End Of The Road For Atonement (UPDATED)

 

Dust to dust: central aisle of the Church of the Atonement sanctuary | Photo: Bradley Maule

Dust to dust: central aisle of the Church of the Atonement sanctuary | Photo: Bradley Maule

On Friday, City Paper staffer (and former Hidden City contributor) Ryan Briggs reported on the impending demolition of the Protestant Episcopal Church of the Atonement in Southwest Philadelphia (or West Philadelphia, depending on whether you use Baltimore Avenue or the SEPTA Elwyn Line as the boundary). The Department of Licenses and Inspections told Briggs demolition would begin yesterday, Monday, June 9.

Unsecured chain link fence surrounds the tower at Church of the Atonement | Photo: Bradley Maule

Unsecured chain link fence surrounds the tower at Church of the Atonement | Photo: Bradley Maule

As reported by Christopher Mote for Hidden City last year, the church has occupied the southwest corner of 47th Street and Kingsessing Avenue since 1900. It was built to replace the former parish at 17th and Summer Streets, where the Church of the Atonement was founded in 1847, and has been known as St. Peter’s Church of Christ since 1979.

The church’s design came from the office of Furness, Evans & Co., the final iteration of Frank Furness’ architecture firm, which continued under that name until 1932—twenty years after his death. As Furness goes, the church is relatively understated from the outside, even compared to the parish house next door, completed in 1892. Michael Lewis, author of Frank Furness: Architecture and the Violent Mind (2001), has a theory on the church, which does not appear in the book.

“You’re correct that it doesn’t look like Furness in his prime, as the earlier parish house does,” Lewis said via email from Berlin. “By [1900] the office was big enough that other architects on his staff could develop projects based on Furness’s guidance and advice; I think this is clearly one of those.”

A photograph of the church does appear, however, in an earlier book Lewis co-authored, Frank Furness: The Complete Works, Revised Edition (1996). And, he added, the Philadelphia Inquirer published an illustration on January 8, 1900, credited to Furness, Evans & Co.

The church’s composition is at its best inside the vaulted main chapel, particularly when the early morning and late afternoon light casts a golden hue over the congregation. Stained glass windows by Franz Mayer & Company of Munich, Germany, bookend the front and back of the nave.

The holy water font has been littered from years of crashing stained glass | Photo: Bradley Maule

The holy water font has been littered from years of crashing stained glass | Photo: Bradley Maule

As of 5pm yesterday, only a non-secured chain link fence placed around the base of the tower on the corner of 47th & Kingsessing indicated any sign of demolition activity. No L&I notices were visible on the building’s exterior, and one that had previously been posted on the Kingsessing-side doors were removed, leaving adhesive behind. Briggs’ City Paper story reported that Sprint removed their cell phone equipment from the tower last week.

A homemade sign on pink paper posted to telephone poles surrounding the church asked neighbors to “Please help our neighborhood! … Based on recent events involving L&I, the city and demolition (The Salvation Army, Elena’s Soul lounge on 49th and Baltimore and most recently Hoops Deli on 42nd and Chester) we are concerned that the work be done with proper care and under proper supervision.” The unsigned note continued, asking residents to make their presence known and “hang around, observe the process and visibly take photos.”

Several attempts to reach L&I for comment, to determine when the demolition would start if not yesterday, whether anything would be salvaged, and which contractor would be handling the demolition, proved unsuccessful. Hidden City was told all press requests must now go directly through Commissioner Carlton Williams, per his order. Two phone calls and two emails to him went unreturned. UPDATE: An L&I spokesperson confirms that, after the court order calling for demolition, the agency will move forward with those plans as soon as Sprint has finished removing its equipment, which includes cell phone mechanisms inside the tower in addition to the equipment already removed from the roof. Once that has finished, L&I will bid the demolition out, and once contracts are lined up, demolition will begin.

The most recent violation posted to L&I’s web site was for unsecured access to a vacant building on February 25. The entry was updated March 31 with “clean and seal.”

In early 2013, a Celtic cross crashed to the sidewalk on 47th Street overnight, fortunately injuring no one. Several support columns inside the church had severe cracks, and entire portions of the floor had caved in. St. Peter’s Church of Christ’s congregation still meets in the parish house next door.

Across 47th Street from Atonement stands the Crusaders for Christ Church, built as the Fourth Presbyterian Church in 1897 with a design from Hazlehurst & Huckel. That church is in active use and appears to be in decent shape.

* * *

For a photo essay of Church of the Atonement’s deteriorated state from April 2013, see HERE.

About the author

Bradley Maule is co-editor of the Hidden City Daily and the creator of Philly Skyline. He's a native of Tyrone, Pennsylvania, and he's hung his hat in Shippensburg, Germantown, G-Ho, Fishtown, Portland OR, Brewerytown, and now Mt. Airy. He just can't get into Twitter, but he's way into Instagram @mauleofamerica.



12 Comments


  1. Chandra Lampreich

    It was only a matter of time, sadly. I had noticed a lot of changes here over the years with things going missing, likely as scrap or salvage.

  2. Another church bites the dust. Really too bad they cannot be used for something else. But…..a church is a church, re-use as something else seems to be a no go proposition. Too bad lots of good memories in any church.

    • Lots of churches are re-used for other purposes. Many are retrofitted into housing elsewhere while we prefer the suburban model of urban “renewal”. Philadelphia lags behind other cities in this kind of preservation. It’s a lack of creative thinking on the part of the powers that be.

      • NickFromGermantown

        It does happen though. The main problem is probably the economics of the deal. Retrofitting the churches are expensive propositions.

      • Thanks for that info Davis. Would you mind telling me where these “many” churches are? I know of one large church in Philly that was converted to apartments. On some tv shows I saw some (small) country churches converted into houses. But, just curious, where are all (many) churches at and what are they now being used for?

        • In Boston at least 2 are in the Back Bay – converted into condominiums. I have seen them turned into marketplaces and of course theaters. In the UK it is the routine to utilize such buildings in a thoughtful way when possible. Is it costly? Well often but not always prohibitively. But if the point to every decision made in Philadelphia is the bottom line, then we are in a very sad situation in my view.

          My point was also to lament what passes for residential development in hardscrabble neighborhoods all across the city.

          • In Philadelphia, as well as many other cities these days, it always comes down to the bottom line. Thanks to the inability of our elected representatives to utilize the money they receive in a wise manner.
            And in the long run, more churches are demolished than converted into other uses. I always thought a good use for a abandoned church would be a restaurant. Do you know of any?

        • Per your comment below, no restaurant conversions in Philadelphia (yet), but many other successful rehabs:
          http://hiddencityphila.org/2013/05/how-to-reuse-a-church-our-top-ten/
          You have to go to Pittsburgh for the restaurant/brew pub:
          http://www.churchbrew.com/

          • Don’t forget the Swedenborgian church at 2129 Chestnut (Chandler, 1881-3)which has been beautifully restored as offices, see Historic Sacred Places of Philadelphia, by Roger Moss, for some great pictures.

            Historically, Churches did not have fixed pews, and the sanctuary space could be open and used for all sorts of community uses, even markets, in the wide-open space. Could the stained glass windows and other church adornments be removed, the building stabalized, then used as a modern-day shambles, or market?

  3. Thank you.

  4. Where is the Preservation Alliance? I have been in several back and forth arguments with various people at that office and the response I get is, “well, you can do something about it if you want but our resources are limited”.

    They concentrate most of their money into CENTER CITY the LEAST LIKELY of all locations in Philadelphia to suffer from this sort of incident. Meaning – the residents of rittenhouse or society hill would hardly suffer from a church decaying to this state and being demolished EVEN WITHOUT the Preservation Alliance. THEY AND THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY ARE A JOKE. Unless it concerns Betsy Ross, or a wealthy patron they could care less.

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
With A Little Help From Frank Furness, We Evaluate 10 New Projects

With A Little Help From Frank Furness, We Evaluate 10 New Projects

June 23, 2017  |  Vantage

Hidden City architecture critic Jason Lempieri summons the spirit of Frank Furness in this appraisal of Philly's newest urban forms > more

Row House: Past And Its Future

Row House: Past And Its Future

June 20, 2017  |  Vantage

Contributor Hilary Jay dives deep into the evolution and politics of contemporary row house design with Interface Studio Architects > more

An Artful Adaptation In Bella Vista

An Artful Adaptation In Bella Vista

June 15, 2017  |  News

A contemporary art gallery and residence on Bainbridge Street goes green with reuse and sustainable renovation. John Henry Scott has the story > more

Behind The Bar At Dirty Frank's

Behind The Bar At Dirty Frank’s

June 13, 2017  |  The Shadow Knows

The Shadow saddles up to the bar at Dirty Frank's with the backstory on one of Philadelphia's most beloved dives > more

With New Penn's Landing Plan, A Central Park

With New Penn’s Landing Plan, A Central Park

June 12, 2017  |  News

Lost in the intense news cycle: major news about the at-long-last redevelopment of Penn's Landing. Nathaniel Popkin has a look > more

With Bloomsday Near, Remembering The Rosenbach Brothers

With Bloomsday Near, Remembering The Rosenbach Brothers

June 9, 2017  |  Vantage

Every year in June a crowd gathers outside of the Rosenbach Museum & Library to celebrate James Joyce's seminal literary masterpiece "Ulysses" with a block party and day full of public readings. Karen Chernick gives us the backstory on the Rosenbach Company and two rare book dealers whose legacy is enshrined on Delancey Place > more