TOD Is Here; Now Let’s Make It Really Work For Us


Hello TOD, Watcha Knowin?

Damen El stop, Chicago | Image: Steve Vance

In Chicago’s Wicker Park neighborhood just northwest of downtown, where Midwest hipsters collide with upwardly mobile YPs, El stops are the puncture points of some of the most active, vibrant streets and most densely built neighborhood corners in the city.

The Damen stop in particular is so successful that nearby the Flat Iron Building and Milwaukee Avenue have come to characterize Wicker Park as an urban regional arts destination. Thanks in large part to this intensifying urban pattern, what planners call transit oriented development, a place was born and a neighborhood defined.

But in Philly’s rapid transit paradigm, the Damens of the world are the exceptions to the rule. Outside of Center City and University City, development around Philly’s high volume transit stations is too often characterized by drive-thrus, gas stations, and parking lots. This is transit under-development.

Looking through the graffiti, Girard El stop | Photo: Theresa Stigale

One step off any of the three El stops that serve the Northern Liberties and Fishtown, roughly comparable places to Wicker Park, and you’re unlikely to encounter iconic, neighborhood defining buildings or vibrant shopping streets. Instead, you’ll get a drive-thru McDonald’s, a one-story Deal$, or a downright anti-urban Delilah’s. In contrast to Damen, there are few resulting attributes that contribute a sense of place and neighborhood identity (aside from incoherence), and, critically, reduced interest in transit.

This leaves us with a rather striking under-utilization of prime urban real estate in high demand areas that could be filled to the brim with potential transit riders and neighborhood services.

All This is About to Change

Wayne Junction station renovation, part of a future Wayne Junction TOD overlay | Photo: Hidden City Daily

Philly’s urban planners are a smart bunch; they understand the city’s land utilization-mass transit mismatch like Planning 101 students know Jane Jacob’s four principles to healthy cities. Armed with this recognition, for the first time, they have codified TOD overlay districts as part of the City’s brand new zoning code. Through Philadelphia 2035 they hope to officially put TOD on the map.

Googling the location of these districts won’t do you any good–they haven’t been mapped yet. According to Jennifer Barr and Natalie Shieh, staff planners of the City Planning Commission, they will be defined through Philadelphia 2035’s district planning process which is ongoing.

True, a number of district plans have already been completed, but Barr says TOD has yet to be an appropriate recommendation in those plans. But, TOD fanatics, don’t fret, she says that “the current Central District Plan will include recommended sites.”

The City is banking on overlays to assist in establishing a more coherent public realm in and around transit stops. This means allowing higher density development, reducing parking requirements, and encouraging a higher mix of uses right when you hop off the train.

Paseo Verde rising next to Temple University station | Photo: Theresa Stigale

At 9th and Berks, just northwest of the Northern Liberties, the non-profit APM is bringing 120 units of housing, retail, office space (and reduced parking) to a parcel immediately adjacent to the Temple University Regional Rail station, SEPTA’s fourth busiest.

In the proposed overlays, city planners envision scaling up from a single Paseo Verde kind of development to ultimately create what can become an entire transit-oriented neighborhood.

To accomplish this, a lot of up-front work needs to happen. This is where the district planning process comes in. “Ideally, as part of the district planning process, the community, in conjunction with the City Planning staff, will define ideal places for TOD and create a vision for what it could look like,” explains Barr who is currently working on the Central District Plan. “Then, City Council will adopt what the community wants, which will effectively make the overlay the law of that land.”

“We’re looking for the TOD overlay districts to make a big impact, so we’re going to place them in high demand areas that are ripe for redevelopment and haven’t realized their potential,” explains Barr.

About the author

Greg Meckstroth is an urban planner/designer, freelance writer, and recent Philly transplant. Greg received a Master of Community Planning from the University of Cincinnati in 2009 and has spent the last few years bouncing around the private sector planning world, more recently moving to Philly to work for a nationally renowned design firm in Center City. He also writes for Flying Kite Media and blogs at the Philadelphia Real Estate Blog. Twitter follow: @GMeckstroth.

Send a message!



5 Comments


  1. Will the dynamics of a block like 2nd and Girard ever change? There, any potential for transit-oriented development appears to be blocked by seemingly permanent installations – 7-Eleven and McDonalds – which are both national chains located in a high-traffic area, and presumably are highly profitable franchises.

    • While there might be some pushback from these groups, bringing them into the equation could be even more useful. The promise of even higher traffic could persuade them to buy into a TOD. National chains have been successful because they are willing to adapt to the environment, communities just need to make it clear to these chains that the paradigms have changed and that they will profit more if they adapt.

      Also, does anyone happen to have any information on the Wayne Junction TOD overlay? I

      • Also, I think that any Regional Rail TOD would be vastly strengthened by the development of an S-Bahn Regional Rail system. Trains running every hour or half hour will not attract people to pay more for TOD living.

  2. What would be more profitable? A one story McD’s and a 7-11 with surface parking? Or a McD’s and a 7-11 on the first floor of a 5-story mixed use building in a vibrant TOD neighborhood?

    • Exactly, there might be a higher barrier of entry to getting in larger businesses given their scale, but most businesses are open to adaptation. Even the famously suburban Walmart is incorporating one of its locations into a TOD project in DC.

Trackbacks

  1. North Central’s Paseo Verde Set For Spring Completion | Hidden City Philadelphia
  2. Lunchtime Quick Hits | Philadelphia Real Estate Blog
  3. Zoning for TOD: A Point of Clarification | Philadelphia Planeto
Recent Posts
Haunting Holmesburg Prison

Haunting Holmesburg Prison

October 31, 2014  |  Last Light

It's Halloween and we've rounded up the work of seven photographers for a super-sized photo essay on creepy Holmesburg Prison. Enjoy! > more

Temple’s Next 15 Years

Temple’s Next 15 Years

October 31, 2014  |  Morning Blend

Temple releases latest plan, Bartram’s Mile fully funded, Penn Museum official talks up Philly as World Heritage City material, and senior living center in Roxborough opens > more

Bid Process Reveals Uncertain Future For Delaware Power Station

Bid Process Reveals Uncertain Future For Delaware Power Station

October 30, 2014  |  Developing Challenges, News

Bids for purchase and redevelopment of the Delaware Power Station are due Monday at 5PM. What will they tell us about the monumental building's future? Ryan Briggs talks to some experts and considers the future of this part of the Delaware waterfront > more

The Case For Logan Square

The Case For Logan Square

October 30, 2014  |  Morning Blend

Why the current thinking about the Parkway’s transformation needs to be more ambitious, development anxiety in Powelton Village, Brickstone’s latest acquistions in Midtown, and Councilwoman gets her district office > more

Saying Goodbye To Stokes House

Saying Goodbye To Stokes House

October 29, 2014  |  News

The end is near for the Stokes house of Holme Circle. Despite efforts by a local civic association to save the 19th century stone farmhouse at 2976 Welsh Road, it will be razed any day now for new residential development. Hidden City co-editor Michael Bixler took a trip out to Holmesburg to bid the building a fond farewell > more

Getting A Pedestrian-Driven Main Street Right In Center City

Getting A Pedestrian-Driven Main Street Right In Center City

October 29, 2014  |  Morning Blend

Chestnut Walk as a new kind of Center City street, the multiplying effects of pop-up gardens, Penn to break ground on South Bank, and angry parents unleash on Walter Palmer > more