Shovel Ready?

Photo: Peter Woodall

Martin Filler, writing on the New York Review blog, says that with the completion of phase 2, “the High Line feels wholly consistent and yet never repetitive throughout its entire mile-and-a-half length.” This has something to do, he says, with having both a holistic vision and the desire to variegate experience.

Proper sequencing is therefore critical, a point already being revealed in the fledgling Reading Viaduct project. In this age of shrunken finances, how to initiate (and implement) an ambitious vision? Taking the Race Street Pier as a cue, city officials want to think small first, raise excitement, and, in time, achieve broad transformation.

Don’t we often wish this city would seize the moment?

A phase one would begin design for a portion of the City Branch of the elevated railway–owned by SEPTA and therefore simpler to acquire–the sideways “r” that runs from Broad and Noble to Callowhill Street. Indications are that process is underway.

Photo: Peter Woodalll

The strategy makes perfect sense. As one project observer noted to me, this is the only part of the proposed 3 mile park to which the city has–or ever will have–certain access. And building a park in that section will have immediate impact on a the Callowhill neighborhood, a place on the cusp.

But starting here will have consequences. Primary of these is that by developing here first it precludes using this most accessible section for staging and construction equipment, and according to Paul VanMeter of Viaduct Greene, it will raise the overall cost of the project considerably. VanMeter would like to see an international design competition first, anyway, and a holistic vision emerge before investing in finished design for a particular section. And after that? “Construction-wise, I think I’d start at Broad Street and go West,” says VanMeter. “Build something splashy on the West side of Broad St at the Inquirer Building and behind the Rodin.”

About the author

Nathaniel Popkin is co-editor of the Hidden City Daily and author of three books of non-fiction, including the forthcoming Philadelphia: Finding the Hidden City (Temple Press) and a novel, Lion and Leopard (The Head and the Hand Press). He is the senior writer of the film documentary "Philadelphia: The Great Experiment."



1 Comment


  1. also from the outstanding and inspiring Martin Filler piece…

    “David and Hammond’s High Line is above all an inspiring case study of how major city planning initiatives can be realized without either the authoritarian methods of Robert Moses—New York’s mid-twentieth-century public works czar, whose pursuit of vast infrastructure and urban clearance projects often ran roughshod over democratic procedures and working-class neighborhoods—or today’s characteristic commercially driven redevelopment schemes.”

    seems the Philadelphia of today has a Robert Moses of sorts:
    http://www.citypaper.net/news/2011-10-06-paul-levy-center-city-district-philadelphia.html

    it would be a shame to see ‘politics,’ unravel good and welcome momentum.

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
City Council To Vote On Ridge Avenue Demo Moratorium

City Council To Vote On Ridge Avenue Demo Moratorium

December 13, 2017  |  News

A bill to place a temporary hold on demolition applications for 300+ historic properties along Ridge Avenue goes before City Council tomorrow. Michael Bixler has the details > more

The Marvelous Multiple Occupations Of The Midtown II

The Marvelous Multiple Occupations Of The Midtown II

December 11, 2017  |  The Shadow Knows

Last June, one of Center City's last classic diners, Midtown II at 11th and Sansom, closed its lunch counter for good. The high-profile property is now under development, although plans for the space remain elusive. The Shadow takes us behind the façade to reveal a lively list of tenants and a colorful history of reuse > more

Secrets! Romance! Scandal! The Hush-Hush Love Of Philly's Paint King And His Irish Lass

Secrets! Romance! Scandal! The Hush-Hush Love Of Philly’s Paint King And His Irish Lass

December 8, 2017  |  Harry K's Encyclopedia

Harry K. takes us to Old City where the flames of a secret affair scorched newspaper headlines in the early 1900s > more

Marc Lamont Hill Energizes Germantown Ave With New Bookstore Cafe

Marc Lamont Hill Energizes Germantown Ave With New Bookstore Cafe

December 6, 2017  |  Vantage

Academic, activist, and political commentator Marc Lamont Hill carries the tradition of the Black-owned bookstore into the 21st century with Uncle Bobbie’s Coffee and Books. John Henry Scott has the details > more

Give $$$, Get a Cool Perk: 2017 Campaign

Give $$$, Get a Cool Perk: 2017 Campaign

December 4, 2017  |  Vantage

Hidden City's annual fund drive is in full swing on Generosity and we've got a brand new batch of perks celebrating Philadelphia available. Here's a look at this year's killer lineup > more

Three Historic Designation Removals Call Procedure Into Question

Three Historic Designation Removals Call Procedure Into Question

November 30, 2017  |  Vantage

Three historic properties on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places were abruptly stripped of legal protection last week. Contributor Starr Herr-Cardillo unpacks the details of each situation > more