Developer Targets Asian Shopping Center In Next Battle For Washington Avenue

 

Hoa Binh Plaza, or “Peace Plaza,” at 16th Street and Washington Avenue has been a fixture of the Vietnamese and Cambodian communities west of of Broad Street since 1990. That could change soon if local real estate developer Streamline moves forward with plans to raze the shopping complex for a collection of town houses, duplexes, and apartment units. | Photo: Michael Bixler

Last night on Washington Avenue a multi-lingual, intergenerational crowd of about 60 people gathered in the back dining room of Huong Tram Restaurant in the Hoa Binh Plaza, intent of making themselves heard by their City Councilman Kenyatta Johnson. The issue was the proposed razing of the small 90s-era strip mall at 16th Street and the likely demise of the long-standing Asian-American businesses there.

While the property’s prospective buyer, Philly-based developer Streamline, eventually revealed its plans to build a large block of townhouses there, the business owners related how the current owners and the developer have kept them in the dark. “There hasn’t been anyone talking to us,” claimed Mr. Toan, the restaurant’s owner through a translator. “We’ve been forced into a dead end, passively waiting for the end.”

Washington Avenue has seen numerous transformations, from its 19th century history as a manufacturing corridor, and then morphing into a mix of suppliers to the building trades in the second half of the 20th century. As the millennium approached, southeast Asian immigrant communities arrived, finding commercial and residential properties that were cheaper and more plentiful than in Chinatown.

The next wave is now arriving, as the hot neighborhoods of Point Breeze to the south, Graduate Hospital to the north, and East Passyunk and Bella Vista are expanding and butting up against Washington Avenue. It’s driving up real estate prices and putting pressure on the long-standing businesses like the building supply stores and auto repair shops that line the avenue. The older businesses are noisy and often unsightly–not a harmonious mix for the residents of the new townhouses.

And converting to residential not only affects those parcels being developed, but also draws the requisite cafes and shops catering to the new residents, which ultimately pushes out existing small businesses.

That’s the scenario playing out now at 16th and Washington, where Hoa Binh Plaza, or “Peace Plaza,” has housed southeast Asian businesses since it opened in 1990. As in several areas of the city, Streamline’s plans to raze the supermarket, bakery, and restaurant and construct two rows of townhouses, a handful of duplexes, and two multi-unit buildings seems to be a familiar turn of events with an inevitable outcome.

However, zoning might prevent it from being a given. Much of the eastern portion of Washington Avenue, from Front to Broad Streets, is zoned either residential, multi-family, or neighborhood commercial mixed use, which allows for the intermingling of residential and commercial properties. But when you cross Broad Street going west, the zoning is almost entirely industrial, with residential use prohibited.

A merchant at Hoa Binh Plaza showing his merchandise in 1991, a year after the shopping center opened. | Image courtesy of Temple University Libraries, Special Collections Research Center

Several of the Hoa Binh Plaza business owners and their supporters have drafted a petition opposing the development. They aim to deliver it to a Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA) hearing on July 24, at which Streamline is requesting a zoning variance to allow the construction of residential units. Co-sponsored by the community groups 18MR.org, Viet Lead, the Cambodian Association of Greater Philadelphia, and Soil Generation, the petition currently has over 10,000 of the 12,800 signatures they are seeking. 

At the meeting, Johnson listened quietly to the sometimes tearful testimonies, delivered in Vietnamese, Khmer, and English. Many spoke of the community that has been fostered by the plaza, dating back to when their grandparents came to the area as refugees. When given the floor, Johnson related how he’d grown up in the neighborhood and recalled his grandmother shopping at the Plaza’s Big 8 Supermarket. “I can’t support evicting all the tenants,” he said, promising to reach out to the developer and to the South of South Neighborhood Association (SOSNA) to find a solution.

Although Johnson stopped short of offering a concrete plan, the crowd appreciated his words. “Having him present was a step forward,” said Nancy Nguyen, executive director of Viet Lead.

While the petitioners hope to hold on to the status quo, SOSNA members have looked for compromise, perhaps sensing the futility of fighting the tidal wave of development that’s careening along Washington Avenue. “We want to support local businesses,” said Nolan Tully, a member of SOSNA’s board and zoning committee. “So we reached out to the developer about helping the businesses relocate, hopefully still in the area.”

But such actions can place them in conflicting situations: as the Registered Community Organization (RCO) for the area, SOSNA has a role to play in the zoning hearing process.

The Hoa Binh merchants, not convinced they could find replacement locations and also preferring to stay together, want to ask Streamline to alter its plans and add a strip of commercial tenants to the complex along the 16th Street side of the parcel. “We’re not trying to stop anyone from making money,” said Thomas Sinnison of Nam Son Bakery. “We just want a chance to stay in the neighborhood,” noting that at least one business has been there since 1991, the year after the plaza opened.

Sinnison’s suggestion of a mix of commercial and residential mirrors what’s been happening elsewhere along Washington Avenue. SOSNA holds up one in particular, at 2401 Washington, as a successful example of developers, neighbors, and the City working together. They drafted a Community Benefits Agreement (CBA), in which the developers offered neighborhood improvements, including a handful of affordable housing units, local hiring, bicycle infrastructure, and tree plantings. Councilman Johnson then introduced a rezoning bill for the property, which would eliminate the need for a ZBA hearing. Approval was held up at a City Council Rules Committee hearing last week when another neighborhood group wanted to weigh in and will now wait until Council returns from summer recess.

The lure of so many large parcels along Washington Avenue is drawing more and more developers to the area. “It’s moving at an extreme pace,” agreed Murray Spencer, another member of SOSNA’s board and zoning committee, noting that, after entering into its very first CBA barely 12 months ago, it’s already worked on two others. The puzzle now is how to meld SOSNA’s desire for compromise with the Hoa Binh businesses’ commitment to their past and present and the developer’s plans for the future.

About the author

Kimberly Haas is a staff writer for Hidden City Daily. She is a long time radio journalist, both nationally and locally with WHYY and WXPN. In particular, she enjoys covering Philadelphia’s neighborhoods, culture and history, as well as urban sustainability and public policy, in both print and audio.



2 Comments


  1. The resulting development type is problematic as well. Washington Avenue is a wide street capable of supporting a fixed guideway transit facility (i.e. a new trolley route from 49th/Woodland to Sugar House Loop via Columbus Blvd.) in the median. If redevelopment is going to occur, then Transit Oriented Development featuring density (ideally CMX 2.5 or CMX 3) should be built here.

  2. Hoa Bihn Plaza is on the very border of SOSNA’s boundaries. Aside from having a slick website, how did they get to be the primary arbiter of negotiation with real estate development entities for this parcel? Why have no other RCOs been involved that better represent the population of the adjacent communities?

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
Mütter Museum Goes Viral With New Influenza Pandemic Exhibition

Mütter Museum Goes Viral With New Influenza Pandemic Exhibition

September 23, 2019  |  City Life

The Mütter Museum of The College of Physicians of Philadelphia examines the Influenza Pandemic of 1918-19 with a multimedia exhibition, walking tours, and a chorus-led parade up Broad Street. Kimberly Haas has the story > more

Protected Jewelers Row Building Cited

Protected Jewelers Row Building Cited “Unsafe” By L&I On The Eve Of Toll Brothers Demolition

September 19, 2019  |  Development, Preservation

Last week the owner of a legally protected historic property on Jewelers Row was unexpectedly served multiple violations by the Department of Licenses and Inspections as suburban real estate developer Toll Brothers prepares to demolish five buildings next door. Starr Herr-Cardillo reports > more

Still Chugging Along: Exploring Philadelphia's Other Broad Street Station

Still Chugging Along: Exploring Philadelphia’s Other Broad Street Station

September 18, 2019  |  History

Ed Duffy dives deep into the origins of a litttle-known Neoclassical train station in North Philly > more

Renovations At William Way Look To The Future While Preserving The Past

Renovations At William Way Look To The Future While Preserving The Past

September 16, 2019  |  Architecture, Preservation

Big changes are in the works for William Way Community Center thanks to a $1 million grant from the Commonwealth's Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program. Stacia Friedman has the details > more

Final Plans To Transfer Philadelphia History Museum Collection To Drexel University Unveiled

Final Plans To Transfer Philadelphia History Museum Collection To Drexel University Unveiled

September 12, 2019  |  City Life, History

The Philadelphia History Museum is officially dead. The large collection of beloved city artifacts will be transferred to Drexel University. Kimberly Haas has the news > more

Hidden City Daily Celebrates Eight Years Of Publishing

Hidden City Daily Celebrates Eight Years Of Publishing

September 11, 2019  |  City Life

September marks Hidden City Daily's 8th year of publishing. To toast the occasion we look back at the past 12 months with a curated list of our top 15 stories. > more