Then And Now: 11th & East Passyunk Avenue

 

| Photo courtesy of the George Mark Wilson Photograph Collection, Library Company of Philadelphia

You can’t use your Super Saver card here. Where the East Passyunk ACME buzzes with busy grocery shoppers once stood Moyamensing Prison, home to the country’s first serial killer and dramatic, castellated towers | Photo courtesy of the George Mark Wilson Photograph Collection, Library Company of Philadelphia

At least one South Philadelphia corner hasn’t always hummed with urban life. In the 1830s, 11th Street and Passyunk Avenue was home to the imposing Moyamensing Prison, now the site of Acme shopping center built 36 years ago. Traces of the old house of corrections’ wall can still be found along 11th Street, but the block’s history of dangerous inmates and grim executions has all but faded into memory since the prison’s demolition in 1967.

Then: Moyamensing Prison

Moyamensing Prison, also known as also called the Philadelphia County Prison, was built in the Gothic style between 1832 and 1836 on the lot that spans 11th Street, Reed Street, and Passyunk Avenue. It had a similar castellated appearance to Eastern State Penitentiary on Fairmount Avenue. The first of Philadelphia architect Thomas Ustick Walter’s commissions, Moyamensing–nicknamed “11 Street Dock,” “the jug,” and “the county hotel”–was designed to evoke fear in its prisoners and would be troublemakers. Walter understood that since the prison would be housing violent criminals the building had to have a menacing outward presence. The fortress-like structure included the separate Debtors Apartment designed in an Egyptian-Revival style similar to the Temple of Amenhotep III along the Nile River. The debtors’ quarters doors were flanked by lotus-bud columns—the ornamental moulding above was decorated with a winged Aten sun disk. By the time of its completion in 1836, the law requiring the imprisonment of debtors was repealed. The prison used the new wing as a women’s annex.

Front Elevation Philadelphia County Prison, Debtors' Wing, Reed Street & Passyunk Avenue

The Debtors Apartment at Reed Street & Passyunk Avenue was designed in the attractive, unique Egyptian-Revival style | Source: Historic Buildings Survey, Library of Congress

Famous Imprisonments

Moyamensing Prison had a number of historic guests during its 127 years in operation. Al Capone and his body guard Frank Cline were arrested by detectives James Malone and Jack Creedon on May 16, 1929 and were imprisoned at Moyamensing for 24 hours after spending their first day behind bars in a City Hall jail cell. They were then transferred to Holmesburg Prison for a few months and then sent to Eastern State Penitentiary for the rest of their sentence.

Passmore Williams, 1855 | Source: Chester County Historical Society

Abolitionist Passmore Williams serving his 100 day sentence at Moyamensing Prison in 1855 | Source: Chester County Historical Society

Another “one-nighter” was American author and poet Edgar Allen Poe. Living in Philadelphia at the time, it is said that Poe became so intoxicated on July 1st, 1849 while on a severe drinking binge that he began hallucinating and became suicidal. “The Tomahawk Man” was arrested for public intoxication and spent a single night at Moyamensing. When Poe went before Philadelphia mayor Charles Gilpin for his arraignment hearing he was dismissed without fines when the mayor recognized the renowned poet.

Charles Bukowski, another renowned boozehound writer, spent 17 days in the prison on suspicion of draft dodging.

In 1855, abolitionist Passmore Williamson, member of the Pennsylvania Anti-Slavery Society, served nearly 100 days at Moyamensing. Williamson, accompanied by Underground Railroad conductor William Still and other free African-Americans, helped Jane Johnson and her two children escape enslavement from Col. John Wheeler while visiting Philadelphia. Johnson had accompanied Wheeler to New York and Nicaragua, where he was then appointed U.S. ambassador. Williamson’s arrest gained national headlines; he was visited by prominent abolitionists like Frederick Douglass and Harriet Tubman. Following his three months at Moyamensing, Williamson rejoined his colleagues at the Underground Railroad.

Moyamensing Prison gained the nation’s attention in 1896 when it put America’s first serial killer, H.H. Holmes, behind bars. An Inquirer headline in April, 1896 called Holmes, the subject of Erik Larson’s 2004 novel The Devil in the White City, “The Most Fearful and Horrible Murderer Ever Known in the Annals of Crime.” He lured dozens of people in Chicago to his specially designed torture chamber hotel, “Murder Castle,” during the 1893 World’s Fair. In the basement Holmes set up a ghastly autopsy room that was also outfitted with quicklime pits and a crematory. He tormented and murdered all of his guests and claimed the lives of an estimated 200 men and women between 1888 to 1894.

Herman Webster Mudgett

A face only the Devil would love. Herman Webster Mudgett, aka H.H. Holmes | Photo: Public domain

Holmes dissected some of his victims’ bodies and sold others to medical schools around the country. He was arrested in Philadelphia after a police officer entered his small office at 1316 Callowhill Street and discovered the body of Holmes’ fraudulent patent business partner Benjamin F. Pitzel, whom he murdered in an act of insurance fraud. On the day of his execution in 1896 newspapers reported that Holmes remained calm and eerily serene during his hanging, which lasted over 20 minutes. He was buried without a tombstone in a casket filled with cement at Holy Cross Cemetery in Yeadon.

In 1834, Pennsylvania was the first state to abolish public hangings, though this was then superseded by “private hangings” within the walls of the institution. In 1916, Moyamensing was the site of Pennsylvania’s last execution by hanging, which was then replaced with the more modern method of execution by electric chair.

By the early 20th century, the city had grown around the prison, placing it in the middle of a busy neighborhood. The facility’s 19th-century heating, plumbing and fierce, imposing architecture eventually forced the prison to retire. Moyamensing Prison was abandoned in 1963 and most of the structure was torn down in 1967.

Now: Acme

ACME

Free as a bird. Although reuse of the prison and its fine architecture would be more feasible and attractive today, tbe City elected to release the surrounding neighborhood from the dense weight of Moyamensing Prison and tore it down in 1967, freeing it up for commercial use and the ACME supermarket that replaced it | Photo: Michael Bixler

Following the prison’s demolition the large parcel sat empty until the City elected to give the space over to commercial use. Grocery giant Acme Markets filled the lot with a new store in 1979 to replace its pitched roof sister store directly across the street where a CVS Pharmacy is now located. Pep Boys auto service took over the old Acme location at 1405 South 10th Street until 1993 when the pharmacy moved in. Following the dictates of the day (only now diminishing), the new grocery store was given suburban amenities, most profoundly a 202-space parking lot. The 53,915 square foot store was remodeled in the late 1990s and, partially, again in 2014 with new flooring and additions in the produce, deli, and bakery section, a reconfiguration of the paper goods isle and general reorganization of all non-refrigerated stock, and an overall redesign of the store’s visual branding. The self checkout machines were also removed. A new “Thank you from South Philly” welcome sign hangs inside the entrance.

October 5th, 1971 Source: PhillyHistory.org

Moyamensing pillars post-demolition and the old Acme Market across the street on October 5th, 1971. CVS currently occupies the old grocery store | Source: PhillyHistory.org

The square-block where Moyamensing once stood is home to the South Philadelphia Older Adult Center as well. Also built in 1979, the 8,461 square foot recreation center is owned by the City and managed by Philadelphia Department of Parks & Recreation. A gated, landscaped green space and flower garden extends from the building’s entrance and stretches along East Passyunk Avenue and Dickinson Street. SPOA offers a host of activities and programming for South Philadelphia elderly,including group meals, counseling, educational courses, volunteer opportunities, bocce, movie screenings, and a glee club. The center receives partial funding from the Pennsylvania Department of Community and Economic Development and the Philadelphia Corporation for Aging.

Although most of Moyamensing Prison has been torn down, a small part of its wall still remains behind the Acme at Reed Street. An historical marker commemorating the prison was installed in 2011 on the edge of the shopping center’s parking lot on 11th Street, and an “in memoriam” picture of the prison hangs on the wall inside the store to the left of the Butcher Department near the entrance to the public restrooms.

In 2007, the City Planning Commission proposed the addition of a porcelain enamel interpretive sign with lighting in its Urban Designs Recommendation report for Passyunk Square Village Center. Renderings of the proposed sign combines an image of Moyamensing Prison and the ACME logo added to the store’s outer wall at 11th and Reed Street as a nod to the site’s architectural history. Those plans have not been implemented.

***

Hidden City Daily co-editor Michael Bixler contributed reporting to this story.


7 Comments


  1. Hi Michael,

    Great article. I grew up down on the 2000 block of S. 10th St. and had a great aunt and uncle who lived around the corner from the prison. I remember walking past the debtor’s wing when I was 7 or 8 years old. Did you come across any reference to the Walter facade being stored at the Smithsonian? It’s referenced here:
    https://ruins.wordpress.com/2006/12/25/egyptian-revivalism-and-moyamensing-prison-debtors-apartment/
    It would be good to know if that story’s true. Maybe another research project for Misplaced Philadelphia.
    Cheers,
    Larry

    • You can tweet the folks at the Smithsonian archives and they are pretty handy at knowing about major items in their collections. I feel a whole building facade would stand out!

      @smithsonianarch.

  2. How can one be held for “suspicion” of draft dodging. Either you did or you didn’t!?! But hey, our wonderful fabulous judicial system, it’s a joke now and evidently even back. Interesting article though, Thank you.

    • Jim, things were quite different back then. There were no fingerprints and very little photography. A man could legally take a “bounty” for another man and go into the Army for the original “drafted” man. In a very short time the man who received the bounty could go AWOL and in a different location do the scam again. It was easy to change your appearance. It was done quite often. One man was caught after doing it 21 times. He was sentenced to jail time until the war (Civil War in this case) was over. So, the man in the story above may have not been a bounty jumper but simply a man that looked like another man who was drafted and never showed up. Once positively identified as not being the draftee, he was released.

  3. That I didn’t know as I walked on the site with wife to see our daughters. Very interesting story. Wish it was reconstructed to serve as a museum somewhere.

  4. Thank you for your wonderfully researched and very well written story. I grew up one block away from “da’ prison,” on 10th and Wharton, and I have long wondered about the history of the building that so frightened us as children. To be honest, I assumed the neighborhood stories about Al Capone’s incarceration there were myths, so its great to read such a precise account of Moyamensing’s history.It was torn down when I was young, but it’s memory has always loomed in the back of my mind. It’s hard to overstate how oppressively grim that building was. Probably the scariest looking building I’ve ever seen. Thanks again.

  5. . Barbara Ridgley

    How do you go about finding out about a relative who served in 1940 in the prison.

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
Renovations In Bella Vista Reveal Barber Supply And Bootlegging Biz

Renovations In Bella Vista Reveal Barber Supply And Bootlegging Biz

September 25, 2017  |  The Shadow Knows

The Shadow takes a spin around the old Via Bicycle shop on 9th Street where a barber supply company peddled boozy contraband during Prohibition > more

Without Remediation, Diamond In The Rough A Risky Play

Without Remediation, Diamond In The Rough A Risky Play

September 22, 2017  |  Vantage

How safe is safe enough? Environmental researcher Coryn Wolk explores the potential public health risks at a youth baseball field built on top of an industrial alloy production site surrounded by an oil refining complex > more

Wayne Junction Moves Forward With Revitalization

Wayne Junction Moves Forward With Revitalization

September 20, 2017  |  News

Developer Ken Weinstein unveils transit-oriented development plans for Wayne Junction district. GroJLart has the story > more

Inside Northeast Philly's Temple Of Ryerss

Inside Northeast Philly’s Temple Of Ryerss

September 19, 2017  |  Harry K's Encyclopedia

Harry K. takes us on a fall field trip to the Ryerss Mansion, an eccentric, little-known house museum in the Great Northeast > more

Unlisted Philadelphia: Locust Theatre

Unlisted Philadelphia: Locust Theatre

September 14, 2017  |  Unlisted Philadelphia

Ben Leech spotlights unique and significant buildings not listed on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places with his architectural illustration series, Unlisted Philadelphia. In this installment, a marvelous movie house in West Philly > more

Monument Lab: A City-Wide Art Museum That Asks Us To

Monument Lab: A City-Wide Art Museum That Asks Us To “Leave Fingerprints”

September 13, 2017  |  Vantage

We ought to write our own history, say the organizers of Monument Lab, who launch their multi-week public art and civic introspection festival today in the wake of Charlottesville, Dallas, and Durham. Nathaniel Popkin catches up with Monument Lab founder Paul Farber, who asks us all, "What is an appropriate monument for Philadelphia today?" > more