Examining Class And Racial Dynamics On The Anniversary Of The 1918 Riots In South Philadelphia

 

This clip from the July 30, 1918 edition of the Evening Public Ledger shows Adella Bond, an African American woman who became the target of a white mob for buying a home on Ellsworth Street. A riot broke out across South Philadelphia after Bond defended herself from roughly 100 men surrounding her home. | Image courtesy of Library of Congress, Chronicling America

We are living in an era of degrading racial norms. President Donald Trump’s tweets and statements regularly use defamatory language to describe people of color both in our nation and abroad. According to FBI statistics, hate crimes based on race, ethnicity, and ancestry increased 18.4% from 2016 to 2017, the last year for which statistics are available.

Between the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 1920s, Philadelphia experienced similar escalations in both discrimination and racial violence. In fact, one of the worst episodes of racial violence in the city’s history took place exactly 101 years ago. To understand the context of the events of July 26-31, 1918, it helps to examine the early lives of two of Philadelphia’s most noteworthy African American women.

World-renowned singer Marian Anderson (1897-1993) was born in South Philadelphia during an era of relative racial peace in Philadelphia. At the turn to the 20th century, the city’s black population was fairly small (only about 60,000 people in a city of over 1.2 million residents) and led by an educated, intellectually engaged elite that had coalesced in the late 18th century. Members of this community attended the venerable Institute for Colored Youth at 9th and Bainbridge Streets, mixed within the ranks of the exclusive black social clubs, and frequented restaurants and theaters alongside white Philadelphians.

Marian Anderson at 19-years-old in 1915. | Image courtesy of Penn Libraries, Rare Book & Manuscript Collections 

The Anderson family was not of this ilk. Like many poor black Philadelphians, her grandparents had been enslaved and her parents were recent migrants from the South. Although Marian’s mother Anna had been a teacher in Virginia, she was unable to find work in her profession once she came to Philadelphia. In spite of her education, she took in laundry and worked in a tobacco factory. Marian’s father, John, shoveled coal and did odd jobs for the Pennsylvania Railroad.

John was also a church officer with Union Baptist Church, proud that his daughter was able to join the choir at the age of six. Known as the “baby contralto,” Anderson was soon invited to sing at varied events and gatherings, thus bringing in a much-needed bit of money. Her budding talent also gave the family a sense of specialness within their community—albeit a less elevated community than that of their wealthier and more established African American peers.

Sadie Tanner Mossell Alexander (1898-1989) was born a year after Anderson. The extended Tanner Mossell family epitomized Philadelphia’s black elite. Her family tree includes the painter Henry Ossawa Tanner. Her father, Aaron Mossell, was the first African American to attend the University of Pennsylvania’s Law School and her uncle, Nathan Mossell, was Penn’s first black medical school graduate.

After earning a BA from the University of Pennsylvania’s School of Education in 1918, she stayed on at Penn to become the second African American woman in the country to earn a PhD. She married attorney Roy Pace Alexander, another descendent of the black aristocracy. In 1927, Mossell became the first black female University of Pennsylvania Law School graduate and the first admitted to the Pennsylvania Bar.

In order to understand a key turning point in the life of Marian Anderson, we must turn to the work of the young scholar, Sadie T. Mossell. Her thesis written in pursuit of a master’s in economics was entitled The Standard of Living Among One Hundred Negro Migrant Families in Philadelphia. Completed in 1919, her research documented the quickly shifting racial dynamics that existed in early 20th century Philadelphia.

Sadie Tanner Mossell Alexander, the second African American woman in the U.S. to earn a PhD, was a member of Delta Sigma Theta, the University of Pennsylvania’s first black sorority. Left to right: (front) Virginia Margaret Alexander, Julia Mae Polk, Sadie Tanner Mossell, (back) Anna R. Johnson, Nellie Rathbone Bright, Pauline Alice Young. | Image courtesy of University of Pennsylvania, Archives & Records Center

During the early years of Marian Anderson’s life, her family lived in several South Philadelphia locales, neighborhoods that were characterized by a mix of African American, Jewish, Irish, and Italian residents. Although racial tensions surely existed, these diverse communities of recent arrivals to the city struggled and strived in proximity and generally in peace. Anderson attended the integrated Stanton Grammar School at 17th and Christian Streets throughout her childhood and early adolescence.

But, as Mossell explains, the steep influx of Southern migrants during the era of the Great War changed the racial mood of the city. As European immigration screeched to a halt, uneducated, unskilled black families were lured to Philadelphia as to other industrial cities of the North. Philadelphia’s black population skyrocketed, causing consternation among the city’s white residents. The increase was particularly steep from 1916-1918 when an estimated 150 black migrants arrived from the South each week.

Finding a place to live became the biggest challenge for the new arrivals. In her thesis Mossell describes attitudes toward the black migrant:“If we may judge the attitude of the whites by their efforts to segregate him, it would seem that he was highly unweclome. The housing problem was itself a result of the determination on the part of the white people that the migrant should live only in that part of the city in which Negroes had previously lived. Vacant houses in other sections were not for rent or sale to the Negroes.

The black elite, who had become known as the Old Philadelphians or OPs, were also wary of the new arrivals who posed an enormous threat to their comfortable, genteel way of life. According to Mossell, “The increase in Negro population greatly stimulated the movement….to segregate children in schools. Also, such social privileges as the service of eating houses and the attending of white churches and theaters by Negroes, were practically withdrawn after the influx of Negro migrants into Philadelphia.”

It is in this context that we must understand a key turning point young Anderson’s life, as illustrated in the video below. With the encouragement of her community, in 1914 Anderson walked from her South Philadelphia home to the Philadelphia Musical Academy at 1617 Spruce Street–later The Garden Restaurant and now a condominium.

Video courtesy of Making History Productions.

Nearly five decades later, Anderson still sharply recalled the sting of this rejection. Given the Philadelphia of her early years, she claimed that this was when she first experienced a “painful realization of what it meant to be a Negro.”

Unfortunately, Adella Bond learned about the change in more dramatic fashion. In 1918, she bought a home at 2936 Ellsworth Street. Mossell describes Bond as “a colored probation officer of the Municipal Court, a woman of refinement and training and an old citizen of Philadelphia.” In this new racially-hardened city, however, being a member of the “OP” class did not insulate blacks from anti-migrant anger.

On July 26, 1918, a crowd of roughly 100 white men and boys, many of them armed, congregated in front of Bond’s new home. After a rock was thrown through her parlor window, she shot a rifle through her second story window to alert the police. Bond was arrested and several days of rioting ensued. Large swaths of the area from Dickinson Street to Washington Avenue and 23rd to 30th Streets were engulfed in violence. A police officer was shot by a black man. Subsequently, two black men were killed while in police custody. 60 blacks and three whites were arrested during the days of violence. Many witnesses, however, thought the police exacerbated the situation by antagonizing the black men and protecting the whites. Overall, four people died, hundreds were injured, and black neighborhoods were severely damaged. It was the first race riot the city had experienced since 1871.

During the years of the First World War, racial attitudes in Philadelphia had changed. Increased hostility and discrimination affected not only struggling blacks like the Andersons, but also members of the established black elite like the Alexanders. As Mossell describes in her thesis, “As in the case of the probation officer (Adella Bond) so in numerous other occurrences, the colored people of every class received harsh treatment at the hands of the white public.” No wonder Anderson chose to leave the city to pursue her career; and no wonder that Alexander chose to stay, continuing to fight for civil rights as an attorney and early member of Philadelphia’s Commission on Human Relations.

About the author

Amy Cohen spent 20 years as a social studies teacher, most recently at Masterman. She is currently the Director of Education at History Making Productions where she develops educational materials to accompany documentaries about the Philadelphia region. Amy was born and raised in Center City long before the era of sidewalk cafes and pop up beer gardens. She now lives in West Mount Airy with her husband—also a lifelong Philadelphian—and their two daughters.



12 Comments


  1. William C Jamieson

    You are imputing your political bias into this article. I usually enjoy HIdden City Philadelphia, not this time. Leave Donald Trump out of your story. What evidence do you have that he is racist? He has done more for people of color than our last President ever did. He is maligned by the liberal press all the time.

    • I agree with Mr. Jamieson. This was a very interesting and well researched article, but the Donald Trump dig was gratuitous. I’m surprised that the editors of Hidden City allowed this. I will have to reconsider making donations if this site begins to take more of a political slant.

      • The addition of facts and context adds value to lessons learned from the past and can be applied towards action today. If Hidden City publishes more quality content like this piece I’ll have to consider raising my donations!

    • What evidence Do you have that quantitatively shows your classroom….? You don’t because your claim is at best a subject opinion. I believe the authors intent is draw a parallel to what happened 101 years ago. Basic FBI statistics presented in the opening are factual and do correlate to the most current president, which has made racist claims. To deny that presidential power over society via speech and social mannerisms doesn’t impact the psyche of our population would imply that the president is powerless. Which I doubt anyone believes. So if you think that this author needs to actually support you with evidence, than you need to get your head out of your a$$ and listen to your leadership yourself.

    • You Trump supporters really make me sick. He is a racist, a flaming narcissist, an ego centric miserable human being. Done more for Blacks, oh please give me a break. Trump hates blacks, Hispanics and everybody who isn’t him. Trump is without a doubt the biggest disaster that ever happened to this country.

    • Mr. Jamieson I couldn’t agree more. To the liberals ready to attack me, I am a gay man, moderate who votes based on candidate not party. It is an interesting story but has nothing to do with Trump. Both sides aren’t helping but do not blame the President; as if democrats are not responsible, at least partly.

      Examples:
      – Maxine Waters calling on the public to harass republicans
      – protestors at Mitch McConnell’s house last night saying they wanted to kill him
      – Joe Biden & Corey Booker making statements about a desire to assault the President
      – mobs of ANTIFA thugs roaming cities,violently assaulting anyone who isn’t in line with leftist extremism, including 2 hispanic marines in OUR OWN CITY- disgraceful.
      – The tragedies this weekend:

      The left is fixated on El Paso, despite his motives being a mix of socialism and extremely nationalistic/fringe views that are not in line with the president’s. It is A cowardly crime just like what happen(s) in Dayton, or Chicago where nearly 50 were shot over the weekend.I agree laws should be changed, but their faux outrage is to pin this tragedy against Trump… notice how the media DROPPED the Dayton story when it came out he was a far-left extremist and Liz Warren supporter? And the democrats don’t care about Chicago bc it will always be dark blue (and coincidentally is almost impossible to own a firearm.) Get real Amy!

    • I think the country is finished litigating whether donald trump is a racist. He is. Next issue…

  2. vote trump keep usa white

  3. Instead of reacting with shame and disgust at the 1918 riots people are reacting to the Trump reference. Hitler decried kristallnacht, we are experiencing a kristallnacht of our own. Words and attudes matter. Wake up, please.

  4. @ Kyle, Iliveina,and Jim,
    The Russian bots are everywhere. Please keep this in mind…everytime you acknowledge them in comments everywhere, they win a little. Everyone knows that Trump supporters can’t read…hell, Trump can’t read. Please start ignoring the bots in comment sections. If we all keep this in mind, they can’t win…they’ll just be arguing with and high fiving each other.

    Ignore, ignore, ignore.

Recent Posts
Renovations At William Way Look To The Future While Preserving The Past

Renovations At William Way Look To The Future While Preserving The Past

September 16, 2019  |  Architecture, Preservation

Big changes are in the works for William Way Community Center thanks to a $1 million grant from the Commonwealth's Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program. Stacia Friedman has the details > more

Final Plans To Transfer Philadelphia History Museum Collection To Drexel University Unveiled

Final Plans To Transfer Philadelphia History Museum Collection To Drexel University Unveiled

September 12, 2019  |  City Life, History

The Philadelphia History Museum is officially dead. The large collection of beloved city artifacts will be transferred to Drexel University. Kimberly Haas has the news > more

Hidden City Daily Celebrates Eight Years Of Publishing

Hidden City Daily Celebrates Eight Years Of Publishing

September 11, 2019  |  City Life

September marks Hidden City Daily's 8th year of publishing. To toast the occasion we look back at the past 12 months with a curated list of our top 15 stories. > more

Settlement Houses: Doing Good In The Neighborhood

Settlement Houses: Doing Good In The Neighborhood

September 9, 2019  |  History

Stacia Friedman takes a look at Philadelphia's long tradition of providing social welfare and education through settlement houses, some of which still serve communities today > more

Until Death Do Us Part: An Ode To Philadelphia Book Collecting

Until Death Do Us Part: An Ode To Philadelphia Book Collecting

September 6, 2019  |  History

In celebration of National Read A Book Day, Mickey Herr dives deep into the stacks at some of Philadelphia's most historic and obscure libraries > more

Bootleggers & Back Alley Bars: Philadelphia During Prohibition A City

Bootleggers & Back Alley Bars: Philadelphia During Prohibition A City “Soaked In Alcohol”

September 4, 2019  |  History

Speakeasies are all the rage these days. The revival finds its roots in secret cocktail lounges that opened after the 18th Amendment was ratified in 1920. Pennsylvania got a head start and outlawed alcohol in 1919. Amy Cohen takes a look back at Philadelphia during Prohibition on the 100-year anniversary of the ban > more