Time Running Out At St. Bonaventure

 

Soon to tower no more: St. Bonaventure's steeple on North 9th Street | Photo: Bradley Maule

Soon to tower no more: St. Bonaventure’s steeple on North 9th Street | Photo: Bradley Maule

The former St. Bonaventure Roman Catholic Church will not tower over North Philadelphia for much longer.

With shingles and entire sections missing, St. Bonaventure's steeple is "imminently dangerous" | Photo: Bradley Maule

With shingles and entire sections missing, St. Bonaventure’s steeple is “imminently dangerous” | Photo: Bradley Maule

The Department of Licenses & Inspections is set to take action on the church’s deteriorating steeple due to the inaction of its owner, L&I spokesperson Rebecca Swanson said. The church’s condition is now classified as imminently dangerous, which gives the City the authority to perform emergency demolition work.

L&I is currently analyzing the structure of the Gothic revival church at Ninth and Cambria Streets to determine exactly how much must be demolished to make it safe. Besides the steeple, the church’s exterior walls are missing bricks and the roof is partially collapsed.

Swanson estimated that demolition work could commence within two weeks, after the job is bidded out to a City contractor and the owners—Bishop Carswell Jackson and the New Life Evangelistic Church—are given final notice.

St. Bonaventure was designed by prolific church architect Edwin Forrest Durang in 1894, construction completed in 1906. In 1993, it became one of a dozen churches shuttered by the Archdiocese, many of them in low-income neighborhoods of North Philadelphia. For photographs of the church’s interior, click HERE.

The church was cited for violations after near neighbors complained about slate shingles from the spire falling onto the street. The case was sent to Equity Court, but according to Swanson, it never moved forward because L&I could not reach the owners via secured mail.

However, sources close to Jackson report that he was aware of the deadline that the City had given him, as he had hoped to raise funds to stabilize the steeple before the church became imminently dangerous.

St. Bonaventure and the Quaker-owned Fair Hill Burial Ground (opened 1703) have been neighbors for 119 years | Photo: Bradley Maule

St. Bonaventure and the Quaker-owned Fair Hill Burial Ground (opened 1703) have been neighbors for 119 years | Photo: Bradley Maule

Jackson’s network of churches is headquartered in northern New Jersey. He did not respond to requests for comment.

Demolition costs, which would be taken out as a lien against the property, could run into the hundreds of thousands of dollars. Swanson said that the contractor will adhere to strict safety assessments to protect residents on the block and the foundations of the adjacent buildings.

The New Life congregation had been using the red brick building to the south—the original St. Bonaventure school and church, which dates from 1890—for worship and Sunday school services. The former St. Bonaventure parish house to the north, now occupied by Women of Excellence, a shelter for the homeless, and the former rectory to the rear of the church on Hutchinson Street used by Hannah House, a reentry program for women, are in good condition.

* * *

Michael Greenle contributed to the reporting of this story.

For photos of the interior by Chandra Lampreich, see HERE.

About the author

Christopher Mote covers stories of preservation, planning, zoning and development. He lives in South Philadelphia and has a special fondness for brownstone churches and mansard roofs.

Send him a message at: motecw[at]hotmail[dot]com



3 Comments


  1. I think the saddest part in all of this is that the church will come down without anyone attempting to do anything about it. Such is the state of historical preservation in Philadelphia…

  2. The photo from Fairhill Cemetery says it all – what we will lose all on account of The Almighty Dollar.

  3. Are the owners even trying to unload this? I know churches are hard to reuse, but . . .

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled, no need to resubmit any comments posted.

Recent Posts
A History Of Leadership During Philadelphia's Epidemics

A History Of Leadership During Philadelphia’s Epidemics

July 21, 2017  |  Vantage

Contributor Sam Dunnington examines disease outbreaks in Philadelphia and the individuals that helped the city navigate its most deadly epidemics > more

La Salle University Tears Down Historic Victorian Home

La Salle University Tears Down Historic Victorian Home

July 19, 2017  |  News

Another historic home is demolished by La Salle University for campus expansion > more

Shaping Up And Shipping Out At Philadelphia's First Navy Yard

Shaping Up And Shipping Out At Philadelphia’s First Navy Yard

July 18, 2017  |  Harry K's Encyclopedia

Harry K sets sail for South Philly where shipbuilding and national defense once defined the Delaware River waterfront > more

Demolition Of Two Neighborhood Sanctuaries Begins

Demolition Of Two Neighborhood Sanctuaries Begins

July 14, 2017  |  News

Two historic churches meet the wrecking ball this week. Michael Bixler reports > more

Marked Potential: Film Exchange Building

Marked Potential: Film Exchange Building

July 12, 2017  |  Marked Potential

Shila Griffith is back with the latest and last edition of her column, Market Potential. In this final piece, Griffith reinvents a vacant, Mid-century Modern landmark near Chinatown as a cooperative cooking space for culinary entrepreneurs > more

Old Mansion Hangs Tough On Chestnut Street

Old Mansion Hangs Tough On Chestnut Street

July 10, 2017  |  The Shadow Knows

Rittenhouse Square is full of sturdy, old mansions, but you would be hard-pressed to find one as resilient as this. The Shadow has the lowdown on this tenacious Queen Ann Revival home at 22nd and Chestnut Streets > more