Taking On The G-Word In G-town

 

The G-word is "gated community" at Rittenhouse Hill | Photo: Bradley Maule

The G-word is “gated community” at Post Brothers’ Rittenhouse Hill | Photo: Bradley Maule

“The word ‘gentrification’ is a word I’ve always hated.” That’s how moderator Alan Greenberger, Philadelphia’s deputy mayor for economic development and director of commerce, introduced the forum held on Saturday, April 26, titled “The Big G” and subtitled “Gentrification in Germantown: How it Works and for Whom.” After about two-and-a-half hours listening to Greenberger and the four panelists discuss the issue, jumping from topic to topic like grasshoppers, it was difficult not to dislike panel discussions as much as Greenberger dislikes the word “gentrification.” That’s not a knock on the participants but on the inadequacy of a using the panel discussion format to dig into a subject like gentrification, a subject of multiple facets, many existing on the macro level; which looks different in different places; which brings out the often contradictory desires of people who are faced with it.

The forum was hosted at the Mastery Charter School at 5700 Wayne Avenue in Germantown, a pertinent site given the panelists’ agreement on the role of schools when it comes to people deciding where to live—and due to its location a mere two blocks from Rittenhouse Hill. The just-completed upscale renovation of twin 12-story residential towers opened in 1950 as Park Drive Manor Apartments comes from Post Brothers, the company owned by brothers Matthew and Michael Pestronk, noted object of union protests at their Goldtex construction site in Callowhill. While one of the panelists qualified her reference to “rich developers” by saying, “not all developers are rich, and not all developers are bad,” and while Germantown, with its many vacant lots and rundown properties, doesn’t quite fit the description “gentrified,” the Pestronks’ investment in Rittenhouse Hill and other area properties displays their sense that Germantown has “potential”—essentially the prerequisite for gentrification. Matthew Pestronk asserted this unequivocally during a phone call the day before the forum.

Rittenhouse Hill counts proximity to regional rail among its amenities. The closest stop, Chelten Avenue, represents one of Germantown's primary arteries (Germantown Avenue the other); as yet, it's difficult to detect the forces of gentrification on Chelten | Photo: Bradley Maule

Rittenhouse Hill counts proximity to regional rail among its amenities. The closest stop, Chelten Avenue, represents one of Germantown’s primary arteries (Germantown Avenue the other); as yet, it’s difficult to detect the forces of gentrification on Chelten Avenue | Photo: Bradley Maule

“[Germantown] is a desirable place for middle income people,” Pestronk pointed out. “It’s very attractive.” That section of Northwest Philadelphia offers a “tremendous opportunity” when it comes to renovations, explained Pestronk. “All there are are these old buildings that haven’t had any money put into them in 30 or 50 years. We thought, why don’t we start buying them and raising the rents?”

Rittenhouse Hill now includes exercise rooms where residents can take classes for free. The large back courtyard has a basketball/tennis court, a bocce court, an infinity pool, a hot tub, a small playground, and not one but two dog runs (one each for large and small pooches). Studios start at $895 a month, one bedrooms at $1,245, two bedrooms at $1,695, with rents for each going up by about $150 depending on, say, the quality of the views.

The rents are now double what they had been before the renovation, said Pestronk. “The area is totally undervalued.” Rittenhouse Hill is more than 80 percent leased.

The brothers started targeting the neighborhood around 2006. “We felt it was not so competitive,” explained Pestronk. “There weren’t a ton of other developers focusing on the market.” He believes the time is ripe: “Germantown, specifically in the area where Rittenhouse Hill is located, 10 or 15 years ago did not feel like it feels today.”

That sentiment brings us back to “The Big G” community forum, where the panelists touched on many of the same points made by Pestronk, but from a different perspective. For example, panelist Betty Turner, co-founder and president of Germantown Community Connection, noted that Germantown’s “older architecture attracts developers”—but she said it with a note of dismay. She also observed that some terms are relative: “‘Affordable’ doesn’t always mean affordable.”

To be clear, no real data was presented at the forum to show that Germantown actually is gentrifying, and indeed, one neighborhood real estate professional sees little evidence of it. Katey McGrath, director of operations at Elfant Wissahickon and a self-described “proud Germantowner,” notes that any increases in rents and housing prices are proportionate to other areas of Philadelphia. Nonetheless, the people in attendance at the forum were clearly concerned about what happens when an area is undervalued, as the Pestronks consider Germantown to be. The forum’s keynote speaker and panelist Colvin Grannum, president and CEO of the Bedford Stuyvesant Restoration Corporation, addressed who gets displaced when rents and housing prices go up, as they did so sharply in central Brooklyn. “It depends on where you are on the economic spectrum,” he said. “Gentrification does not impose suffering solely on the basis of race.” He noted that African American professionals and members of the creative class were doing well there.

All eyes are on Maplewood Mall which, half a block east of thoroughfare Chelten Avenue, is the subject of a $2.2M makeover initiative from Councilwoman Cindy Bass' office; Little Jimmies Bakery and Cafe opened their second location here two months ago | Photo: Bradley Maule

All eyes are on Maplewood Mall which, half a block east of thoroughfare Chelten Avenue, is the subject of a $2.2M makeover initiative from Councilwoman Cindy Bass’ office; Little Jimmies Bakery and Cafe opened their second location here two months ago | Photo: Bradley Maule

And yet, wealth is intertwined with race, with Grannum noting that, generally, blacks get displaced because power tends to be concentrated in the hands of whites. And when he was asked about the impassioned anti-gentrification argument that Spike Lee delivered in February—Lee essentially drowned out a questioner positing that there’s “another side” to gentrification when, for example, the value of a longtime homeowner’s property increases many times over—Grannum said, “the substance of what he said was on point,” adding that Lee was “really focused on the cultural dimension.”

During one tangent of the discussion, the panelists seemed to come to these conclusions: Schools are important, commercial corridors much less so.

Regarding the first point, panelist Stephen Mullin, president and principal of Econsult Solutions, put it bluntly: “I’m a big believer that white parents will not send their kids to schools that are predominantly black.” Grannum noted that in Brooklyn, people buy a $1 million or $2 million house, “but they’ve already budgeted in for private school.” In other words, gentrification still often leaves the schools segregated and low-performing. In the case of a neighborhood like Germantown, which doesn’t have newly prestigious Brooklyn’s ability to draw the affluent despite unpromising schools, the lack of solid schools will likely hinder the onslaught of full-fledged gentrification.

Regarding the second point: Although community development corporations often focus on attracting businesses to their neighborhoods, “gentrification is not likely to happen just because of commercial corridor revitalization,” Grannum asserted. “In Brooklyn, the commercial corridor lagged a decade behind residential growth.” Businesses first want to make sure the foot traffic exists.

Mullin agreed: “Having 20 more stores just does not work.”

In Greenberger’s opening remarks, he emphasized the point that “change in urban neighborhoods is inevitable”—an observation that was echoed repeatedly, for example by Mullin: “The notion of stability of neighborhoods is dangerous because it doesn’t exist.” The recurring theme, inevitable change, received nods of approval from the other panelists, then was often ignored as audience members’ written questions and even some panelists’ remarks kept circling back to the issue of how to keep the neighborhood the same. Which leads right back to Spike Lee’s comments.

It might be worth reproducing part of an “Ask a Native New Yorker” column written by Gothamist publisher Jake Dobkin. As with the doesn’t-fit-quite-right choice of having Grannum, of Brooklyn, as the keynote speaker on a panel about Germantown, Dobkin’s perspective won’t align perfectly with Philadelphia. Nevertheless, he wrote: “All New Yorkers are gentrifiers. Say you’re of Jewish extraction: your forebears gentrified some Irish right out of [the Lower East Side] around the turn of the century… Some neighborhoods, like [Brooklyn’s] Fort Greene, have been gentrified, degentrified, and regentrified, and will be again at some point in the future.”

After all, Grannum admitted, “Successful examples of controlling gentrification are hard to find.”

About the author

Formerly the editor-in-chief of Philadelphia City Paper, Theresa Everline has written for the New York Times, the Washington Post’s travel section, Next City and Preservation Online, and is a contributor to SmartPlanet.com. She usually says she lives in Manayunk, but it’s really Lower Roxborough, or maybe Wissahickon.



5 Comments


  1. Parts of Germantown were substantially populated by gentry from the earliest times. In a way it’s a microcosm of a small city. There is no reason G-town shouldn’t’ have all sorts and conditions of people living happily within its borders.

    • Exactly. Germantown was never intended to be a ghetto. It went from an urban village to a railroad suburb and continued to be an elite community up to about 40 years ago. Only people ignorant of Germantown’s long and proud history would condemn efforts to improve its current state.

  2. Hi – at Rittenhouse Hill, the property actually had a gate in front when we acquired it, but we removed it and do not plan to put one back. We wanted to be part of the wider community, and specifically not a gated community. Thanks,
    Mike

  3. Northwest Philadelphia has always reminded me a lot of the eastern part of Delco. The rowhouse architecture might be better in Germantown, and it might be more consistently urban in parts of the NW among other differences, but the history and makeup is very similar. East Falls would be like Darby/Colwyn/Collingdale. Germantown would be like Upper Darby, East Germantown would be Stonehurst neighborhood in Upper Darby/Millbourne, Mount Airy would be Yeadon/East Lansdowne/Lansdowne, Manayunk would be Clifton Heights, Rox would be Westbrook Park/Drexel Hill/Springfield, and Chestnut Hill would be Havertown/Haverford/Radnor.

    My point being that such a large, varied area should be every bit as varied as it would be if it were outside of the city. Germantown I think is the only neighborhood in the city that has a chance to be a legitimately mixed neighborhood where gentrifiers don’t control the entire commercial corridor. It’s a shame that residents of Germantown can’t try to revitalize their community without fearing gentrification though.

  4. 50 years ago Germantown’s diversity was a bragging point. Our block had Doctors, poets and truck drivers; public, private and parochial kids. Enough German immigrants that I knew as many Dads who had fought for the Fatherland as Dads who had fought against it.

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
Sixty Years Of Holiday Cheer At Wanamaker's

Sixty Years Of Holiday Cheer At Wanamaker’s

December 12, 2018  |  Last Light

Patrick Glennon gives us a look at the origins of a holiday tradition at the Wanamaker Building > more

City Archives Opens New HQ In Northern Liberties

City Archives Opens New HQ In Northern Liberties

December 6, 2018  |  Buzz

New digs in NoLibs for the Philadelphia City Archives. Michael Bixler has the details > more

Give a Gift, Get a Gift: 2018 Fund Drive Perks Are Here

Give a Gift, Get a Gift: 2018 Fund Drive Perks Are Here

December 6, 2018  |  Uncategorized, Vantage

Our annual fund drive is in full swing and this year's perks are better than ever, so have a look. Not to mention: all donations will be matched dollar for dollar by NewsMatch! > more

Architecture Trips The Light Fantastic in <em>Philly After Dark</em>

Architecture Trips The Light Fantastic in Philly After Dark

December 4, 2018  |  News

The Athenaeum of Philadelphia shines a light on local architecture at night with their illuminating exhibition, "Philly After Dark." Greg Prichard has this review > more

#GivingNEWSDay Is Here!

#GivingNEWSDay Is Here!

November 27, 2018  |  News

Double your donation to Hidden City today and help us get to the next level of journalism > more

When The United Nations <em>Almost</em> Chose Philly For Its HQ

When The United Nations Almost Chose Philly For Its HQ

November 23, 2018  |  Last Light

With the news of Philly losing Amazon HQ2 to New York and D.C., Patrick Glennon takes us back to 1945 when the City nearly convinced the United Nations to built its headquarters in Fairmount Park > more