Historic renovation isn’t just for buildings. In response to increased rainfall attributed to climate change, stakeholders are directing resources toward restoring and protecting some of nature’s bygone capacity to absorb, filter, and slow stormwater runoff, which the Philadelphia Water Department (PWD) acknowledges as “the primary cause of pollution in our local rivers and creeks.”
Fueled in part by PWD, along with significant private foundation and government agency funding, nonprofit organizations, schools, businesses, municipalities, and citizen scientists are taking measures designed to slow the flow of runoff with the goal of reducing flooding and some of the pollution in the city’s waterways. These include rain gardens—shallow pits of native plants designed to capture and store rain water—and riparian buffers along streams that feature native trees and shrubs meant to control erosion and provide shade that lowers water temperature in the summer.

Wingohocking Creek (left), Tookany Creek (right), and Frankford Creek (foreground). | Photo: David Bell
Rain lands either directly on bodies of water, on the ground, or on impervious surfaces, such as streets, parking lots, and pavements. In general, when it falls on lawns, gardens, or forests, rainwater either gets soaked into the ground or flows on top of the ground as runoff, picking up fertilizer from lawns and farms and loose soil from construction projects.
When rain falls on impervious surfaces, the runoff flows downhill, grabbing motor oil, road salt, and other pollutants on its way to nearby creeks and rivers, either directly or via storm drains designed to move water quickly. In Philadelphia, where stormwater and sewage often share a combined sewer system, rain storms frequently overwhelm infrastructure, causing runoff mixed with raw sewage to be discharged into the Delaware River and its tributaries.
Hands On, Feet Wet

Streamkeeper David Bell sampling for chloride. | Photo courtesy of Tookany/Tacony-Frankford Watershed Partnership
I became more aware of how runoff impacts local waterways as a volunteer streamkeeper with the Tookany/Tacony-Frankford Watershed Partnership (TTF). The TTF watershed encompasses 29 square miles in Montgomery and Philadelphia counties. Headwater tributaries in Abington and Cheltenham townships join to form Tookany Creek, which becomes Tacony Creek in Philadelphia. Tacony Creek meets the sewer outfall that once was Wingohocking Creek on the grounds of the Juniata Golf Course to enter the Delaware River near Bridesburg as Frankford Creek. Launched by the PWD in 2000, and incorporated as an independent nonprofit organization in 2005, TTF’s work includes implementing restoration projects collectively known as Green Stormwater Infrastructure (GSI) along creeks in the watershed from Abington to Philadelphia.
“The number one challenge to many of our suburban watersheds is urban runoff. Therefore, many of the restoration efforts that we undertake focus on reducing the volume of stormwater entering our creeks,” said Ryan Neuman, TTF’s upstream conservation leader. “These efforts begin in the headwater creeks of the watershed, taking many forms such as rain gardens, bioswales, and subsurface stormwater storage, all aimed at slowing down stormwater. Especially in a highly urban watershed such as the TTF, the headwaters are often where we have the most space for these projects and where we can have the largest impact. As water flows downstream, pollutants such as sediment aggregate. When we work to improve water in the headwaters we are simultaneously improving water downstream as well.”
Along with co-stream keeper Rebecca Schultz, I monitor a site on Tookany Creek, making and reporting monthly observations of its health and the presence of wildlife. In addition to its GSI projects, TTF provides citizens with opportunities to engage with their watershed through stewardship, recreation, and education.

Volunteers plant native trees to control erosion. | Photo courtesy of Tookany/Tacony-Frankford Watershed Partnership
In that vein, TTF introduced me to the Penn State Extension (PSE) Master Watershed Steward (MWS) program. After 60-plus hours of training and volunteering, I was a certified MWS, joining colleagues in Philadelphia and surrounding counties to help manage stormwater with rain gardens and other GSI, remove trash and aggressive invasive plant species from waterways, engage with local elected officials on watershed and stormwater issues, and offer watershed outreach and education to adults and children at community events. Annual informational MWS recruiting sessions are held in December, and training begins in the spring.
TTF also provides regular training for streamkeepers, held in cooperation with our counterparts in the Pennypack and Wissahickon watersheds. Sessions on construction site runoff and road salt proved to be especially relevant to me.
Not long after training on construction site runoff, while passing a local high school construction site during a rain storm, I noticed brown water running off the hillside directly into a storm drain that emptied into a nearby creek. The main problem with too much soil in a waterway is that it contains nutrients that can cause algae blooms. When the algae die off, bacteria feed on them, consuming oxygen and releasing carbon dioxide in the process. This can cause oxygen dead zones where fish cannot survive. In some instances, the sediment can smother life on the bottom. GSI has limits in its ability to remove runoff soil before its enters waterways, so stopping it at the source is most effective.
A call to the county soil conservation district secured what turned out to be a false promise to visit the site. An email to a township official resulted in action. The next day, she informed me that the township engineer visited the site, saw that soil containment measures originally put in place had failed, and ordered the contractor to correct the problem. I went back during the next rain and saw that runoff from the site was mostly clear, although I couldn’t determine if the fix reduced the amount of water headed for the storm drain.
Salting the Water
The salt issue is more complicated. When it snows, states, municipalities, businesses, and homeowners routinely apply sodium chloride to highways, streets, parking lots, driveways, and sidewalks. Rightly seen as a safety measure, the problem is that people often use much more salt that is necessary. Salt can corrode cars and infrastructure and harm plants. What is left after a snowfall remains on hard surfaces until it gets washed away by rain or melting snow, ending up in our fresh water creeks.
Historically, salt levels in our creeks have tended to spike after winter snow events—often to levels that are toxic to aquatic life—before dropping in the spring, summer, and fall. Sampling and analysis by TTF and the Stroud Water Research Center over the past three years determined that levels of sodium chloride in Tookany Creek and its tributaries remain high year-round, even after winters of little or no snow. Data from the Izaak Walton League’s Salt Watch program confirm that this is a regional problem. As a consequence, salt has worked its way into our ground water and drinking water.
Municipalities around the country—places that get more snow than we do—have re-trained their operators, adopted best management practices, and turned to alternative products to reduce their impact, while ensuring public safety. Although local officials are aware of the problem, they have yet to address it in a quantitatively meaningful way. Water suppliers, such as PWD and Aqua, are not equipped to remove salt from drinking water, and GSI measures don’t work on salt, so reducing the amount that is applied, sweeping up the excess, and/or finding alternatives to sodium chloride are necessary to keep the problem from getting worse.
Outdated Wastewater Infrastructure
Around 60 percent of Philadelphia is served by a combined sewer system, where runoff and sewage flow through the same underground pipes. “During wet weather, this older section of our system often overflows,” notes PWD’s website. “As a result, billions of gallons of stormwater and diluted sewage flow into local waterways each year.” This is known as combined sewer overflow (CSO).
Philadelphia has three wastewater treatment plants and 164 outfalls where CSOs routinely discharge runoff and sewage into local creeks and rivers during and after rain events—for some waterways, as often as once a week or more, on average. “On Labor Day in 2019, just a quarter inch of rain caused a 9-fold spike in sewage and stormwater at Frankford Creek in Juniata Park, resulting in an overflow,” noted John Rumpler, clean water director and senior attorney for Environment America.

Construction site runoff feeding into a storm drain that feeds into Tookany Creek headwaters. | Photo: David Bell
In response to enforcement actions brought against Philadelphia by the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency for violations of state and federal laws, respectively, the City signed consent orders committed to reducing the volume of stormwater that enters its combined sewers. Dubbed “Green City, Clean Waters,” the 25-year plan details how PWD will implement green infrastructure measures, expand stormwater treatment capacity, and repair and improve existing infrastructure.
Officially launched in 2011 and scheduled to meet pollution reduction goals by 2036, PWD says that in the program’s first 10 years, system repairs and the installation of more than 2,800 green tools at nearly 800 sites throughout the city kept more than 2.7 billion gallons of polluted water from entering local waterways.
To encourage community support of its stormwater management efforts, PWD offers a Home Stormwater Guide, incentives and private development services for businesses, mini-grants to organizations, and a guide to transforming schoolyards—available on its Green City, Clean Waters website.
A Critical View

A GSI map showing green infrastructure in Philadelphia. The green dots represent public sites and the blue dots represent private project sites. | Image: Philadelphia Water Department
“Despite significant efforts over the past decade, Philadelphia’s wastewater system still pours billions of gallons of pollution into local waterways,” said Rumpler. “While eschewing a comprehensive overhaul of the conventional sewage system, the City’s plan made bold commitments to green infrastructure that aim to restore some of nature’s capacity to absorb stormwater before it overwhelms sewers or pollutes rivers with runoff.”
However, Rumpler noted that the average volume of CSOs has gone down relative to precipitation. “In the 13 years from 2010 to 2022. CSOs per inch of precipitation declined from a rolling 3-year average of roughly 333 million gallons to about 273 million gallons—a decrease of about 18 percent.” He calls on the City to take measures to dramatically reduce the number and volume of CSOs, including rapid deployment of green infrastructure to capture stormwater that causes combined overflows.
Research on quantifying the effectiveness of GSI to filter nutrients and pollutants is mixed, depending, in part, on modeling assumptions and other variables. Keeping nutrients and pollutants out of the runoff to begin with is more effective than trying to filter them out on the way to a sewer or waterway. A study from Villanova University, published in the August 2024 issue of the Journal of Hydrology, examined the effectiveness of GSI that the PWD installed along Tookany-Tacony/Frankford Creek. The authors concluded, “The results demonstrate the complexity in assessing urban streams and their interactions with urban runoff and GSI, and the stochastic nature of what GSI receives.
“While many studies have shown the benefits of GSI to improve runoff retention, water quality, and CSO releases, the influence of GSI on urban hydrographs in larger watersheds in large cities such as Philadelphia has been less clear. GSI is typically designed to target smaller, more frequent storms, and Green City, Clean Waters (GCCW) aims to manage the first inch of stormwater on site. As the first stormwater control plan to rely so heavily on GSI, GCCW has the potential to serve as a guideline for future urban stormwater management.”
GSI’s ability to capture runoff from all-but-severe storms shows promise. A 20-year study on the benefits of a rain garden installed at Villanova in 2001 determined that it “was found to manage 86.2 percent of all rainfall in its watershed.”
GSI measures have limits when it comes to mitigating sever storms. “They are designed to capture the average storm, which should account for most of the rain that falls in a year,” said Dr. Laura Toran, professor of hydrology at Temple University’s College of Science and Technology. “If designed well, GSI is good at delaying and reducing stormwater runoff. We should focus our efforts on designing and monitoring basins to ensure that they are doing that.”






Many of my technical communication students at Temple University’s College of Engineering are Civil and Environmental Engineering majors who choose green infrastructure–related topics for their major course papers. David Bell’s incisive and circumspect Hidden City article will henceforth be my recommended initial reading for all these students.