A Rusty Nail On Lancaster Avenue Reveals All

 

The old Gartside’s Iron Rust Soap Company headquarters at 4054 Lancaster Avenue adds charm and distinction to an otherwise subdued block. | Photo: Michael Bixler

Lancaster Avenue is slowly waking up with a fascinating building stock to match its renewed energy. Once a lively, main thoroughfare between the city and suburban points northwest, the completion of the Schuylkill Expressway, between 1951 and 1960, contributed to a crippling decline in business along the avenue. The corridor has maintained a certain level of neighborhood vitality, but, with the growing influence of Drexel University in Poweltown Village, and a recent uptick in real estate speculation in neighboring Mantua, a rise in vibrant, commercial activity is beginning to speckle Lancaster Avenue like ice cream jimmies. Ripe for reuse along the corridor are unique spots like this mysterious Victorian row house and birthplace of Gartside’s Iron Rust Soap at 4054 Lancaster Avenue.

The unique property was built some time in the 1890s. The architect is unknown. Even in its current forlorn state, the building’s façade is still striking. A slim, pitched roof covers the 3rd floor, while the second level is clad in patterned brick. Most prominent is a round bay window that stands out like a conical tower. The earliest known occupant of the property was Madge A. Kelly, who imported and distributed millinery and straw goods here between 1896 and 1900. Mary A. Gallagher, a University of Pennsylvania student and, later, professor, lived on the upper floors during the first decade of the 1900s.

A surviving tube of Gartside’s Iron Rust Soap with box. | Image: Ebay

In 1914, Joseph Gartside bought the house and altered it for the production and distribution of his famous stain removal product, Gartside’s Iron Rust Soap. Gartside was the youngest son of a prominent, iron-working family in Chester, PA.  In 1894, Gartside, an amateur chemist, discovered a formula that was capable of removing rust, ink, fruit, and medicine stains from clothing and marble. He first produced the soap in his house at 719 North 40th Street (now demolished), selling small tubes of his concoction door-to-door for 25 cents each.

The product quickly became popular. Only a small dab of the substance was required to remove stains from cloth. Gartside’s Iron Rust Soap Company was officially incorporated in 1896. By 1910, other manufacturers were imitating Gartside’s stain remover, but only one, Call Again Iron Rust and Ink Remover, ended up being viable competition. In a bold move, Call Again packaged their version of the soapy goo identical to Gartside’s, even including the same type of rubber band around the tube.

Gartside sued the company and several others, but was unable to legally prove infringement. To make matters worse, he never trademarked his product. After losing in court, Gartside started a smear campaign, placing ads in publications around the country to mock and insult his copy cat competition. In 1917, the Federal Trade Commission investigated Gartside and ordered him to cease and desist his public derision.

After Garside’s death, the company was willed to his son, Harry, and his sister, Katherine Gartside Emmert, who appears to have taken over as head of the company. Katherine, an accomplished woman in her own right, was one of the founders of the Philadelphia Chapter of the Professional Women’s Club, a social and professional organization for business women. The club operated out of 4054 Lancaster Avenue until the mid-1920s.

Gartside’s Rust Soap continued to be a successful product, and the company moved out of 4054 Lancaster Avenue in 1928 to several other locations over the next few decades. At its peak, the company even had its own store at 50 North 8th Street. Gartside’s Iron Rust Soap finally folded in the early 1980s. Joseph Gartside’s grand nephew, Gar Emmert, was the company’s final owner.

“It frequently happens.” A 1927 advertisement for Gartside’s Iron Rust Soap. | Image: Newspapers.com

After Gartside’s moved out of 4054 Lancaster Avenue, Danzig & Romain Housewares opened on the ground floor. Danzig & Romain was a Lancaster Avenue staple for decades, quickly expanding their operations to other locations on the same block to serve different the departments of their store. Their location at 4054 Lancaster Avenue underwent several name changes over the years, from Danzig & Romain Radio & Fridgidaire Shop in the 1930s, to Danzig & Romain Radio & Electric Shop in the 1940s, to, finally, just Danzig & Romain Store in the 1950s.

By the 1970s, the building was being used for a jewelry store. Sun Byung Moon bought the place for $18,000 in 1976, yet it sat vacant for quite some time thereafter. In 1988, Moon combined the storefront with the building next door and opened Mooney’s Menswear. In 2002, 4054 Lancaster Avenue, now separated again, was leased to a hair salon followed by Sugar N Spice Video, an adult video store. While the upper floors have remained empty for decades, the ground floor was last occupied by a laundry service. The current owner purchased the property earlier this year.

About the author

Dennis Carlisle (AKA GroJLart) is the anonymous foulmouthed blogger of Philaphilia, where he critiques Philadelphia architecture, history, and design. He resides in Washington Square West. GroJLart has contributed to Naked Philly, the Philadelphia City Paper's Naked City Blog, and Philadelphia Magazine's Property Blog.



3 Comments


  1. Every time I drive down Lancaster Ave in W Philly I am finding new and fascinating buildings that somehow have survived. This is one I hadn’t seen before. Thanks

  2. I knew Mantua was ripe for speculation, if only for location reasons. I’d be so rich now, if I’d followed my nose years ago, and if I’d had the money to buy up properties.

  3. I wonder if Katherine Gartside Emmert was in any way related to the Emmert of The Emmert Vise fame and fortune? http://mprime.com/Emmert/index.htm

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
Unraveling Myths About Philly's Pioneering African American Architect

Unraveling Myths About Philly’s Pioneering African American Architect

May 23, 2019  |  Vantage

Amy Cohen separates fact from fiction surrounding one of Philadelphia's most famous architects, Julian Francis Abele > more

A Fine And Public Space: Preservationists Revive Philadelphia's Historic Cemeteries As Vibrant Spaces For The Living

A Fine And Public Space: Preservationists Revive Philadelphia’s Historic Cemeteries As Vibrant Spaces For The Living

May 21, 2019  |  Vantage

New life is blooming at Philadelphia's historic cemeteries. Starr Herr-Cardillo has the story > more

Appetite For Deconstruction: North Philly Nonprofit Tackles Three Pressing Issues With One Program

Appetite For Deconstruction: North Philly Nonprofit Tackles Three Pressing Issues With One Program

May 17, 2019  |  News

Philly Reclaim brings sustainability, historic preservation, and job training together with its architectural salvage program. Kimberly Haas has the story > more

Arson & Archway Raise Awareness Of A 19th Century Architect

Arson & Archway Raise Awareness Of A 19th Century Architect

May 14, 2019  |  Vantage

Pauline Miller takes us on a journey from Old City to Mount Moriah Cemetery where the work of architect Stephen Decatur Button struggles for longevity > more

A Fond Farewell To Paley Library At Temple University

A Fond Farewell To Paley Library At Temple University

May 10, 2019  |  Last Light

Paley Library closed its doors to the public on Thursday after serving Temple University for 53 years. Michael Bixler says goodbye to the mid-century modern library with this photo essay > more

In Kensington, Old Textile Mill To Be Revived With Apartments

In Kensington, Old Textile Mill To Be Revived With Apartments

May 7, 2019  |  Vantage

Gotham Hosiery, once the country's most popular pantyhose manufacturer, quickly rose to fame and crashed even faster. Now, the nearly 100-year-old mill at 2nd and Norris is getting a residential makeover. Rob Masciantonio dives deep into the history of the old textile mill and details on plans for redevelopment > more