The Newest Part Of The Oldest Theater

 

That tall drink o' water in the sun on the right over | Photo: Bradley Maule

That tall drink o’ water in the sun on the right over there | Photo: Bradley Maule

Anyone who patronizes the Walnut Street Theatre may notice that the entrance is not in the theatre’s front door but in an alcove along the eastern side of the building. That alcove, located at 825 Walnut Street, is the first floor of a 98-year-old building that has only been a part of the theater since 1971. For years I’ve wondered about this building, with its thin and intricately detailed façade, but I struggled to determine its origin or architect.

Herkness Property at 825 Walnut connects to the family's Bazasr in this 1875 Map | Souce: G. M. Bromley map, philageohistory.org

Herkness Property at 825 Walnut connects to the family’s Bazaar in this 1875 Map | Source: G. M. Bromley map, philageohistory.org

As I’ve become better at recognizing the styles of individual architects over the years, I noticed that the façade of this mysterious building has design elements in common with buildings by architect Frederick Webber, who also designed 1830 Rittenhouse Square, the Vida Apartment Building at 15th and Locust, and the Sheridan Building at 125 South 9th Street, which shares a party wall with 825 Walnut. According to city property records, both the Sheridan Building and 825 Walnut were built in the same year: 1916.

In fact, these two buildings stand on what used to be one property. For 75 years, this land was the location of Herkness Bazaar, an 1840-built Cyclorama building that became an auction house for horses and carriages. A 25′ x 143′ patch of land that was part of the Herkness Bazaar property stretched all the way back to Walnut Street, directly adjacent to the Walnut Street Theater. By the end of the 19th Century, a short retail storefront/office stood here, briefly home to the W.B. Saunders Company before they moved to their iconic building on Washington Square.

In 1915, the same year Herkness Bazaar was demolished, two calls for bids for two completely different buildings appear for the corner of Ninth and Sansom. One calls for a $500,000, 10-story building, just like the Sheridan Building, and the other calls for a 6-story “loft building”, just like the 825 Walnut. The only other things in common these bids had were their architect and owner: Frederick Webber and S.P. Wetherill, respectively.

Looking pretty sad in 1966 | Source: Philadelphia Historical Commission via the Philadelphia Architects and Buildings Project

Looking pretty sad in 1966 | Source: Philadelphia Historical Commission via the Philadelphia Architects and Buildings Project

Samuel P. Wetherill and Frederick Webber had an established working relationship. After 1910, Wetherill was in post-retirement life, having recently bowed out from the paint and chemical company that bore his name. He spent his twilight years in the speculative real estate game, running an office out of the Robert Morris Building right next to Webber, who himself was recently divorced from his partnership in an architecture firm. A perfect storm of architectural brains and entrepreneurial braun, Webber designed nearly all of the real estate that Wetherill built between 1911-1922.

Therefore, it is my contention that this building was designed by Frederick Webber, commissioned by S.P. Wetherill, who bought the former Herkness property that consisted of both 125-137 South 9th Street and 825 Walnut Street and developed it as two separate properties.

The first major office tenant of the 825 Walnut building after it was completed in 1916 was the newly-formed Keystone Equipment Company. This company produced machinery and lubricating devices. In later years, they became famous for their innovative home repair tools like the Colton Tool Holder. They shared the building with Thomas V. Hopper & Sons, makers of plate printers and dye stampers, who also had offices in the Sheridan Building.

By 1920, the Raymond & McNutt (later Raymond-McNutt) Company, who made greeting cards, moved into the building. They started out small, sharing the building with two clothing companies. Over the next couple of years they grew to consume the entire place. They named the building the Raymon & McNutt Building (the only name the building ever had besides its address) and continued to grow until moving out for more space in 1925. Their space was taken over by the Liberty Printing Company, who shared the building with the Apfelbaum & Elias clothing company and the McClenaghen Optical Company. Liberty Printing moved out in the late 30s and later merged with Pearl-Pressman to become Pearl-Pressman-Liberty in 1953, a company that still exists today.

Lookin' pretty good these days | Photo: Bradley Maule

Lookin’ pretty good these days | Photo: Bradley Maule

From the late 1930s and through the 40s, the building was split between the Dittmar Engraving Company and the Laskin and Abrams Clothing Company. After that, the building fell into such disrepair that only the first floor storefront and a couple of the upper floors remained usable. The New Liberty Printing Company, no doubt named in homage to the old Liberty Printing Company, made use of the space during this period.

On February 2, 1970, the Walnut Street Theatre Corporation purchased the old Raymond-McNutt Building. They restored the façade and incorporated the building into the historic theater, making the first floor its new box office. They converted the upper floors into business offices, studios, and rehearsal space. The completely restored building opened along with the newly restored theater on October 16th, 1971 and has been associated ever since, even giving over its address, 825 Walnut, as the new address of the Walnut Street Theatre.

The mini-tower holds two small theaters, the Walnut’s education and business offices, two large rehearsal halls, the costume shop, and other spaces used for classroom and camp activities. Despite all of that, the extra space provided by 825 Walnut isn’t enough. The Walnut also maintains an off-site warehouse.

Currently, the old Raymond-McNutt Building is an essential part of the oldest continuously operating theater in America, more like a 90-foot-tall wing than a building separate from the 1809 original (an all-star building featuring William Strickland’s stage and John Haviland’s façade).

About the author

GroJLart is the anonymous foulmouthed blogger of Philaphilia, where he critiques Philadelphia architecture, history, and design. He resides in Washington Square West. GroJLart has contributed to Naked Philly, the Philadelphia City Paper's Naked City Blog, and Philadelphia Magazine's Property Blog.



7 Comments


  1. The old Walnut St. Theatre’s claim to being the oldest legitimate theatre in the U.S.is false,or to put it poliely:historically inaccurate.The oldest theatre,predating the Revolution is in Charleston,SC,c.1726.

    • William: the theatre you’re talking about is the Dock Street Theatre in Charleston. But that theatre was destroyed by a fire in 1740. A hotel was built on the site in 1809 (the same year the Walnut opened), and the hotel was converted to a theatre in 1937. A building that’s only been used as a theatre for the past 77 years (and not continuously during that time) is HARDLY the same thing as a theatre that’s been operating continuously in one site for over 200 years. (Which is what the Walnut’s claim is – it never claimed to be the first theatre in the U.S.)
      Pretty building, though: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dock_Street_Theatre

    • Yes, if we’re going to be technical about it, the first theater in the British colonies was in Williamsburg, built in 1716. Unfortunately neither it, nor any of its immediate successors in that town (1751, 1760) survived the eighteenth century, except for a small portion of the last one that remains as a shed attached to a colonial house.

    • I worked at the walnut street theatre for nearly two years, so please check your facts.

  2. That building that used to sit on what’s now the parking lot next door looked pretty sexy, like a mini Strawbridge’s. I wonder if you know anything about it…

  3. Excellent recap of an often overlooked building.

Recent Posts
Hot Or Not, Part II: A Drive-By Critique

Hot Or Not, Part II: A Drive-By Critique

September 17, 2014  |  Soapbox

New construction in Philadelphia is on fire right now. Perfect timing to feature another episode of "Hot or Not," courtesy of our indespensible drive-by architecture critic Jason Lempieri > more

City Hall Apron To Be Redone

City Hall Apron To Be Redone

September 17, 2014  |  Morning Blend

Improvements for Dilworth Park’s visual flow, more details on the Bridesburg land swap with Dietz and Watson, Philly Bike Share locations, and a “creative hub” in Brewerytown > more

Dilworth Park, On Balance

Dilworth Park, On Balance

September 16, 2014  |  Soapbox

The new Dilworth Park at City Hall has drawn a considerable amount of criticism since opening last week. Despite a few misgivings, Michael Bixler thinks that there may be a silver lining: inclusive, public appeal > more

Preliminary Plans For Maplewood Mall Presented To Germantown Residents

Preliminary Plans For Maplewood Mall Presented To Germantown Residents

September 16, 2014  |  Morning Blend

A community meeting unveils early design thoughts for the corridor revitalization, previewing phase 3 of Fishtown’s Icehouse, Penn teams up with Swiss firm for innovative cancer research facility on its campus, and Dranoff musing on the market > more

An Antique Swimming Hole Under The El

An Antique Swimming Hole Under The El

September 15, 2014  |  The Shadow Knows

A public bath for five decades, this brick-arched beauty now houses a brush and broom manufacturer. The Shadow dives into the history of this sunken treasure under the El > more

Redevelopment In Fishtown Threatened By NIMBYs

Redevelopment In Fishtown Threatened By NIMBYs

September 15, 2014  |  Morning Blend

Samschick’s lynchpin draws the ire of the myopic, Two Liberty Place scraps hotel plan for condos, 30 more police for the Northeast, and some selective gentrification concern in Point Breeze > more