Tax Credit Turnabout Triggers Protest At New Aloft Hotel

October 23, 2017 | by Dennis Carlisle (AKA GroJLart)


Protestors play tug of war with a President Donald Trump impersonator over a giant novelty check representing the $33 million in federal and State grants and tax credits received by developers of the Aloft Hotel at Broad and Arch Streets. | Photo: GroJLart

On Thursday, October 19, a crowd of activists gathered in front of the new Aloft Philadelphia Downtown hotel on the corner of Broad and Arch Streets. Members of Center City Organized for Responsible Development (CCORD), Philadelphians Organized to Witness, Empower & Rebuild (POWER), leaders and members of the Arch Street United Methodist Church, and several other groups rallied around the hotel to protest what they believe was a misuse of Federal and State tax credits. The new hotel opened in August after a total renovation and conversion of the 1924-built Liberty Title & Trust Building into a 179-room hotel with a second floor indoor and outdoor lounge, two retail spaces, and one restaurant space. The developers were a partnership of Berwyn-based Realen Properties and HRI Properties from New Orleans.

The project received several a substantial number of tax credits and grants–$10 million in Federal Historic Preservation Tax Incentives, $15 million from two New Market Tax Credits, $2 million from the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania’s Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program (RACP), and a 10-year tax abatement from the City of Philadelphia valued at approximately $6 million, bringing the total to $33 million.

CCORD first pushed back at the hotel’s qualifications for those credits and grants last June. The developer’s application for a RACP grant included the promise of 170 jobs to members of the community, 115 positions of which would be for the ongoing operations of a restaurant located at the hotel. That part of the plan was cancelled and a small bar and lounge was installed instead. The restaurant space currently available for lease on the ground floor is not affiliated with the hotel.

Liberty Title Building was built in 1924 for the headquarters of the Liberty Title and Trust Company. Before renovations for the Aloft Philadelphia Downtown hotel began, the building remained vacant since the 1990s after the last tenant, the Philadlephia Water Department, moved out. A Dunkin Donuts coffee shop previously occupied the corner retail space. | Photo: Michael Bixler

Drawing attention of rush hour drivers and pedestrians with drummers and bullhorns, the group of protesters lined up on the North Broad Street median across from the hotel, leading chants echoed by the crowd on the east side of Broad Street. Activist Mike Mullins spoke to the crowd, denouncing the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania’s lack of taxation on fracking and “the rich”. He also spoke about how the SRC and the City closed numerous schools in 2013, having other activists name each one. Mullins asked the crowd where the money from the school closures should have went. After several responses, he turned the bullhorn over to an impressionist dressed as President Donald Trump, who bragged about the developers using the money to build a “beautiful hotel.”

Mullins listed each tax credit and grant the hotel received and asked the crowd where each should have went. Members of the crowd responded “Affordable housing!”, “Rec Centers!”, and “Feed the homeless!” When the President Trump impersonator spoke of the restaurant promised in the RACP grant application, some activists responded, “What happened to the jobs?”

Through public relations firm Bread & Butter, the hotel’s general manager, Evan Evans, told Hidden City, “Aloft Philadelphia is actively seeking a restaurant tenant for the space.” Evans would not provide a clarification of if they mean the lounge area on the 2nd floor or the 1st floor restaurant space currently available for lease.

Reverend Robin Hynica, President of CCORD, told Hidden City “There are two ways that this issue can be resolved: create the jobs as promised, or return the $2 million of RACP grant dollars to the state of Pennsylvania.” In Aloft’s RACP grant application, the jobs promised began at a median wage of $31,500 per year.

The recently renovated lobby of the Liberty Title & Trust Building for Aloft Philadelphia Downtown hotel. Photographs by Michael Bixler.

One central issue brought up by the protesters was the two New Market Tax Credits granted to the developers. This tax credit, created in the 1990s to encourage and assist development in impoverished neighborhoods, has a broad range of qualifications. Criticized from its inception, the tax credit has been used for a number of redevelopment projects that just barely qualify. The new Aloft hotel at Broad and Arch Streets is another one, only qualifying for the credits because the census tract in which it is located has a low median family income. On June 12th, U.S. Representative Bob Brady, whose district the hotel is located in, wrote a letter to the Treasury Department denouncing the tax credits.

Messages left with the Governor’s press office were not returned by the time of this story’s publication.

Kate Esposito, member of POWER and CCORD, speaking about the New Market Tax Credits, told Hidden City, “There’s legal, and there’s moral. If they are doing something for the community, let us know. Let’s get these jobs in there.”

Revered Hynica said, “We share Congressman Brady’s concerns that the project is not in an area that should be described as low income and deserving of NMTC investment.”

A small group of activists entered the hotel and got stuck in the elevator, causing the protest to become even more of a scene as the Fire Department showed up to help them. The protest eventually moved onto the Broad Street median. A group of protesters held a sit-in demonstration in the lobby of the hotel and were arrested and issued citations. The Philadelphia Tribune captured video of the lobby demonstration and arrests.


About the Author

GroJ Lart Dennis Carlisle (AKA GroJLart) is a former Hidden City contributor and the anonymous foulmouthed blogger of Philaphilia, where he critiques Philadelphia architecture, history, and design. He resides in Washington Square West. Carlisle has contributed to Naked Philly, the Philadelphia City Paper's Naked City Blog, and Philadelphia Magazine's Property Blog. He is currently an employee of developer Ori Feibush, owner of OCF Realty.


  1. bob crapster says:

    You think that’s bad, take a look at the $20 million in taxpayer funds the SLS debacle at Broad and Spruce is ransoming the neighborhood over.

  2. glenn says:

    What the hell does this have to do with President Trump this was all done before he was President. You need to go after your crooked mayor governor and city council for taking payoffs to get this done

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.