A Broken System

Historic Preservation In Crisis: A Hidden City Daily Feature

Monastery of St. Clare (demolished) | Photo: Peter Woodall

Interviews with a wide array of people involved in historic preservation in Philadelphia reveal a strong sense that the system is broken. The consequences of the broken system are clear, and brutal enough: a steady stream of demolition of architecturally noteworthy and historically significant buildings in every part of the city, the loss of urban fabric, scale, memory, and property value. And beyond all that, wasted opportunities to build on, adapt, reuse, and refabricate a truly wonderful and variegated urban form, to meld it with contemporary uses, designs, and materials, and in doing so to elevate ourselves and our humanity.

Since the launch of the Hidden City Daily last September, we have covered dozens of lost or threatened buildings, destroyed by fire or neglect or administrative error (in fact each case has very different circumstances). The Monastery of St Claire, St. Boniface Church, the Stephen Smith home, Buck Hosiery, Cramp Shipyard, Frankford Arsenal, Edison High School: there were so many significant losses in 2011, we had to present them in two separate photo essays, HERE and HERE.

This is a crisis that will only worsen in the coming two years, with dozens of churches, schools, and factories–the very buildings that lend our neighborhoods scale and identity–about to be deactivated and left to the will of the shaky market.

There are numerous reasons why a building might be lost. The practice of preservation, indeed of urban development in general, is complex and complicated, involving a diverse set of actors–from advocates to bankers to community members. But we’ve started our reporting, which was conducted chiefly by Ryan Briggs, where the rubber meets the road, with the one government agency legally tasked with protecting buildings of significance: the Philadelphia Historical Commission. Within the limitations of their budget and staff they do an heroic job safeguarding buildings, and yet because of their paltry budget and because of the general disregard for preservation among elected officials, the Commission is barely able to manage oversight for the buildings on Philadelphia’s list of protected properties and in its few historic districts, it can’t add either new buildings (or types of buildings) or districts in any fundamentally effective way, and it can’t provide the inspiration or impetus for city residents and policy makers to use preservation as a mechanism for community and economic development.

Cramp Machine & Turret Shop (demolished) | Photo: Peter Woodall

Ask almost anyone involved in historic preservation in this city of history and they will tell you the point of preservation is not to embalm the city in any particular historic moment, theme, or style, but to put all that inherited wealth to work for us today, to create a more interesting, lively, economically vital, and yes, marketable city. And yet, as we have learned following crisis after crisis as building after building is threatened or lost, the system for meeting this goal is shot, worn thin by lack of funding, political interest, and NIMBYism.

This leaves enormous swaths of the city, including architectural wonderplaces like Germantown and West Philadelphia–and wide categories of buildings–without the protection that a rigorous preservation system should offer. And without a municipal culture innovative enough to see preservation as a systemic catalyst for neighborhood development, in the way previous generations viewed Society Hill, there is little reason to hope that the status quo is going to change.

Our Investigation In Context
However, historic preservation as a discipline is changing. Here in Philadelphia, the work of the city’s chief preservation advocate, the Preservation Alliance of Greater Philadelphia, is expanding the very idea and practice of preservation from the protection of buildings designed by noteworthy architects of other times to the proactive and neighborhood based process of identifying sites of cultural importance. The Alliance is also pushing a “thematic” historic district to cover, for the first time, in this city of work, the wilting collection of 19th century textile mills. The Pew Center for Arts and Heritage is sponsoring a thought experiment called “Gray Area” meant to exploit the questions in the field of preservation about what makes a building significant, what it means to preserve it, and what exactly we mean to preserve.

Globe Dye Works | Photo: Peter Woodall

In actuality, quite a lot of preservation–the reuse and adaptation of old buildings for contemporary uses–happens every day in Philadelphia. Most of us live in old buildings, after all. In Kensington, the folks from 3RD Ward are nearing completion of the wonderful renovation of a set of buildings; in Frankford, the Globe Dye partners are quietly (re)turning that complex into an economic machine (in part by engaging contemporary designers); in West Philly, the folks from the non-profit ACHIEVEability have lovingly renovated the 1912 Von Louhr California Mission-style apartment building, which sought to prove the viability of apartment living in the city of homes. But these projects proceed entirely on an ad hoc basis. And the fact remains that for every Globe Dye there is a handful of Buck Hosieries.

What Our Investigation Reveals
Our reporting on the Philadelphia Historical Commission, the agency created to be the chief custodian of the city’s architectural past, reveals a department that has been enfeebled by underfunding and overwhelmed with responsibilities. Our exploration of preservation cases in action reveals a system that’s fairly easy to exploit and often manipulated by provincial neighborhood interests. Our research into the practices of peer cities reveals ways we could do substantially better and methods we can adapt going forward.

In this two part series, which will run today and tomorrow, the Hidden City Daily will first outline how historic preservation efforts have manifested themselves in Philadelphia’s municipal government, examine both successes and failures of that system in its efforts to proactively guard significant buildings and places, and compare Philadelphia’s methods to neighboring East Coast cities. Part two will investigate cracks in the system of protection and the legal difficulties involved in protecting even historically certified structures.

–Nathaniel Popkin and Peter Woodall, co-editors

Click PAGE 2 below to advance to Part One of the story.

About the author

Ryan Briggs is a journalist who lives in West Philadelphia. A veteran of several economic development agencies in Philadelphia, Ryan has contributed to the Philadelphia City Paper, Next City and other fine, local publications. Follow him on Twitter at @rw_briggs.

Send a message!


  1. This and part 2 are fine articles, packed with well researched, supported, and thought-out information.

    I’d like to comment, however, on something more trivial, even ridiculously so: your use of the couplet “an heroic.” Bravo! I guess I’m not the only holdout to use “an” before words beginning with the letter h after all. I just can’t write or speak “a” in such instances. I feel as though I’m hiccupping. Rather like the feeling one has when tripping on a cracked sidewalk.

    My wife thinks I’m crazy. (I very well may be, but for wholly other and additional reasons!) If so, at least I’m not the last lunatic.

    • You may be crazy, but you are not alone – this makes an historic connection…

      Yes, and thanks to Mr Briggs for excellent articles.

  2. You gentlemen are providing long needed look at how the City of Philadelphia treats its historic landscape.

    Ms. Blackwell’s hostility in 2002 can be traced to the Spruce Hill. The Community Association’s nomination to create a local historic district was perceived as a way to give themselves unwarrented power over the residents. People feared this was an attempt to drive out low income and a means to tell owners what colors to paint their houses.

    These fears were not based on facts of law or how the Historical Commission works, but they were real fears. Most Citizens do not know the difference in powers between a local historical Society and the Historical Commission. With the local historical Society and Spruce Hill organizations doing the nominating the local Citizenry saw them as one and the same. Confrontation only fanned the flames and in doing so caused a Citywide halt in district nominations.

  3. I can’t help but think that we’ve driven industry out of the city with burdensome regulations, now we wonder why there are no funds to preserve the past. Surely a factor is moving from the industrial age, but I know it is both difficult and expensive to operate in the city…thus my husband’s employer moved the company outside of the city. You need a tax base to tax, if the businesses leave there isn’t much of a tax base left.


  1. - Philadelinquency
  2. Some Incentives Coming For The Renovation Of Mills In Kensington | Hidden City Philadelphia

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
Docomomo PHL To Host

Docomomo PHL To Host “Wake” For Modernist Store

June 18, 2018  |  News

Modernist architecture advocacy group will hold a demonstration to protest Philadelphia's historic preservation crisis. Michael Bixler has the details > more

The Rise, Fall, & Revival Of North Broad's Opera Palace

The Rise, Fall, & Revival Of North Broad’s Opera Palace

June 14, 2018  |  Vantage

Rob McClung takes us on a journey through the turbulent history and present reawakening of the mighty Metropolitan Opera House at Broad and Poplar > more

A Brief History Of Race & Contested Space In West Philly

A Brief History Of Race & Contested Space In West Philly

June 11, 2018  |  Vantage

Mariam Williams dives deep into the social evolution of Malcolm X Park to unearth the history of race and economics within a neighborhood space > more

Italian Market Project Puts Fresh Eyes On A Philly Staple

Italian Market Project Puts Fresh Eyes On A Philly Staple

June 8, 2018  |  Vantage

The Italian Market Project mixes a walking tour with Philly-accented theater in a fun, immersive experience. Mickey Herr has the details > more

Taking History To The Streets With Preservation Activism

Taking History To The Streets With Preservation Activism

June 6, 2018  |  Soapbox

Ali Roseberry-Polier discusses civil rights history, selective public memory, and why she created an historical marker for a Black female activist who challenged segregation in 19th century Philadelphia > more

A Buzzy New Beginning For Poth Brewing Company

A Buzzy New Beginning For Poth Brewing Company

June 4, 2018  |  Last Light

Before renovations begin, Michael Bixler takes us inside the remains of Poth Brewing Company with this photo essay > more