Dilworth Park, On Balance

 

Weighing design and public appeal at Dilworth Park. | Photo: Bradley Maule

It has been a little over a week now since Dilworth Park has opened, to much fanfare and almost equal dismay. A few usual suspects have weighed in: their general consensus is that money was squandered on a park that doesn’t deliver. Some have approached it with a smart, informed eye while others with impulsive vitriol. How things pan out with Dilworth Park upon completion will ultimately be revealed in time (and Hidden City is waiting until the park is fully completed to provide readers with a design review). Though, now that the dust has settled for the moment I think it is worth stepping back to consider the social impact the park will have on this once famished space. To get a glimpse of the new dynamic culminating there all you have to do is sit and observe.

Let there be light! Glass gateways illuminate the 15th Street entrances to City Hall Station. | Photo: Bradley Maule

On paper, I shouldn’t much like Dilworth Park–and I didn’t expect to. $55 million is a lot to spend on a granite floor. I concur with Inga Saffron’s assessment that the space could use some softening up. Her questions about a private company leasing this historically public space–indeed what in plan is the city’s public living room–are incisive. This issue would benefit from a bit more public scrutiny. What we can and cannot do in front of City Hall is now regulated and enforced by a private company, the Center City District. This feels like a huge overstep.

However, if you spend some time there taking in the crowd and even talking to a stranger or two what you will find is an inclusive public space that is as progressively Philly as one could have hoped for. That is where it succeeds.

OccupyDP2

Lady Justice – Dilworth Plaza, 2011. | Photo: Michael Bixler

The old plaza was a cold, dead place. It was not a space to linger much on your lunch hour nor was it a destination to take your kids to on the weekend. It was tired, bleak, and a little threatening: a perfectly dark-humored metaphor for city government. I know the sun must have shined on Dilworth Plaza but be damned if I can remember when, with the exception of the two months before it closed for construction.

In October 2011 Occupy Philly took up residence at City Hall. Overnight it transformed Dilworth Plaza from a lonely concrete wasteland to a warm and supportive civic space, accomplishing what Occupy Wall Street failed to do. It really was an astonishing scene. I had visited Zuccotti Park in Manhattan on the seventh day of protests and wasn’t particularly impressed. Confusing, half-baked populist rants and fashionable tomfoolery dashed my expectations of a solid working class protest. Many protesters voiced thoughtful, intelligent grievances but these were ultimately drowned out by goofy irreverence. Needless to say I had my doubts on the first day of Occupy Philly.

To understand what was just then developing at Dilworth Plaza you had to be there among the tents, signs and people. I won’t get into the specifics of why they were there other than to say that the downturn of the economy was devastating for many. I met folks from Pottstown to Vineland who had lost their homes to foreclosure, who were disabled and had their veteran benefits cut, people who were working three jobs to pay for their children’s health insurance, and many others who had been laid off. Time again I was told that they came to Dilworth Plaza because they didn’t know where else to go. The people that made up Occupy Philly were scared, angry and hurting, and those fleeting weeks at Dilworth Plaza provided them with temporary collective compassion. So, I immersed myself in it and spent as much time as I could at City Hall, observing, talking to people, and even marching.

OccupyDP1

Tent City – Dilworth Plaza, 2011. | Photo: Michael Bixler

Until Mayor Nutter ordered the police to clear the encampment on November 30th it was evident that Occupy Philly had become an unsung model for all other Occupy encampments. The City and Commissioner Ramsey did a pretty good job, respecting, protecting and policing the Occupiers. Believe it or not, it was a harmonious dichotomy. One detective told me that by order of command the police at Dilworth were required to listen to the First Amendment being read over the radio every morning. You could almost hear Frank Rizzo rolling in his grave. Despite a number of hiccups and a little resentment from the Mayor’s Office toward Occupiers for providing food and shelter to the homeless, it was almost as if the shadow of City Hall had finally been lifted. In the end, it gave Dilworth Plaza an opportunity to shine, and glow it did with the kind of civic engagement that it was intended for.

Before the bulldozers arrived. The last night of Occupy Philly – Dilworth Plaza, 2011. | Photo: Michael Bixler

The last night of Occupy Philly was a sad, deflating occasion. That a $55 million renovation had put a stop to an earnest protest for economic equality was a bit distasteful. The irony stung. Yet, evident even on the first day, Dilworth Park restored the space to the people, real Philadelphia people, and I think in the end it will carry on with what the former plaza finally achieved in October and November of 2011. A few design misgivings aside, I think CCD president Paul Levy and his staff and the designers at Olin and Kieran Timberlake were successful in building a forward-thinking park for everyone. No, you cannot protest without a permit, which is perhaps more than disappointing but where Love Park comes in handy. No, you cannot have public bathrooms, which is cruel and totally boggles the mind. And yes, keeping it clean will be an impossible, Sisyphean undertaking, but that is where private management of the park becomes a godsend.

***

Remembering Occupy Philly. Click any thumbnail to launch gallery.

About the author

Michael Bixler is a writer, photographer, and managing editor of Hidden City Daily. He is a former arts and entertainment reporter with Mountain Xpress weekly in Asheville, North Carolina and a native of South Carolina. Bixler has a keen interest in adaptive reuse, underappreciated architecture, contemporary literature and art, and forward-thinking dialogue about people and place. mmbixler.tumblr.com

Send a message!



2 Comments


  1. Aside from being a mute architectural turd, the cafe near the corner of City Hall is, in my opinion, intrusive.

  2. I enjoyed being in the new Dilworth. I thought the old one was much more dramatic and well-suited to City Hall, with the absence of people being the main problem. To wit:

    The solution could have used interest revenues from a $10 Million endowment (instead of a $10 M demolition project) for promotion of community and arts programs (even if the investment netted only 3%, that’s still $300,000 per year to encourage/pay artists to attract people to the space. The presence of just the artists would discourage people pissing in public in the areas where they performed, and this in turn would allow more people to enjoy the cool hollows of the stone-clad recesses at the foot of City Hall.

    Going forward, crediting the park for a return of people at the tail end of a decade of decreasing urban crime and after the recent opening of a high-rise condo 50 steps across the street, would be a stretch. Doing none of the construction at all, but executing the intensive maintenance and cultural programming now underway, might have yielded similar results to what we have now, at a fraction of the cost.

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

 

Recent Posts
The Best Seats In The City, Ban Be Damned

The Best Seats In The City, Ban Be Damned

January 16, 2017  |  Buzz

Last week Friends of Rittenhouse Square and PPR announced a ban from sitting on the interior walls of Rittenhouse Square. Two days later Mayor Jim Kenney reversed the rule. We take a look at life along the balustrades in these old photos > more

Capturing The Ghosts Of Demolition

Capturing The Ghosts Of Demolition

January 13, 2017  |  Last Light

The demolition composites of photographer Andrew Evans beguile the eye with ghostly images of a city passing through time. Evans presents his newest additions to the series and explains his process with this photo essay > more

Pencoyd Bridge Reopens In Manayunk, As Redevelopment Of Foundry Site Begins

Pencoyd Bridge Reopens In Manayunk, As Redevelopment Of Foundry Site Begins

January 11, 2017  |  Vantage

The deserted industrial site of Pencoyd Iron Works is next on a growing list of riverside redevelopment along the Schuylkill. Contributor Mick Ricereto takes us deep inside the history of the family-owned foundry and farmland that dates back to the city's founding > more

Urban Fantasy: The Carousel Maker Of Broad & Erie

Urban Fantasy: The Carousel Maker Of Broad & Erie

January 10, 2017  |  The Shadow Knows

Traditional carousel design may have roots in Europe, but "Philadelphia Style" took the amusement ride to a whole new level. The Shadow takes a stroll down Germantown Avenue where the G.A. Dentzel Carousel Company became the gold standard in animal kingdom merry-go-rounds > more

Lost Buildings Of 2016

Lost Buildings Of 2016

December 30, 2016  |  Vantage

That cheery, time-honored tradition: the year-end list. Here on the Daily, that means a roundup of the year's demolitions in our World Heritage City. Brad Maule finds 2016's list warrants more than just a top ten > more

Unlisted Philadelphia: John Decker & Son

Unlisted Philadelphia: John Decker & Son

December 28, 2016  |  Vantage

Ben Leech spotlights unique and significant buildings not listed on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places with his architectural illustration series, Unlisted Philadelphia. With this installment, a kingly cornice in Brewerytown > more