A Field Guide To Demolition

 

Editor’s Note: A version of this story was published in the Winter 2017 issue of Extant, a publication of the Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia.

Development pressure on historic buildings in Philadelphia is primarily driven by developers’ desire to acquire large parcels of land for housing. Purchasing a single, sizable property allows them to build a number of units at once, reducing costs and eliminating the uncertainty of negotiating with multiple property owners. Unfortunately, the types of buildings sitting on those large parcels–churches, meeting halls, grand homes, workshops, and factories–are the very structures that define our neighborhoods’ visual character and historical context. Although a wide variety of buildings are being torn down across the city, patterns do emerge in certain areas. These pressures particular to each neighborhood should be taken into account by policymakers as they prioritize what to protect.


Neighborhood: University City/Powelton

Threatened Building Type: Large Victorian homes

Dynamic: Developers are targeting single-family homes on large lots, many of which were previously converted into multi-unit rentals. Although these properties are usually occupied and produce income, the robust market for rentals near Penn, Drexel, and University of the Sciences makes them worth more as tear-downs. The number of additional units that can be created is more than enough to make the numbers work. For example, a 25-unit building replaced a 10-unit building at both 4042-44 and 4046-48 Chestnut Street. The reduction of parking requirements in 2012 inadvertently made this approach more financially attractive to developers by reducing the cost per unit. A similar situation exists west of Broad Street adjacent to Temple University. 


Neighborhood: Graduate Hospital/Bella Vista

Threatened Building Type: 19th century churches

Dynamic: Residential South Philadelphia features blocks of row houses, with a sprinkle of schools and churches. While many of the schools have been repurposed, developers have targeted churches for demolition. The parcels they sit on are large enough for developers to include parking in the back–a tremendous plus in these parking-scarce areas. Although modest, the buildings are repositories for a great deal of these neighborhoods’ African-American heritage. The churches themselves are often willing sellers, as their congregations have been pushed out of the neighborhood by increasing real estate values. The Union Baptist Church where Marian Anderson learned to sing is perhaps the most prominent casualty. Churches of similar size have also been torn down in Fishtown, Fairmount, and Brewerytown. 


Neighborhood: Northern Liberties

Threatened Building Type: Workshops, factories, warehouses, garages

Dynamic: Much of the new construction in Northern Liberties was initially built on the neighborhood’s many vacant lots. As that supply dwindled, developers began purchasing and demolishing industrial buildings, some of which were still being used for light manufacturing, as was the case of the Pearl-Pressman Liberty printing company building at 5th and Popular. Although most buildings of this type have now been torn down or rehabbed, there are still several that remain, including Aircon Filter Company on Green Street and the former Fishtown Star building on 3rd Street and Girard Avenue. Now that so little developable land remains, former industrial buildings successfully repurposed a decade or two ago may also become vulnerable to demolition and more valuable for the large parcels they occupy.


Neighborhood: Center City

Threatened Building Type: Various

Dynamic: In most neighborhoods, a building that is handsome, historic, occupied, and in good condition would never be considered for demolition. Unfortunately, that is no longer true in highly desirable neighborhoods, and especially Center City, where land is worth the most. The critical thing for policymakers to consider isn’t so much the threat to a particular size or type of building, but rather the tremendous development pressure that exists across the board, which should give their efforts greater urgency. The recent examples above–and Jewelers Row, which remains endangered–show that no buildings in Center City can be assumed safe from demolition unless they are listed on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places.

Peter Woodall is the co-editor of Hidden City Daily. He is a graduate of the UC Berkeley School of Journalism, and a former newspaper reporter with the Biloxi Sun Herald and the Sacramento Bee. He worked as a producer for Radio Times with Marty Moss-Coane and wrote a column about neighborhood bars for PhiladelphiaWeekly.com.



3 Comments


  1. The Mt. Olive A.M.E. was at 19th and Fitzwater, not 18th.

  2. Thank you for a concise and provocative analysis, where the pictures add a thousand words. I have been concerned about the unintended consequences of the new zoning code as a catalyst. You mention one factor: the stimulus of reduced/eliminated parking requirements. Second, while size and type of existing buildings may not matter on high-value center city properties, wholesale high-rise re-classifications contribute to the threat on many blocks. Third, the small increase in allowable height from 35 ft. to 38 ft. tips the balance away from renovating existing 3-story buildings toward replacement with new 4-story ones, a trend which disrupts many neighborhood streetscapes around the city. Until the zoning code is tweeked to re-balance the requirements for new vs. historic projects, perhaps revised tax incentives can fill the void. These imbalances might be reduced with a revision of the 10-year tax abatement program, which seems to be here to stay and which is now used primarily for new construction, with adequate incentives for renovation of historic properties.

  3. pretty sad to read — especially all the beautiful churches in grad hospital. Would be easier pill to swallow if the buildings replacing them were designed with any taste, but all we usually get is cheap construction with aluminum facades.

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
A Century Of Public Events On The Benjamin Franklin Parkway

A Century Of Public Events On The Benjamin Franklin Parkway

October 23, 2018  |  Last Light

Patrick Glennon takes a look at big public shindigs and the making of the Benjamin Franklin Parkway through rarely seen photographs from the Historical Society of Pennsylvania > more

Cherry Street Pier Raises The Bar For Dynamic Public Space

Cherry Street Pier Raises The Bar For Dynamic Public Space

October 19, 2018  |  Buzz

Cherry Street Pier is officially open for business. The 99-year-old maritime warehouse blends a public park with artist studios, food vendors, a beer garden, and incredible views of the Delaware River. Michael Bixler gives us a look inside > more

Defending Philly History From 3,000 Miles Away

Defending Philly History From 3,000 Miles Away

October 17, 2018  |  Vantage

Joshua Bevan knew he had to act after discovering the architectural beauty of Belmont. From his home in San Francisco he mobilized to nominate a neighborhood landmark for historic designation. In this essay Bevan describes his journey between the Bay Area and Philly to protect the McGaw Mansion > more

Design Coalition Aims To Bridge The Old-New Divide

Design Coalition Aims To Bridge The Old-New Divide

October 12, 2018  |  Walk the Walk

Move over Miami, the Philadelphia Design District is getting ready for some time in the spotlight. The coalition of gallery owners, artisans, and tech startups want to transform Old City into a hive of contemporary design, while preserving the neighborhood's historic character. Joe Brin takes a look inside the idea with co-founder Eugenie Perret > more

Germantown Boys & Girls Club Compromise Brings Peace To Penn Street

Germantown Boys & Girls Club Compromise Brings Peace To Penn Street

October 9, 2018  |  News

Owners of Germantown Boys and Girls Club reach an agreement with preservationists after two years of heated debate. Starr Herr-Cardillo has the news > more

Shakespeare & Co. Brings Old Bank Back To Life

Shakespeare & Co. Brings Old Bank Back To Life

October 4, 2018  |  Buzz

Manhattan-based bookstore and café revives an old banking storefront in Rittenhouse Square. Michael Bixler takes a look > more