Artist Explores Pattern Of Synagogue Reuse For African American Churches

 

Artist Zoe Cohen’s Shul / Church Project began in response to a demolished building. The magnificent West Philadelphia Jewish Community Center had long dominated a stretch of 63rd Street just south of the El tracks. When the synagogue center was razed in January 2014, Cohen, like many West Philadelphia residents and preservation advocates, was unsettled by images of the wreckage. Although it served a Christian congregation for decades, the massive brick building, adorned with colorful tiled Stars of David, Menorahs, and Hebrew script, stood as one of the last and most prominent testimonies to the Jewish community that had thrived in West Philadelphia in the first half of the 20th century. Cohen memorializes the community center in her series of watercolor paintings depicting former synagogues now being reused by African American churches. An exhibition of her Shul / Church Project opens at Abington Arts Center on February 5th.

| Photo: Michael Bixler

Artist Zoe Cohen stands in from of her watercolor and paper cutting diptych, Our Sanctuary Laid Waste. At left: former West Philadelphia Jewish Community Center, then Philadelphia Baptist Church. At right: Second Baptist Church, then Anshe Emethe, and lastly D’rshe Tov. It was then used by a fencing company before being demolished in 2014  | Photo: Michael Bixler

Jewish themes and iconography often figure into Cohen’s artwork. She once incorporated some of the West Philadelphia Jewish Community Center’s decorative Hebrew lettering into a bookplate she designed for her own synagogue. She was moved by the poignant contradictions in the demolition photos of the Jewish community center. “It was a sanctuary,” she said, “and sanctuary means safe, enclosed. Now it’s blasted open.” In a large-scale collage, Cohen created a ghostly approximation of the hollowed-out sanctuary, with cut white paper and swirly watercolor paint rendering the collapsing brick walls and splintered roof beams all the more fragile and ephemeral.

Cohen then came across a wrenching photo published in Hidden City Daily of another former synagogue demolished around the same time. The Second Baptist Church in Northern Liberties was built in 1803 and housed two different synagogues, Anshe Emethe and D’rshe Tov, beginning in 1871 and well into the 20th century. The building’s life ended in the more prosaic service of the AA Fencing Company. The ruins of the building’s demolition site inspired Cohen to make a companion collage, again using paper cut-outs and watercolor to make once weighty stone seem precarious and insubstantial.

As she cut out paper strips for roof timbers and painted swirls of rubble, Cohen realized she didn’t want her work to simply chronicle devastation and loss. The demolished synagogues sparked her curiosity. Many Jewish families had migrated from Center City and South Philadelphia at the turn of the 20th century to leafy, residential enclaves like Cobbs Creek, Strawberry Mansion, and Cohen’s own neighborhood of Black Oak (now Malcolm X) Park. Those families, like many other white residents, fled to the suburbs after WWII as African Americans moved in. But what happened to their houses of worship, Cohen wondered? What vestiges of Jewish religious life remained?

Photo: Peter Woodall

This 2014 photograph of Second Baptist Church in mid-demolition contributed to Cohen’s inspiration for her Shul / Church Project | Photo: Peter Woodall

Not far from her own house, she came across the Open Heart Church on the 6000 block of Larchwood Avenue. Although a large white plastic cross hangs over the door of the stately two-story brick building, the Star of David–the central motif in each of the building’s ten façade windows–gives away the building’s former use. When Cohen spoke to the pastor, Bishop Derrick Hanna, he told her what he knew of the building’s past. His father, the founding pastor, purchased the synagogue, Beth MaMedrosh HaGadol, from the Jewish congregation in the early 1980s. The Pentecostal congregation embraced their building not only because its interior spaces were built to be a gathering place and already suited to ritual and worship, but that the synagogue’s  history was still very present. When Cohen expressed surprise that the church retained so much Jewish iconography, Bishop Hannah said to her, “Why would we want to remove a symbol that is the foundation of our religion? We really feel like this is our mission to preserve the DNA of the building. It is meaningful to us that that this was a house of God.”

The Open Heart Church is hardly unique. Assisted by a comprehensive list of Philadelphia’s synagogues past, present, extant, and demolished (available online through the Jewish Genealogical Society of Philadelphia) Cohen discovered that a large number of former synagogues survive today as African American churches of various denominations. As her research deepened,  the Shul / Church Project began to materialize and the series became an exploration, in image and sound, of the past and present of these buildings and of the links between the Jewish congregations that built them and the African Americans who worship inside them today.

Beth HaMedrosh HaGadol / Open Heart Church, 60th & Larchwood, West Philadelphia, Watercolor on Paper, 10x12", Zoe Cohen, 2015 | Photo: David Johanson

Beth HaMedrosh HaGadol / Open Heart Church, 60th & Larchwood, West Philadelphia, watercolor on paper, 10″ x 12″, Zoe Cohen, 2015 | Photo: David Johanson

The centerpiece of the installation at Abington Arts Center will be sixteen watercolor portraits of Philadelphia synagogues built between 1900 and 1930 that are now African American churches. In contrast to the two collages of demolished sanctuaries, the architectural portraits are intimately scaled and buoyantly colored. Cohen, using images from Google Maps street views and Flicker galleries, painted the buildings freehand without preliminary pencil outlines or straightedge measures. There’s a child-like candor in these fluid watercolor presentations. Cohen purposely eliminated any specific Christian or Jewish imagery (except in structures like Shaare Zedek, now the Millenium Baptist Church, in which the double tablets of the Ten Commandments are an integral part of the architecture), preventing viewers from reading the signs and symbols that identify one religious tradition or another and instead drawing attention to the buildings’ lively, evocative shapes.

The Jewish congregations that once worshipped in the sanctuaries Cohen paints did not disappear entirely. Many of them moved to newly built synagogues in suburbs like Wynnewood and Elkins Park. The Abington show gives Cohen an opportunity to forge some living links among people and the congregations for whom these buildings once were or still are a spiritual home. “My ultimate goal is to bring people together,” she says. She created three sound collages to complement the paintings and collages, recording services at suburban synagogues and the churches those congregations once inhabited. Beth Sholom, now Beloved St. John Evangelistic Church, Adath Jeshurun, now the New Greater Straightway Baptist Church, and Kol Tzedek Synagogue, now the Open Heart Church, are featured in her series.

Beth Jacob / Reconciliation & Liberty Bible Church, 60th & Chestnut, West Philadelphia, Watercolor on Paper, 10x12", Zoe Cohen, 2015

Beth Jacob / Reconciliation & Liberty Bible Church, 60th & Chestnut, West Philadelphia, watercolor on paper, 10″ x 12″, Zoe Cohen, 2015 | Photo: David Johanson

Cohen chose her own synagogue, Kol Tzedek, to pair with the Open Heart Church because the original congregation, Beth HaMedrosh HaGadol, no longer exists. In the 1980s, as that congregation dwindled, Penn students attended services there so the Larchwood Avenue synagogue would have a minyan. Some of those former students now belong to Kol Tzedek, founded in 2005. Kol Tzedek is one of several faith communities that share space in West Philadelphia’s Calvary Church and helped save that historic building from the wrecking ball.

As Cohen edited the recordings she made with her phone, she was struck by the similarities, the chattering as people entered the sanctuary, the gradual settling into stillness, and then the service beginning with voices united in song.

With these layered conversations and incantations, and with her portraits of buildings in fluid, watercolor shades, Cohen aims to evoke a spiritual connection, past and present, Jewish and Christian, white and black. The Shul / Church Project began as a response to a building that was lost, but, as Cohen delved deeper and traced the history of the Jewish exodus to the suburbs, she uncovered another loss, more subtle and more painful. By leaving the city as African Americans moved in, she believes Jewish communities and the city as a whole lost a tremendous opportunity, “to connect, to identify with, and to live beside people” with whom they shared a common history of prejudice and exclusion.

Beth Sholom / Beloved St John Evangelistic Church, 4541 North Broad St, North Philadelphia, Watercolor on Paper, 10x12", Zoe Cohen, 2015 | Photo:

Beth Sholom / Beloved St. John Evangelistic Church, 4541 North Broad St, North Philadelphia, watercolor on paper, 10″ x 12″, Zoe Cohen, 2015 |Photo: David Johanson

“What did we lose by becoming white?” she asks. “What would have happened if we had stayed here? Not to suggest that these buildings should have stayed Jewish,” she adds. Instead, she ponders an alternate history in which Jewish and African American communities lived in the city’s residential neighborhoods side-by-side. Would the conversations have been different? Would they have found common ground?

By stripping the buildings of religious imagery and layering voices in prayer and song, Cohen creates a vision of this alternate past with the exhibition. However, her motivation behind the Shul / Church Project is not necessarily to look backwards and focus on possibilities lost. “Art is always a beginning,” she says. Cohen hopes the exhibit will be a springboard for further conversation and a deeper cultural connection.

***

Zoe Cohen’s solo exhibition of Shul / Church Project opens on Friday, February 5th with a reception between 6-8PM. The exhibit will be on view until March 24th. The Abington Arts Center is located at 515 Meetinghouse Road in Jenkintown, PA. For details and hours of operation see: www.abingtonartcenter.org.

For more information on artist Zoe Cohen and the Shul / Church Project see her website: zoecohen.com

About the author

Ann de Forest has written frequently about design, architecture, and the built environment for the Philadelphia Inquirer, ID Magazine, and Attaché, among other publications. Her short stories have been published in Cleaver, The Journal, Hotel Amerika, Timber Creek Review, and PIF. She teaches creative writing to kids ages 8-13 and adults over 70 and is writing a time travel trilogy for middle grade readers involving old maps.



5 Comments


  1. Very interesting! It’s a shame it’s out in Abington and not the city, although that’s where a lot of the community has moved to. This could be something good for the Philadelphia Museum of Jewish Art (https://rodephshalom.org/community/philadelphia-museum-jewish-art)

  2. If I recall correctly – correct me if I’m wrong, the Beth Jacob / Reconciliation & Liberty Bible Church, 60th & Chestnut, West Philadelphia has at one time been St Mark’s Armenian Church.

  3. This is fascinating to me. I’m the author of three books on The Lost Synagogues of New York City, published by Avotaynu.com and I have been documenting “lost synagogues” (former synagogue buildings) in NYC. NJ and elsewhere.

  4. This is interesting. The church I grew up in used to worship in a former synagogue (Johnson & Ardleigh in Mt. Airy). I always thought that was cool given the history of the two faiths. We also had another nearby church in our movement that worshiped in a former synagogue, and that building is now a mosque. It’s another way to chart the history of the city.

  5. This is so very interesting, although I am a Catholic convert, I grew up on 60th and Larchwood Ave. The Synagogue on the corner was were I held my first job at 6 years old.
    I was asked by the Rabbi to come in and shut of the lights because they couldn’t use electricity???
    I received a shiny quarter, that was big time in the early 1960’s!!

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
Willis Hale's Bold Beginnings On The Delaware River

Willis Hale’s Bold Beginnings On The Delaware River

October 20, 2017  |  The Shadow Knows

The work of Willis G. Hale, the mind behind the much-adored Divine Lorraine and the frankly fussy Hale Building, is enjoying a renaissance as of late. The Victorian architect's penchant for brazen facades can be traced back to a warehouse on the Delaware River, demolished in the 1960s to make way for I-95. The Shadow has the backstory > more

On 40th Street, New Life For A Long-Hidden Furness

On 40th Street, New Life For A Long-Hidden Furness

October 18, 2017  |  Vantage

What's it take to restore this early Furness? Hidden City talks to developer Tom Lussenhop about the tear-down disaster ongoing across the city and his plans for the former West Philadelphia Institute > more

Praise And Protest At Historical Commission Meeting

Praise And Protest At Historical Commission Meeting

October 17, 2017  |  News

Applause and anger filled the room at the monthly Historical Commission meeting on Friday. GroJLart has the details > more

The True Center Of The City Revealed

The True Center Of The City Revealed

October 13, 2017  |  Harry K's Encyclopedia

City Hall may be the "heart" of Philadelphia, but an unassuming corner in North Philly is the true center of the city. Harry K. explores the evolution of Penn's greene country towne and how Philadelphia has a history of being the center of attention > more

LIGHTS! MUSIC! ACTION! Historic Lansdowne Theater Poised For A Comeback

LIGHTS! MUSIC! ACTION! Historic Lansdowne Theater Poised For A Comeback

October 11, 2017  |  Vantage

After 30 years' slumber, Lansdowne's sumptuous Art Deco movie palace is ready to wake up, and rouse Main Street too, with music and community spirit. Ben Leech has the story > more

Wish You Were Here: Postcards From The Past Recall

Wish You Were Here: Postcards From The Past Recall “Real Philadelphia”

October 10, 2017  |  Vantage

The Athenaeum of Philadelphia's new exhibition, "Real Philadelphia: Selections from the Robert M. Skaler Postcard Collection," puts elusive images of working class city life in the limelight. Contributor Karen Chernick has the review > more