Almost 150 Years Later, A Small Miracle At City Hall

 

2016 campagin_3

 

| Photo: Michael Bixler

At long last. City Hall’s entryways finally get the fencing treatment they deserve. All four portals are now fitted with aluminum and stainless steel gates based on architect John McArthur, Jr’s original sketches | Photo: Michael Bixler

Editor’s Note: A version of this story appeared in the December issue of Extant, a publication of the Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia.

There were always two reasons to wince when bringing a visitor to Philadelphia’s City Hall on the weekend. The first was that the courtyard was closed, meaning the city had officially capitulated to a shrunken sense of itself. The second was that the chain link gates that locked the place down were therefore distinctly visible, a dirty expletive aimed at Philadelphia’s ultimate architectural gesture of grandeur.

The chain link gates were installed in the 1980s as restoration work began on City Hall Tower. As construction fencing, they weren’t meant to be permanent. But having lasted more than 30 years, the chain link gates remind us of the pernicious effect of an inappropriate architectural gesture.

In September, at a cost of $1.5 million, City and Center City District officials began the process of replacing the chain link gates with magnificent new portal gates based on drawings created in 1869 by City Hall architect John McArthur, Jr. but never realized. Robinson Iron of Alexander City, Alabama fabricated the new gates out of aluminum and stainless steel, materials chosen for their lighter weight compared to wrought iron.

More than 146 years in the making. Ribbon cutting for new gates at City Hall's West Portal.

More than 146 years in the making. The ribbon cutting for the new gates at City Hall’s West Portal in September, 2015 | Photo: Michael Bixler

This is the second attempt to install architecturally appropriate gates at City Hall. In 1983, the Philadelphia Historical Commission, under Richard Tyler, coordinated an effort to salvage wrought iron gates from the Philadelphia General Hospital complex as it was undergoing redevelopment (some fencing and gate pillars still exist along Civic Center Boulevard). The initial plan, costing about $30,000, was to install gates in City Hall’s north portal in conjunction with the restoration of that part of the building. In 1984 or 1985, the project expanded to all four of City Hall’s portals, but funds were no longer available to cover the increased cost of about $70,000. The chain link gates were left in place, apparently because officials feared graffiti artists would tag the tower.

Three decades later, the new gates complete the poetic reconnection to City Hall that began with the opening of Dilworth Park last year. If Dilworth leads the pedestrian into intimate connection with McArthur’s French Second Empire monument, with its 88 million bricks and more than 200 works of sculpture and bas-relief, the soaring gates draw the eye skyward and into the realm of wonder. This is the gift of the monumental.

McArthur, Jr. drew the gates into a rendering of City Hall, possibly one he made for the public competition for the commission. They lay forgotten in the City archives for almost 150 years until the architect Hy Myers, of Vitetta, discovered them in the early 1990s as the firm began a master plan for the restoration of City Hall. A 2001 Vitetta report connected to the first phase of restoring the building’s envelope included concept drawings of McArthur, Jr.’s gates installed in the four portals, at an estimated cost of $990,000.

Having made it a priority to continue the restoration of City Hall during his two terms, Mayor Michael Nutter appropriated funds to fabricate and install the gates and asked the Center City District to manage the project under the supervision of Vitetta’s Nan Gutterman. The challenge was to adapt a single rendering—made by McArthur, Jr. before he had fully developed the architectural language of the building—into a workable design. The hope was that the gates would look like they’d always been there, preservation in reverse.

A Calder lion wrapped in safety netting still manages to artfully interface with the new portal gates. The backwards wreath on an open gate not so much (but it still beats cyclone fencing) | Photo: Michael Bixler

As KieranTimberlake’s transparent glass subway entrances and the other contemporary design elements of Dilworth Plaza have added a new layer to the architectural fabric of the site, the gates constitute a kind of sub-layer, a chance to see the rudiments of McArthur, Jr.’s visual composition. The bottom of each gate is finished with a system of rails, collars, and flower petal caps, a pattern McArthur, Jr. developed further in the iron rails below the building’s first floor window wells. The architect placed a circle of rosettes connected diagonally by a dominant X at the center of each gate; a blank shield above the circle completes the medieval gesture. It’s interesting to note how generic this composition seems in comparison with the rich visual and sculptural language that developed during the three decades of City Hall’s construction. McArthur, Jr. and the sculptor Alexander Calder used bas-relief carvings and sculpture to adapt the French Second Empire style to late 19th century Philadelphia, capturing powerful images of the city’s intellectual and natural history. By giving us a visual starting point, the gates allow us to see the depth of this evolution.

About the author

Nathaniel Popkin is co-editor of the Hidden City Daily and author of three books of non-fiction, including the forthcoming Philadelphia: Finding the Hidden City (Temple Press) and a novel, Lion and Leopard (The Head and the Hand Press). He is the senior writer of the film documentary "Philadelphia: The Great Experiment."



8 Comments


  1. The gates look great and they make a very beautiful addition to City Hall.

  2. My thought on the design was that the small
    Circles represent the cities squares. Logan, rittenhouse,Franklin and Washington with city hall as center square.
    Just a thought on the design. It may be just a coincidence.

  3. Mod Betty / RetroRoadmap.com

    So excited to see these! When we were showing out-of-town pals the city recently I was slightly mortified to have them see the chain link gates on such a beautiful building. These will be a real improvement, for folks walking by every day plus visitors.

  4. The gates are a handsome addition to City Hall and now I am wondering how are the city doing in putting new sidewalk on the north side of City Hall to preclude vehicle parking. Sidewalk should be for pedestrians and visitors, not city cars.

  5. The addition of these four handsome gates finally puts the finishing touches on our urban cathedral! Like the cathedrals of Europe it took several generations to complete the task but nonetheless it is done!

  6. I was hoping for many years that this would happen. I have had visitors that I was showing around the city. Mention how bad the old gates looked.

  7. Let’s stop saying “graffiti artists” and call them what they are: graffiti vandals.

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
With A Little Help From Frank Furness, We Evaluate 10 New Projects

With A Little Help From Frank Furness, We Evaluate 10 New Projects

June 23, 2017  |  Vantage

Hidden City architecture critic Jason Lempieri summons the spirit of Frank Furness in this appraisal of Philly's newest urban forms > more

Row House: Past And Its Future

Row House: Past And Its Future

June 20, 2017  |  Vantage

Contributor Hilary Jay dives deep into the evolution and politics of contemporary row house design with Interface Studio Architects > more

An Artful Adaptation In Bella Vista

An Artful Adaptation In Bella Vista

June 15, 2017  |  News

A contemporary art gallery and residence on Bainbridge Street goes green with reuse and sustainable renovation. John Henry Scott has the story > more

Behind The Bar At Dirty Frank's

Behind The Bar At Dirty Frank’s

June 13, 2017  |  The Shadow Knows

The Shadow saddles up to the bar at Dirty Frank's with the backstory on one of Philadelphia's most beloved dives > more

With New Penn's Landing Plan, A Central Park

With New Penn’s Landing Plan, A Central Park

June 12, 2017  |  News

Lost in the intense news cycle: major news about the at-long-last redevelopment of Penn's Landing. Nathaniel Popkin has a look > more

With Bloomsday Near, Remembering The Rosenbach Brothers

With Bloomsday Near, Remembering The Rosenbach Brothers

June 9, 2017  |  Vantage

Every year in June a crowd gathers outside of the Rosenbach Museum & Library to celebrate James Joyce's seminal literary masterpiece "Ulysses" with a block party and day full of public readings. Karen Chernick gives us the backstory on the Rosenbach Company and two rare book dealers whose legacy is enshrined on Delancey Place > more