The Last Synagogues Of Strawberry Mansion

 

A few years ago, while driving down Ridge Avenue into Strawberry Mansion on my way home to the Northwest section of the city, I noticed a fading blue Star of David and a big sign reading “Kosher Delicatessen” on the white bricks of an old building. These seemed anachronistic and out of place–signposts of a community that I didn’t associate with North Philadelphia. I wasn’t intimate with the history of the area yet, beyond being well aware of John Coltrane’s formative years spent in a house on the edge of Fairmount Park. Years later, I returned to scour Ridge Avenue for those same signs that had caught my attention, but came up empty-handed. So, I began to dig and what I uncovered were the last vestiges of an historic Jewish community long forgotten.

In Philadelphia’s Strawberry Mansion neighborhood, demographic shifts took place about half a century ago. In Rabbi Fred Kazan’s introduction to Strawberry Mansion: The Jewish Community of North Philadelphia, by Allen Meyers, Rabbi Kazan says of the shift, “Today, Jewish Strawberry Mansion only exists in our hearts, thoughts, and memories experienced and shared by thousands of people less than 50 years ago. The Jews built a community, and when they left for such places as the Oxford Circle, Overbrook Park, and West Oak Lane-Mt. Airy, they left behind their houses of worship. These buildings have withstood the test of time; they now serve Strawberry Mansion’s black community as living monuments and churches.” In my own search I found most of the surviving synagogues being reused by Christian congregations.

Many of these were “row house synagogues,” Kazan tells me on the phone. “You knock down some walls in a house and turn it into a synagogue. But many of these places were not permanent. They lasted only a generation and a half.”

In Meyers’ notes for his book–held in Temple University’s Urban Archives–I found evidence for at least 21 former synagogues in the neighborhood, built for the most part in the first quarter of the 20th century. Of the more formal synagogues in the neighborhood, six remain standing today.

For a community that thrived in the neighborhood for only a few generations–between World War I and the end of World War II–the old Jewish congregations of Strawberry Mansion left a number of remarkable buildings. Alterations have been made, of course, as the Christian congregations that now worship inside these structures have carefully adapted them to their own beliefs. Though, in a few striking instances, the presence of the previous tenants still remain.

Left Behind: The Death And Life of Strawberry Mansion’s Synagogues

Photos by Michael Buozis

B’nai Menashe Synagogue

B’nai Menashe Synagogue | 2341 North 31st Street, Philadelphia, PA 19132

B’nai Menashe Synagogue on 31st Street, founded in 1925, now houses the Redeem Baptist Church. This synagogue served mostly Eastern European Jews in the northern section of the neighborhood. The name of the synagogue was adopted from the founder of the Mt. Lebanon Cemetery in Collingsdale, Pennsylvania, and the synagogue’s primary benefactor, Menashe Abrams. Though the B’nai Menashe may have been the most humble of Strawberry Mansion’s six surviving synagogues, it is perhaps the most unique, evoking urban European synagogues of the late 19th century. The building survived a firebombing attempt in October 1953. It’s now painted in peach and clothed in stucco and aluminum trim.


Kerem Israel Anshe Sfard

Kerem Israel Anshe Sfard | 1813 North 32nd Street, Philadelphia, PA 19121

The next two synagogues–one of them the most grand in the neighborhood–stand practically across the street from one another. The Kerem Israel Anshe Sfard on 32nd and Morse Streets retains much of its original character and now serves as a Baptist church. Originally a Methodist church, the orthodox congregation bought the building in 1917. Kerem Israel was the last congregation to leave the neighborhood in 1971. Its stone façade is almost medieval and imposing despite the windows being replaced with glass cubes.


BethIsrael

Beth Israel Temple | 1806 North 32nd Street, Philadelphia, PA 19121

Across the street, just south on 32nd Street, is the Beth Israel Temple, the neighborhood’s largest synagogue. It was the first that I visited that retains a Jewish symbol on its façade. The congregation this building served dates back to 1840–the third to form in Philadelphia. The temple, designed by Frank Hahn, was built in 1909. Above the entrance you can still read the words “Beth,” though time and weather have worn them down greatly. The façade shows modern French and Byzantine influences. The interior galleries were inspired by the Keneseth Israel Temple at Broad and Montgomery, according to a history of the structure written by members of the congregation. The dome at the heart of the building has a 50-foot circumference and reaches 80 feet above street level. More than 100 years after it was built, it might still be the most impressive structure in the neighborhood.

Rabbi Kazan tells me that after World War II, synagogue architecture changed significantly as the communities moved into the suburbs. Each of Strawberry Mansion’s synagogues contained a balcony—or mechitza–where women worshipped separately from men. The new suburban synagogues, which were often called “Jewish community centers,” would have a more open worship space that was accessible to all, with a large room behind the mechitza for recreation. “The newly ordained rabbis were trying to change synagogue architecture to increase interactivity and usefulness for the community,” says Rabbi Kazan.


FaithTemple

Aitz Chaim Nusach Sfard | 3213 West Cumberland Street, Philadelphia, PA 19132

Aitz Chaim Nusach Sfard on Cumberland Street–now home to Faith Temple–was built in 1918. In an old archived photo the Faith Temple sign is visible, but beneath it you can still see two Stars of David in stained glass above the entryway. The Stars have since been replaced with wooden crosses. The Halacha, which contains the commandments of the Jewish faith, says that a synagogue building retains its holiness even after it is no longer used as a house of worship by Jews.


Chevra Thillum Anshe Sfard

Chevra Thillum Anshe Sfard | 3011 West Cumberland Street, Philadelphia, PA 19132

The former Chevra Thillum Anshe Sfard evokes a school building and may have been based on the Tel Sai Yeshiva in Russia. In a photo from the 1990s, there are crosses on the double doors on the front of the synagogue, a modest brick structure built in 1917. Those crosses are now gone, but the big white box cross with the name of the church hanging out over the sidewalk remains. There’s also a Star of David–right underneath the cross and above the doors–in blue stained glass.


B’nai Jeshurun

B’nai Jeshurun | 2117 North 33rd Street, Philadelphia, PA 19121

On 33rd Street, going north along Fairmount Park toward Ridge Avenue, sits the former B’nai Jeshurun, now Cornerstone Baptist Church. A massive white cross hangs over the door and another heads skyward with its crossbar stretching above the roof of the gleaming yellow and brown stone façade. Two short lancet windows let in light on the park side. Above the entrance–under an intricately carved stone arch and between two sets of nested columns–a stone Star of David and menorah floats like a massive beacon high above the street.


17 Comments


  1. Fascinating piece. I’ve seen lots of repurposed synagogues along the Boulevard and in the Wynnefield area, too. I used to find them in Baltimore – Sanborn maps are a good resource for finding them. Definitely worthy of a bigger project.

  2. Interesting. I live in West Oak Lane which also has a lot of repurposed former synagogues. Some of them have distinctive architecture like the one at Old York Road and Stenton, now known as True United Church, which has a frieze of the Twelve Tribes in the facade above the entry doors. One building went through a stint as a Christian church and is now a mosque. Where else in the world would that happen?

    • Check out 6735-37 North 16th St, formerly Ahavath Israel synagogue, designed by Louis I. Kahn.

    • Happened in Spain (cordoba, toledo?). Same building used at different times as synagogue, mosque, church.

    • The building at Old York Rd and Stenton was the old Congregation Emanu-El (until 1985). My family went there when I was a little kid and we lived in Lynnewood Gardens. Julian Preisler’s book “Historic Synagogues of Philadelphia & the Delaware Valley” documents some of these repurposed synagogues.

  3. Bride of the Juggler

    I bet the Kosher Deli you passed was the old Sandler’s deli. I remember going there with my very nervous mother in the 80s. They had a big case inside of smoked turkey parts and ribs. When I visited Roumanian Kosher Sausage Company in Chicago recently, the smell of smoked meat that hit me as I entered brought me right back to visits to Sandler’s. I even remember if you got the nice lady, you got lean corned beef. If you got the mean lady with the mole, you got fatty, badly cut corned beef.

    • My parents were married at B’nai Menashe.
      I believe the original Sandler’s manufacturing facility was near there.
      I remember the “smell” of the hot dogs & salami’s being made!

  4. Excellent. About 20 years ago, I did a discovery tour of ex-synagogues using a 1955 Bulletin Almanac as my guide. I found a place on a north-south street in Strawberry Mansion which had the signs of the zodiac and the names of the months in Hebrew painted on the walls of the second floor balcony.

  5. There is something both beautiful and tragic about this- later generations will probably be more able to see the natural cultural evolution of this- and yet a part of me- given the quality of life in this area cannot help but consider both the loss of the community and the plight of those who relocated there.

  6. When I was a little girl, I went to the Beth Israel synagogue for Sunday School. Across the street was a church. I remember seeing Father Divine standing on the church steps, waving to his congregation. Beth Israel was incorporated into Beth Zion Beth Israel at 18th and Spruce. But I still remember Beth Israel in Strawberry Mansion and Rabbi Finklestein. What sweet memories.

    • My parents were married in Beth Israel in 1930, probably by Rabbi Finkelstein. My grandmother, Hannah Matusow, was a long-time member, president of the Sisterhood, etc. I also started Sunday School there and attended until my immediate family moved to New York when I was in second grade.

  7. Menashe Abrams was my great-grandfather. My family still runs Mt Lebanon Cemetery. Although I was never inside, I am very proud to be able to say I am an offspring of such a great man.

    • My family’s has many grave sites in this cemetery. I still have some that I would give to anyone who would want them

    • Laurie B. Davis

      I have relatives that are supposedly buried at Mount Lebanon Cemetery but I can find no evidence on Find A Grave. Their death certificates state they are buried at Mount Lebanon. Their names are Louis Davis, death 1939 and Fanny Davis, 1945.

      Any help would be greatly appreciated.
      Laurie

  8. Old Synagogue in Strawberry Mansion 2016 N. 32nd St. at Page St.
    I do not remember the name. I actually heard that this synagogue was functioning after 1971.

    https://www.google.com/maps/@39.9873586,-75.1856216,3a,75y,281.43h,99.71t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sQF_ob93SwGpOKPSqisM5DQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656

  9. Ina Silikovitz Burwasser

    When I was a kid, I used to go to B’nai Jeshurun. After the children’s service, they gave out chocolate candy.

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
With A Little Help From Frank Furness, We Evaluate 10 New Projects

With A Little Help From Frank Furness, We Evaluate 10 New Projects

June 23, 2017  |  Vantage

Hidden City architecture critic Jason Lempieri summons the spirit of Frank Furness in this appraisal of Philly's newest urban forms > more

Row House: Past And Its Future

Row House: Past And Its Future

June 20, 2017  |  Vantage

Contributor Hilary Jay dives deep into the evolution and politics of contemporary row house design with Interface Studio Architects > more

An Artful Adaptation In Bella Vista

An Artful Adaptation In Bella Vista

June 15, 2017  |  News

A contemporary art gallery and residence on Bainbridge Street goes green with reuse and sustainable renovation. John Henry Scott has the story > more

Behind The Bar At Dirty Frank's

Behind The Bar At Dirty Frank’s

June 13, 2017  |  The Shadow Knows

The Shadow saddles up to the bar at Dirty Frank's with the backstory on one of Philadelphia's most beloved dives > more

With New Penn's Landing Plan, A Central Park

With New Penn’s Landing Plan, A Central Park

June 12, 2017  |  News

Lost in the intense news cycle: major news about the at-long-last redevelopment of Penn's Landing. Nathaniel Popkin has a look > more

With Bloomsday Near, Remembering The Rosenbach Brothers

With Bloomsday Near, Remembering The Rosenbach Brothers

June 9, 2017  |  Vantage

Every year in June a crowd gathers outside of the Rosenbach Museum & Library to celebrate James Joyce's seminal literary masterpiece "Ulysses" with a block party and day full of public readings. Karen Chernick gives us the backstory on the Rosenbach Company and two rare book dealers whose legacy is enshrined on Delancey Place > more