Long-Forgotten Furness Building Discovered in Logan

November 13, 2017 | by Dennis Carlisle (AKA GroJLart)


Now, that’s a good-looking convenience store. The former Messiah Universalist Home, designed by famed Philadelphia architect Frank Furness, in Logan. | Photo: Michael Bixler

At the corner of Old York Road and West Ruscomb Streets in Logan a remnant of esteemed Philadelphia architect Frank Furness still stands. The building, heavily altered and in pretty rough shape, is now a convenience store with second floor apartments. Built in 1905, it was originally used as a home for elderly congregation members of the then-ostracized Universalist Church of the Messiah. 

Since the earliest days of their church, the Universalist Church of the Messiah found that their unorthodox version of Christianity, which assumed that all people were destined for salvation, not damnation, did not sit well with other Christians. The discrimination they faced came in its most inhumane form in how their elderly members were treated. Many homes for the elderly existed in 19th century Philadelphia, but most would not serve Universalists.

In 1878, leaders the Universalist Church of the Messiah created a Permanent Charitable Fund to fund the construction of a new senior home for its members. The fundraising goal, $25,000, was not met until 1899. By that point, the church realized that more funds would be required so they moved ahead with their plans, but only if they were able to get another $1,000 of contributions from church members.

It took another nine months to acquire the last $1,000. In 1900, the church incorporated the Universalist Home for the Aged. The constitution and by-laws of the organization, drafted shortly thereafter, renamed the building the Messiah Universalist Home.

A building on Cottage Lane in Germantown was leased and an opening reception was held on January 4th, 1902 at Wister Station. Hundreds of church members attended, donating not only money, but supplies, sundries, furniture, food, and even books and magazines for the new Messiah Universalist Home. When the home opened it only three residents.

By January 1903, the home was up to seven residents. The annual newsletter distributed to church members already noted that the place was overcrowded and that a new larger building may be required in the near future. Additionally, church leaders were adamant about owning a home instead of leasing one, calling the occupancy of the leased space an “experimental stage” that was now complete.

Messiah Universalist Home in its original configuration, date unknown. | Image: Annual Report of the Messiah Universalist Home

Fundraising for a new home began in earnest in 1905. The church purchased a lot at the corner of Old York Road and West Ruscomb Streets for this purpose. They hired acclaimed Philadelphia architecture firm Furness, Evans & Company for the design. By this point in his career, Frank Furness was not very popular in architecture circles and his company’s work leaned more toward Colonial Revival designs. This one would be no exception. In the middle of a large grass lawn retained by a stone wall, a two-story porch embellished the entrance on the Old York Road side of the brick fa├žade under a central palladium window. The only decorations designed for the exterior were an interesting cornice and keystones above the windows. Many windows. No less than 18 windows on the broad sides of the building and eight on the front and back.

Construction began on July 20, 1905 and the cornerstone was laid in a ceremony on September 19th. William R. Lyman, president of the home’s Auxiliary Board of Managers, secretly dropped a “lucky stone” on the construction excavation site that was discovered when Old York Road was widened in 1920. The first residents moved in on March 28, 1906 and the building was dedicated on May 23. Church members donated all of the furnishings and supplies required for the new home, which was much larger and was considered by the church to be better-looking and in a more convenient location with “cheerful surroundings”.

The Messiah Univeralist Home was successfully supported by the contributions and donations of church members for the next several decades. In December 1906, media attention focused on the home when a mysterious, out-of-place wild coyote appeared on the front lawn. Residents panicked and the Pennsylvania SPCA came out to capture the coyote with a wire lasso. The origins of the coyote were never determined, though sightings of coyotes within the city limits have occurred in more recent times.

A sun room was added on the south side of the building in 1934. In 1961, the Universalist Church of America and the American Unitarian Association merged to become the Unitarian Universalist Association. The newly formed church sought to replace the aging Messiah Home with a new facility. The churched moved to the new Unitarian Universalist House on Tulpehocken Street in Germantown once the merger was finalized in 1964.

What remains of the stone retaining wall along Old York Road. | Photo: Michael Bixler

The old home was purchased by the Ukrainian American Youth Organization for use as offices, classrooms, library, and meeting rooms. The organization, founded in 1949, educates Ukrainian-American youth with Ukrainian history, culture, and the development of a Ukrainian-American identity. The organization renamed the building the SUMA Home. Several other Ukrainian-American organizations used the building as their headquarters as well.

In 1963, UAYO proposed the demolition of the sun room for a very large addition that would provide space for an auditorium. The plan was never completed. In 1971, the organization added an single-story addition attached to the sun room.

UAYO sold the building in 1986 to Siphana Sok. Sok removed all the large trees and the grass lawn and paved it all over with asphalt to create a parking lot for a used car lot on the property. The building was adapted into a restaurant and offices. The property changed hands several times over the next few years, with different uses coming and going from the first floor–a restaurant, video store, and a video arcade. In 1992, the current owner purchased the building and installed a food market, New Mee Wah Market, on the first floor and apartments above under the designs of local architect Te-Chow Lei. A few small, one-story additions were added to the rear section of the building.

In 2004, the old stone retaining wall around the property was rebuilt with cinder blocks and a chain link fence, further marring the beauty of the old home. Today, the building has fallen into complete obscurity as a Frank Furness design, both in appearance and provenance. In the book, Frank Furness: The Complete Works, the authors even have the building listed as demolished in both its first and second editions.


About the Author

GroJ Lart Dennis Carlisle (AKA GroJLart) is a former Hidden City contributor and the anonymous foulmouthed blogger of Philaphilia, where he critiques Philadelphia architecture, history, and design. He resides in Washington Square West. Carlisle has contributed to Naked Philly, the Philadelphia City Paper's Naked City Blog, and Philadelphia Magazine's Property Blog. He is currently an employee of developer Ori Feibush, owner of OCF Realty.


  1. Michael J Lewis says:

    Once again, GroJLart is doing the best work these days on Frank Furness. Furness: Complete Works did indeed fail to note that the building still stands. As one of the contributors to the catalogue, I can only say “mea culpa” (and that there are far worse errors there).
    I can add one item to GroJLart’s story. The project architect for this building was Herman “Dutch” Kleinfelder, soon to be made Furness’s junior partner. It is likely that it was designed by Kleinfelder and not Furness, who was alienated from his firm in the summer of 1905. He was then involved in a bitter dispute over payment for the Girard Bank, and as a distraction began his quest to find the Confederate soldier whose wounds he had tended at Cold Harbor.
    One last note: the office earned a fee of about 6% for the Messiah Universalist Home. The building cost $13,421; Furness Evans & Company received $846.07.

    1. GroJLart says:

      Thanks for the extra info Michael!

    2. Hello. I am researching a Furness building for historical preservation. Can you help? 6401 Ogontz Ave
      Thank you.

  2. Anne Slater says:

    The upper molding that outlines the roof is different enough (so busy, so tightly mounted– it looks like those dumb little cotton balls on twisted thread that are sewn on kitchen curtains of a certain era) to the upper regions of the many Furness buildings I have seen in and out of Philadelphia that I am in complete(amd utterly non-professional) agreement with Michael Lewis– probably not FF’s work, although created in his shadow.

    The two Furness buildings I know best (First Unitarian Church, on Chestnut Street, and Harford, in Radnor Township (now used by Main line School Night as a center for day time classes), have much different(may I say more sophisticated?) appearances than the Old Universalist Home: broader and, in their lack of height, more approachable..

  3. Also Davis says:

    Is Te-Chow Lei the same guy who butchered the first floor of his Walnut Street building next to the Theosophical Society before it could be landmarked?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.