It’s a bit hidden, but it’s there. Heading up Germantown Avenue in North Philadelphia, on the right just after the intersection with Diamond Street, something suddenly breaks up the flow of flat facades of brown-and-beige rowhouses. An old marquee juts out over the sidewalk of a triple-wide building and catches the eye, which then drifts to beautiful ornamentation elsewhere: colorful little pendants and terra cotta flourishes tucked into corners and a crowning, decorative pediment containing a grotesque face, its mouth agape.
What is this thing? Peer closer and the faded outlines and empty lightbulb sockets of a sign above the marquee spell it out for you. It’s the Diamond, a century-old theater whose further existence remains in question, according to those who have come to love it.
Call Andy Molholt the leader of that crowd. By day, the Kensington resident is a successful musician, known for his work as guitarist for indie-rock outfit Speedy Ortiz and previously Laser Background. Yet, in his spare time, Molholt has gained an interest in historic preservation, particularly of Philadelphia’s diverse and endangered old-time movie theaters, whose extant numbers have been in decline since their heyday in the first half of the 20th century.
According to a 2011 article by architect Shawn Evans on PhillyHistory.org’s blog, as of 1932 the city had at least 275 movie theaters of various sizes–from grand Center City venues offering thousands of seats to tiny neighborhood nickelodeons. However, by 2013, as Rachel Hildebrandt wrote previously for Hidden City, only half that number remained and only a handful still in use as theaters.
Since then, Molholt has watched as more were razed, most notably Chestnut Street’s Boyd Theater, which, until its demolition in 2015, was Center City’s last great movie palace. “It was an absolute crime that the place was destroyed,” Molholt said.
The downward trend line has made Molholt nervous, particularly for the theater in his neck of the woods, the Diamond. Built circa 1922, the building made it about 50 years as a theater. At one point its name was changed to Teatro Puerto Rico to cater to new arrivals to the city from the Caribbean island, before converting more recently into a house of worship. Last year a for sale sign went up above the old theater’s marquee. Word came down that it was being eyed as a potential demo-and-redevelop job by a prospective buyer.
The threat transformed Molholt from admirer to activist. Teaming up with experienced preservationists, namely The Keeping Society of Philadelphia’s Oscar Beisert, the building has now been nominated for listing on Philadelphia’s Register of Historic Places, which would offer legal protection against the demolition or alteration of the building’s facade. With hearings due this fall, the race to protect the Diamond Theater is on.
A Theater for Every Neighborhood

The Bijou Theater at 8th and Arch Streets circa 1890s. | Photo courtesy of The Athenaeum of Philadelphia
If you grew up like Molholt, a native of suburban Hatfield in Montgomery County, your memories of going to the movies probably involved driving to the one or two area multiplexes: big theaters with multiple screens showing most of the latest major movie releases. If, like Molholt, you relocated to the city, you may have also learned to love arthouse theaters like the Ritz. Yet, if you dig just a little deeper, you come to learn just how truly rich the city’s theater landscape once was.
The craze began in December 1895 when the Lumière brothers of France, whose name appropriately translates to “light,” are typically credited with orchestrating the first public screening of a motion picture using their invention, the Cinematograph, in Paris. In his 2011 piece for PhillyHistory.org, Evans noted that moving pictures debuted in Philadelphia around the same time, first appearing at the Bijou Theatre (1889-1967) near 8th and Race Streets. Indeed, an August 1896 advertisement in The Philadelphia Times touted the Cinematographe at the Bijou and offered up an already robust daily schedule of viewings, including the somewhat quizzically titled films Arrival of the Mail Train, The Gardener and the Bad Boy, and The Instantaneous Sausage Machine. “The most marvelous life-motion picture projector ever seen,” the ad nevertheless insisted. “Showing the most interesting, most life-like, and the funniest pictures ever exhibited in this country.”

The former Bijou Theater, now named New Garden Theater, in 1938. | Photo courtesy of The Athenaeum of Philadelphia
In his research Evans noted that the Bijou sat in the heart of what was then a theater district and showcased “brief, silent experiments of the moving image.” While the theater had seating for 1,200 people, smaller, nickelodeon theaters came to dominate over the next two decades, taking their name from the common five-cent cost of admission. More than 130 were built by 1917, but gave way to more robust theaters as the release of full-length films ramped up that decade, requiring comfortable theaters for larger audiences. With “screen time” during that era of course limited to movie houses, hundreds more were constructed in all parts of Philadelphia into the early 1930s to cater to public demand. “The finest of the movie palaces were located in Center City, although many were built in the outlying neighborhoods,” Evans observed.
In a recent email, Hildebrandt said the theaters quickly began playing an important role in American life and had deep and lasting cultural impacts. “The theater was a type of third space, and it thrived as a place for folks to gather and be,” Hildebrandt noted. “It also had a lot of influence on society. I’m reading a book now that traces fashion trends to their origins. Film was key in introducing Americans to the ‘French girl’ aesthetic, for example.”
Birth of the Diamond
In the early 1920s, moving pictures would reach a little corner of North Philadelphia. There in 1922, a few blocks northeast of what is now SEPTA’s Temple University train station, the Cohocksink Amusement Company purchased a series of dwellings at 2117 to 2123 Germantown Avenue to clear the way for what would become the Diamond Theater, according to research assembled by Beisert for the building’s historic nomination.
Shortly thereafter, the project flipped from Cohocksink to The Diamond Amusement Company, which oversaw construction between July 1922 and January 1923. The name attached was Michael “Mike” Lessy, a Russian-Jewish immigrant who also operated the Collingswood Theater in New Jersey and the Standard Theater in Camden, as well as a Aurora Theater just opposite of the Diamond, which was known to have associations with Universal Pictures. Architecture firm Neubauer & Supowitz was hired to design the building. In the nomination Beisert concluded that it was likely that David Supowitz, a “prolific Jewish architect and designer of theater buildings in the Philadelphia region” who primarily designed the Diamond.

The auditorium of the Diamond Theater. Date unknown. | Photo courtesy of The Athenaeum of Philadelphia
Beisert added that the building’s design was very much in line with the times. Constructed of brick, terra cotta, and steel, its Classical Revival facade matched the Georgian, Greek Revival, and Palladian styles of theaters like the Chestnut Street, Walnut Street, and Fox theaters. Beisert particularly noted a pair of arched, second-story windows that originally flanked the Diamond’s marquee before later being mostly infilled. “With the projecting iron balustrades, these balconies gave the building a sense of importance, as though one of the actors might come out and wave to a crowd on Germantown Avenue,” Beisert waxed.
The theater’s roughly 960 seats was on par with most further-flung theaters of that time, representative of “a neighborhood or small-town theater building type,” Beisert wrote. However, its interior space was well-appointed, with Lessy ordering renovations as early as 1926 and adding central air in 1935. “The early interior included a central screen that looked very much like an elaborate stage that was flanked by speakers set in frames that mimicked Palladian windows,” Beisert explained.
Changing Times

The Mastbaum Theater at 20th and Market Streets. Date unknown. | Photo courtesy of The Athenaeum of Philadelphia
The end of this heyday of grand theaters snuck up quickly, particularly as the introduction of “the talkies” killed off silent films and the need for more robust spaces such as orchestra pits. “For the most part, the era of these elaborate buildings was over even before the Great Depression began,” Evans wrote, adding the economic cataclysm only steepened the trend.
Perhaps most emblematic was the Mastbaum Theater, a large, 4,700-seat theater at 20th and Market Streets that was built in 1929 and torn down just 29 years later. Many theaters of all sizes would follow, particularly as technological and sociological trends converged in the mid-20th century. “Theaters were ubiquitous from roughly 1890 until the 1960s, when television became accessible to middle class families,” Hildebrandt explained. “In addition to TV, urban neighborhoods changed as a result of deindustrialization and white flight to the suburbs. Considering this, many held on longer than one might expect.”
By the time her 2013 article was published, after Hildebrandt performed a full accounting of the city’s past and present movie houses, she concluded that of an original list of nearly 400 theaters just 135 remained. Very few of these were on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places, and, in the decade since, several more have met their end, including the Bluebird, Columbia, Girard, Poplar, Royal, and Strand theaters to name a few. Even still, some hold on, particularly in historic corridors outside of Center City where they are often “masked by modernization and hidden in plain sight,” Hildebrandt said.
Enter the Diamond. According to Beisert, the theater existed in its original form until about 1950, when it began to transform along with the greater neighborhood, as Puerto Rican immigrants moved in following World War II. Lessy, the original proprietor, died in 1948. Two years later, Josephine Trilla applied for permits to put up signage advertising the Diamante (Spanish for diamond) Theater. A change in ownership became official in 1960 when Felix Rodriguez purchased the property from Lessy’s estate and shortly thereafter renamed it the Teatro Puerto Rico. It appears the venue may have served as somewhat of a neighborhood institution: a June 1964 article published by the Philadelphia Inquirer laid out the trials and tribulations of the surrounding community and featured a photograph of the theater. “Spanish language films are featured at Teatro Puerto Rico on Germantown Avenue near 6th and Diamond Streets in the heart of the Puerto Rican settlement,” the caption noted. Beisert also discovered in his research its significance to Puerto Rican residents as a place of “community and social engagement” and as one of the “few Spanish language” theaters in the city.
Its history since then is a bit hazier. Beisert found that its run as Teatro Puerto Rico appeared to cease in 1975. 36 years then passed until a church, The Iglesia Ministerio Maranatha Pentecostal, purchased the property in 2011, apparently worshipping there until a few years ago. Newspaper records suggest a record shop and nuisance bar may have operated at the address prior to the church’s ownership, although it is unclear whether such functions utilized the actual theater space. The property historically included two smaller shops and storefronts flanking the main entrance.

The former Diamond Theater, since renamed Teatro Puerto Rico, circa 1960s. | Photo courtesy of The Athenaeum of Philadelphia
By the early 2000s, Google Street View images show a shuttered and nameless facade that persisted until at least 2012, followed by some restoration work and signage denoting the church’s occupancy by 2014. Evidence of upkeep continued until the for sale sign went up sometime in 2023. That is when Molholt sprang into action.
The musician’s interest in theaters grew out of his appreciation for interesting, creative spaces. In his 20s, Molholt lived in a DIY warehouse in Philadelphia that put on music shows. Once he stumbled upon the historical theaters dotting the city’s landscape, he dreamed of perhaps one day converting one into a proper venue. Then he witnessed the destruction of several favorites, including the 2021 demolition of the Richmond Theater in Port Richmond and The Strand at 12th Street and Girard Avenue the same year. This prompted Molholt to leave a message several years ago with the owner of the Diamond Theater, which City records currently still list as the church, expressing his appreciation for the building and asking for them to call him before any potential sale was made public. When the theater was placed on the market, Molholt toured the building and found it in decent condition. Both the interior and exterior have undergone significant renovations over time that have removed or at least hidden many of the original architectural details, but overall the building remains structurally sound, he said. Molholt also got in touch with the selling agent and came to understand that a New York investment firm was eyeing the property “to destroy it and turn it into condos.”
Unable to swing financing for the building himself, Molholt turned to Beisert, whom he’d met during an earlier protest of the demolition of another historic building. Molholt established a crowd-funding a campaign to allow Beisert to research and write the historic nomination for the Diamond, aiming to spare it from a fate of demolition regardless of who takes ownership.
On one hand, Molholt is cognizant of not wanting to bigfoot long-time residents. However, he also believes in the value of such buildings, both for their original history and continued importance as the city evolved. “The current owner has had it for a decade and probably lived in that area when it was at its worst,” he said. “But a bunch of beautiful old buildings getting destroyed and turned into soulless condos that no one can afford isn’t exactly good for the neighborhood either.”
The building’s fate potentially hangs in the balance as the Philadelphia Historical Commission considers the historic designation application this fall. On Wednesday, October 16, the Historical Commission’s Committee on Historic Designation voted to recommend that the building satisfies criteria for listing. However, the final decision will fall to the full Historical Commission, which is currently scheduled to consider the application at a Nov. 8 meeting. As someone who’s toured the country and played to audiences in spaces not unlike that of the Diamond, Molholt remains hopeful. “On a recent tour I had the pleasure of playing six or seven old, beautiful theaters that were movie palaces that have been converted into live music spots,” Molholt said. “The fate of all these doesn’t have to be condos.”





Make it a theater again, show old and new movies make it a historical experience it’s a landmark deserving Respect, and real representation & resurrection. Thank you from a 50 yr old Philadelphian.
I am not familiar with the Strand theater at 12th & Girard. However, there was a Strand theater at Germantown and Venango, a block from Broad & Erie. My family had a business diagonally across from it. It became a parking lot in the early 70s.
In the ’50’s I saw The Snows of Kilimamjaro at the Diamond. On the west side of 6th St. was Dawn Donuts and the Good & Plenty candy factory. At the Germantown Ave. Strand I saw Suddenly, staring Frank Sinatra as a presidential assassin. I was in the Astor at Franklin & Girard, mentioned by Bill Cosby. The Girard lasted a long time, its demolition documented by photos. At the crown jewel of theaters, the Mastbaum, among a crowd of raving juvenile maniacs, I saw Fess Parker and Buddy Epson in costume at the premiere of Davy Crockett, King of the Wild Frontier. Also WW II hero Audie Murphy at the premiere of To Hell and Back. His array of decorations was stolen from a window at Wanamakers.
I remember when we were kids in the 1950’s, my dad was driving us to that neighborhood to get freshly made donuts/soft pretzels from a factory across the street. I remembered the theater since it was showing Spanish films. Never saw that before; only German films at the Felton and also at the Crest on Monday/Tuesday nights.
We lived in the area and that was our hang out almost everyday, lots of good childhood memories in the 80s Puerto Rico theater