Sloan Mansion Days Are Numbered: Penn Can Proceed Without Permits, Says Historical Commission

 

Sloan 2

A hotbed of designated controversy at 40th and Pine | Photo: Michael Bixler

Advocates for the preservation of the Samuel Sloan-designed mansion at 40th and Pine Streets suffered a loss today. The Philadelphia Historical Commission voted five to three today in favor of allowing University of Pennsylvania, and their partner developers Azalea Gardens Partners, LP to proceed with demolition without obtaining building permits.

As we reported in December, Penn and Azalea Gardens requested recommendation from the Historical Commission’s Hardship Committee to have the condition removed, citing the cost of maintenance and potential environmental hazards the vacant building allegedly poses. The recommendation to remove the condition–with the stipulation that, should the building be razed, the property be landscaped and maintained until construction begins–was unanimously approved by the Committee, making the ruling today yet another predictable development in this embittered, eight year long legal saga. Preservationists worry that an amendment removing the condition would have set a lasting, detrimental precedent, clearing the way for fast tracking the demolition of buildings protected by the Philadelphia Historic Register when economic hardships are granted–the Levy House has been on the Register since 1973. Speaking on whether or not today’s proceeding is precedent-setting once the condition has been removed, Historical Commission executive director John Farnham maintained his opinion that this perception was, from a technical standpoint, without merit. Since hardship has already been granted, he said, demolition has effectively already been granted once permits are obtained too, and amending conditions are at the discretion of Commission. He also pointed out that no formal stay order was filed by the Woodland Terrace homeowners’ legal council, Paul Boni. “We did not seek a stay because we didn’t believe demolition was imminent,” said Boni. Although Penn’s attorney Mathew McClure stated that the building would not be demolished before litigation goes before the Commonwealth Court, this verbal agreement was not made part of the motion thus not legally binding.

An addendum to the ruling was introduced by the Committee that would exhaust Penn appeals for financial hardship, but this was ultimately voted down.

Oral arguments for appealing the ruling that grants the demolition of the Italliante mansion at 40th and Pine Streets go before the Commonwealth Court on Feburary 9th.

About the author

Michael Bixler is a writer, photographer, and managing editor of Hidden City Daily. He is a former arts and entertainment reporter with Mountain Xpress weekly in Asheville, North Carolina and a native of South Carolina. Bixler has a keen interest in adaptive reuse, underappreciated architecture, contemporary literature and art, and forward-thinking dialogue about people and place. Follow him on Instagram



1 Comment


  1. Robert Masciantonio

    The fact UPenn can claim hardship while sucking up 100k per student is laughable. Our cities historic commission is a joke.

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
Fear & Floating At The Gimbels Thanksgiving Day Parade

Fear & Floating At The Gimbels Thanksgiving Day Parade

November 22, 2017  |  Last Light

Michael Bixler has this tribute to the zany hometown floats of the old Gimbels Thanksgiving Day Parade > more

New Book Claims PAFA As Catalyst For Modern Design

New Book Claims PAFA As Catalyst For Modern Design

November 21, 2017  |  Walk the Walk

In his new book, "First Modern," historian George E. Thomas asserts that Frank Furness opened the door to Modernism in 1876 with his design of the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts. Joe Brin walks us through the architectural brilliance of the nation's first art school with this review > more

After 45 Years, Brandywine Workshop Still Thinking Creatively

After 45 Years, Brandywine Workshop Still Thinking Creatively

November 20, 2017  |  Vantage

It looks quiet, but the old 19th century firehouse at 730 South Broad Street, home of Brandywine Workshop, is buzzing with art and adaptation. Contributor Karen Chernick takes us behind the blue-green doors. > more

Cret Exhibition Captures Vibrations Of The City

Cret Exhibition Captures Vibrations Of The City

November 17, 2017  |  Vantage

Illustrator Ben Leech enlivens the dying art of architectural drawing with his exhibition, "Cret Illustrated: Revisiting a Philadelphia Icon in Sketches," at Woodlands Cemetery. Michael Bixler has the preview > more

Task Force Inches Closer To Delivering

Task Force Inches Closer To Delivering “State Of Preservation” Report

November 16, 2017  |  News

Mayor Kenney's Historic Preservation Task Force convened today for their fourth official meeting. Starr Herr-Cardillo reports > more

Give $$$, Get a Cool Perk: 2017 Campaign

November 13, 2017  |  Uncategorized

  Now more than ever, independent journalism needs the support of readers like you. DONATE to the Hidden City Daily today and receive something nifty in return. > more