical journey, including the invention of the music recording industry with Berliner’s gramophone and Atwater Kent’s radio that led to the development of 78s and 45s, also invented in the city of brotherly love.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.