ZBA Delays Decision On Developer’s Demolition Plan For Hoa Binh Plaza

 

Hoa Binh Plaza, or “Peace Plaza,” at 16th Street and Washington Avenue has been a fixture of the Vietnamese and Cambodian communities west of of Broad Street since 1990. Local real estate developer Streamline seeks a zoning variance to raze the shopping complex and build 44 town houses, duplexes, and apartment units. | Photo: Michael Bixler

The struggle over the fate of Hoa Binh Plaza at 16th Street and Washington Avenue was scheduled to be resolved this morning at the Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA). The plaza’s prospective buyer, local real estate developer Streamline, seeks approval to demolish the decades-old strip mall of Asian retail businesses and erect 44 townhouses and apartments. Doing so along this industrial corridor would require a zoning variance, hence the scheduled appeal.

During the meeting, several grassroots organizations, including VietLead and Asian Americans United, staged a protest in front of City offices at 1515 Arch Street. Many of the several dozen participants carried signs reading “Keep our communities rooted” and “Development without displacement.”

Upstairs in the 18th floor hearing room, representatives from the organizations were on hand to speak in opposition and to deliver a petition with over 14,000 signatures protesting the demolition. The group soon discovered they would need to wait for another day to be heard. When the ZBA, led by acting chairman Confesor Plaza, began hearing requests for continuances, one came from an attorney for Streamline, Dawn Tancredi, for the Hoa Binh Plaza project.

It’s not unusual for any party in a zoning dispute to ask for a delay. What ensued in this case demonstrated both a new level of struggle in the old versus new fight over gentrification and a seemingly new concern expressed by the City’s Department of Planning and Development.

Tancredi explained that Streamline had made changes to the plan, received an amended refusal on July 8, and needed time to update their presentation.

In that latest refusal, the Planning Commission’s opposition seemed to go beyond the basic nuts and bolts of zoning, and expressed concern for the potential loss of the plaza and its businesses, which have been a community hub for Asian immigrants in South Philadelphia since 1990.

The Planning Commission’s attorney noted that most of the variance requests that are made to the Commission are delegated to the executive director, but “because of the unique circumstances and the history of this particular site, a decision was made to bring this variance request to the full commission.”

At first, Nancy Nguyen of VietLead and Madeleine Shikomba of the North of Washington Avenue Coalition objected to the continuance, citing the dozens of area residents and business owners who took time off to attend the hearing and the hardship a return visit would cause them. When acting chairman Plaza recommended that the developer use the period of the continuance to meet and negotiate with community groups, they relented. Nguyen pressed the ZBA to receive the petition, but it was declined.

The Planning Commission’s attorney noted that any subsequent changes that Streamline might make in response to community input would necessitate another review by the City. He explained that the Planning Commission opposition still stands, unless amended plans are presented to them.

The ZBA approved the continuance and, owing to the volume of attendees, promised a date that would be devoted solely to this project.

About the author

Kimberly Haas is a staff writer for Hidden City Daily. She is a long time radio journalist, both nationally and locally with WHYY and WXPN. In particular, she enjoys covering Philadelphia’s neighborhoods, culture and history, as well as urban sustainability and public policy, in both print and audio.



3 Comments


  1. People at the zba, hungry developers that carry big goons (aka lawyers) are the main cause of these injustices, HOW LONG UNTILL THIS CORRUPTION GETS COMPLETELY EXPOSED?
    “Extending” the “hearing” process ONLY HELPS DEVELOPERS/LAWYERS and the zba knows it perfectly. 758 n. Uber st. Philadelphia pa 19130 was a similar case were oRphanitas was the lawyer, he was in the room when the case was first presented, knowing that many members of the community were there and that we have had defeated similar peojects o the block he walked away but zba had no penalty for him or his boss, WHAT WOULD HAVE HAPPENED IF NO ONE FROM THE COMMUNITY HAD SHOWN UP? The Zba would have given the case to them! Well… that’s exactly what happened almost a year later, want to know more facts about this case? 267 970 1580.
    THE ZBA, AS MOST OF THE ENTITIES THAT HOLD POWER IN THIS CITY, IS CORRUPT!!

  2. Countless irreplaceable, beautiful, historical buildings are being lost every year in this city (since we have essentially no functioning historical commission) but you’re telling me that PEOPLE ARE FIGHTING TO SAVE A STRIP MALL ?!?!?!
    This city is insane…

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
Historic Maritime Landmark Under Threat After Construction Mishap

Historic Maritime Landmark Under Threat After Construction Mishap

August 15, 2019  |  News

Deferred maintenance and a construction error endangers Edward Corner warehouse, one of the waterfront's last prominent reminders of Philadelphia's shipping history. Starr Herr Cardillo has the details > more

In Northeast Philadelphia, A Rich History Of Train Tracks And Acquisitions

In Northeast Philadelphia, A Rich History Of Train Tracks And Acquisitions

August 13, 2019  |  Vantage

Ed Duffy give us a panoramic view of railroad history in Northeast Philadelphia with this longform essay > more

Eastern State Penitentiary Illuminates “Hidden Lives” Of The Incarcerated

Eastern State Penitentiary Illuminates “Hidden Lives” Of The Incarcerated

August 9, 2019  |  News

"Hidden Lives Illuminated," an animated film project created by inmates of SCI Chester, debuts at Eastern State Penitentiary on August 15. Kimberly Haas went inside the state prison to speak with the incarcerated artists > more

Rittenhouse SoundWorks Keeps The Tune Ups Coming In Old Auto Garage

Rittenhouse SoundWorks Keeps The Tune Ups Coming In Old Auto Garage

August 7, 2019  |  Vantage

A Germantown couple bet big on adaptive reuse when they converted an old garage into a full-service recording studio in 2014. Today, they are sought out by musicians from around the globe. Stacia Friedman has the story > more

In Germantown, Saving A Neighborhood's Character One Renovation At A Time

In Germantown, Saving A Neighborhood’s Character One Renovation At A Time

August 2, 2019  |  Vantage

Emily Birdie Busch profiles nine renovation projects in Germantown that are keeping the neighborhood's architectural history within view > more

Thunderbird Lodge Museum Connects Arts & Crafts Movement With Utopian Community

Thunderbird Lodge Museum Connects Arts & Crafts Movement With Utopian Community

July 29, 2019  |  Walk the Walk

Joe Brin takes use out to Rose Valley, Pennsylvania where a new house museum puts the Arts and Crafts movement front and center > more