Shohei Shigematsu, Reluctant Preservationist

 

Shohei Shigematsu at Gray Area event Wednesday | Photo courtesy of Gray Area

Shohei Shigematsu at Gray Area event Wednesday | Photo: Elise Vider, courtesy of Gray Area

People attending Wednesday night’s lecture by Shohei Shigematsu at the University of the Arts looked a bit befuddled. They had come to see a prominent architect play the role of “preservation provocateur”–the first in a series of such talks funded by the Pew Center for Arts & Heritage and hosted by the university and the Center for Architecture as part of their Gray Area project. What they got was a review of works by OMA, a firm led by Rem Koolhaas and five other partners, including Shigematsu. The portfolio was striking. Unabashedly modern, it included such projects as Milstein Hall at Cornell (a cantilevered slab with Corbusian and Miesian roots), the Marina Abramovic Institute for the Preservation of Performance Art in upstate New York, and the colossal, controversial CCTV headquarters in Beijing. But where did preservation enter in? The answer was that it did not–at least not beyond serving as an ominous caricature, fit for shadowboxing. And yet it was hard to shake the impression that Shigematsu was himself a preservationist of sorts.  Therein lay the befuddlement.

OMA bills itself as “a leading international partnership practicing architecture, urbanism, and cultural analysis.”  It was in the latter capacity that Koolhaas and Shigematsu indicted the preservation field in their 2011 “Cronocaos” show at the New Museum. As architecture critic Nicolai Ourousoff wrote then in the New York Times, “[Koolhaas] paints a picture of an army of well-meaning but clueless preservationists who, in their zeal to protect the world’s architectural legacies, end up debasing them by creating tasteful scenery for docile consumers while airbrushing out the most difficult chapters of history.”

Cornell University's Milstein Hall | Photo: T(h)ed Ferringer under a Creative Commons License

Cornell University’s Milstein Hall . Rand Hall is at right | Photo: T(h)ed Ferringer under a Creative Commons License

That same bumbling, hegemonic creature lurked around the edges of Shigematsu’s talk. There were graphics tying preservation to global economic development (ironically, the exact opposite criticism was recently leveled at the field by urban historian Kenneth Jackson) and others supposedly illustrating preservationists’ special loathing for buildings of the 1960s and 1970s, when “architecture as a social project” flourished. Had these themes been fleshed out, it might have been worth countering that, far from being derided, late-modernist buildings now occupy the popular and academic center of the preservation movement. Groups such as DOCOMOMO have local, national, and international branches. That same zeal has also animated the architecture profession for the last decade or so. It gives some of OMA’s own work a decidedly nostalgic cast.

CCTV Headquarters | Source: Wikipedia Commons

CCTV Headquarters | Source: Wikipedia Commons

Perhaps the deepest irony came as Shigematsu described his firm’s thoughtful renovations of existing buildings. Old surfaces were spared; old layers revealed. Even Milstein Hall, for all its icy bravado, throws the adjacent, classicizing Rand Hall into flattering relief. While bashing preservation may be fashionable (preservationists themselves now routinely bridle at the label), Shigematsu’s talk underscored the extent to which preservationist ideas and commissions have become part of the 21st century architect’s bread and butter. And perhaps that was the point. Perhaps, in their public presentations, Shigematsu and Koolhaas are simply chafing at the cultural, legal, economic, and site-based constraints in which their business must operate. But this is the architecture profession’s oldest and most romantic cry: “I am an artist!  Grant me liberation!”  It has echoed down the halls since the days of Frank Lloyd Wright and his doppleganger, Howard Roark. And yet, as OMA’s work demonstrates, those very constraints can inspire wonderfully elegant and creative solutions. Lift them and you may have a masterpiece…or CCTV.

About the author

Aaron Wunsch is an architectural historian and assistant professor in Penn's Graduate Program in Historic Preservation.

Send a message!



Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
Philadelphia's Forgotten Forebears: How Pennsylvania Erased The Lenape From Local History

Philadelphia’s Forgotten Forebears: How Pennsylvania Erased The Lenape From Local History

August 23, 2019  |  Vantage

In this poignant essay Dan Shurley looks at the mistreatment of the Lenape in Pennsylvania and how historic Philadelphia still manages to misrepresent and largely ignore the city's native people > more

A Reconstructionist Synagogue Weaves Itself Into Manayunk’s Industrial Fabric

A Reconstructionist Synagogue Weaves Itself Into Manayunk’s Industrial Fabric

August 22, 2019  |  Vantage

The congregation of Mishkan Shalom promotes sanctuary and social reform inside a 137-year-old textile mill on Freeland Avenue. Scotty Meiser has the story > more

African-American Abolitionist & Son Of Former Vice President Aaron Burr Receives Formal Recognition

African-American Abolitionist & Son Of Former Vice President Aaron Burr Receives Formal Recognition

August 19, 2019  |  News

The remains of John Pierre Burr, a black Philadelphia abolitionist and natural son of former Vice President Aaron Burr, has resided in an unmarked grave for more than a century. He will receive formal recognition and an official headstone on Saturday, August 24. Kessler Thibert has the details > more

Historic Maritime Landmark Under Threat After Construction Mishap

Historic Maritime Landmark Under Threat After Construction Mishap

August 15, 2019  |  News

Deferred maintenance and a construction error endangers Edward Corner warehouse, one of the waterfront's last prominent reminders of Philadelphia's shipping history. Starr Herr Cardillo has the details > more

In Northeast Philadelphia, A Rich History Of Train Tracks And Acquisitions

In Northeast Philadelphia, A Rich History Of Train Tracks And Acquisitions

August 13, 2019  |  Vantage

Ed Duffy give us a panoramic view of railroad history in Northeast Philadelphia with this longform essay > more

Eastern State Penitentiary Illuminates “Hidden Lives” Of The Incarcerated

Eastern State Penitentiary Illuminates “Hidden Lives” Of The Incarcerated

August 9, 2019  |  News

"Hidden Lives Illuminated," an animated film project created by inmates of SCI Chester, debuts at Eastern State Penitentiary on August 15. Kimberly Haas went inside the state prison to speak with the incarcerated artists > more