Value In Toynbee Tiles? Art Thieves Think So

September 6, 2012 |  by  |  News  |  , , ,

 

Last week there was a tile where the stone is at the bottom of this photo | Photo: Steve Weinik

When work by the street artist Banksy started selling for hundreds of thousands of dollars, big rectangular holes began appearing in the walls where his art used to be. This isn’t unique to Banksy. Street art theft has become relatively common because the work is vulnerable and potentially worth a lot of money.

Last week, a local photographer reported “two guys in their mid-20s with putty knives” attempting to “pry up” Toynbee tiles in Center City. Their apparent goal was to sell the tiles.

Toynbee tiles are linoleum mosaics found embedded in city streets in North and South America. They’ve appeared in crosswalks, parking lots, exit ramps, rest areas and in the middle of highways since the early 1980s. They’re the creation of an anonymous Philadelphian and bear a message calling for the physical resurrection of all human life on Jupiter. However you take the message, the tiles are appropriately regarded as works of art and the tiler as this art medium’s creator. His technique has been copied by street artists around the world.

In 2011, I was a subject and researcher for Resurrect Dead, a documentary that examined the mystery of the tiles. With unexpected success and a wide distribution, the movie has reached the point where art thieves of the world have taken notice.

Of these thieves, the Philadelphia duo has been spotted at least three times. In St. Louis, a security guard witnessed a man removing a 15-20 year old tile from the corner of Sixth and Olive streets. When asked what he was doing, he reportedly told the guard that “it was going to be worth a lot of money.” That tile is now gone.

If left undisturbed, Toynbee tiles can last as long as the asphalt. The tile fragment in the photo at the top of this article, at Ninth and Locust Streets was recently revealed by the erosion of crosswalk paint. It’s 20-30 years old.

4th and South Street Toynbee Tile | Photo: Steve Weinik

A tile at Fourth and South Streets survived in good condition from the early-1990s until road resurfacing in December, 2008.

When well set, tiles sit flush with the asphalt and are extremely hard to remove. The Philly thieves aren’t using heavy duty tools and from what I can tell, they’ve been relatively unsuccessful in removing them. One small tile from around 2004 was pried from the northwest corner of Juniper and Chestnut.

Tile preserved by crosswalk paint | Photo: Steve Weinik

Of course, whatever their value is as art or as a commodity, all the tiles are ultimately doomed. As durable a material as it is, Linoleum erodes and streets are fairly often repaved. At least a dozen tiles were destroyed by routine roadwork in the past couple of weeks. Whatever the intention of the thieves, at some level they’re doing a service in preserving the physical artifact. In no way do I condone what they’re doing, but it’s instructive to acknowledge the accidental benefit that may come from it.

While most street art is meant to be temporary, and the question of preservation essentially contradictory to the work’s original intent, the tiles are different. I can’t speak for the creator, but have a pretty good idea that the message and the idea presented trumps the art. We do know that tiles were embedded in the street to make them as public and permanent as possible–tiling was a direct reaction to the impermanence of paper signs.

 

Ventnor City NJ has paved around this decades old tile, preserving it and other tiles for unknown reasons | Photo: Justin Duerr

With that said, thievery isn’t the only way to preserve these unique pieces of art. Why not carve them out, secure them, protect them and display them publicly? I envision a series of Toynbee Idea lightbox displays, preserved tiles inside, attached to street lampposts, buildings, and bus shelters around town. At the very least, an interested museum or preservation body can work with the Streets Department to save a small collection of tiles before scheduled street repairs.

Why save them? Perhaps for no other reason than their perceived value in the art market. I’m eager to work with any organization or group interested in preserving this odd aspect of Philadelphia culture and history.

About the author

Steve Weinik works a photographer for the City of Philadelphia Mural Arts Program. He also freelances in photography, writing and documentary film. His work has been widely published in print and on screen. You can see more at steveweinik.com.



7 Comments


  1. Street Photographer

    Good story.

  2. recession special.

  3. Hellion cult steals and destroys tiles. You must make and glue tiles. YOU!

  4. Yeah, so many of them are gone – it’s depressing to follow the online maps and come up empty. It would be great if somehow we could convince the city to preserve at least one or two in a museum or something, but over time they may simply be lost. It’s sad and exasperating to think of the tiles lost to the city and preserved only on some rich guy’s wall, but that’s what happens to a lot of art, isn’t it?
    They’ll always be preserved in photos and great films like the beautiful documentary Steve helped make. I’m including references to the tiles in the novel I’m working on now.
    The tiles are so compelling and enigmatic – I hope somebody can get the city interested in doing the right thing and preserve an authentic Philly mystery.

  5. The tile near the northeast corner of 6th and Olive in downtown St. Louis has been stolen in the last few weeks.

  6. I’ve been tracking these tiles for years. It’s sad to think someone would steal them. Also a lot of them are vanishing because of the repaving project that is happening in the city. Slowly I’m seeing them all disappear. I’d rather see more alike tiles be put down then someone take them. Just sayin

  7. If anyone is interested in learning more about the Tonybee Tiles – checkout the documentary “Resurrect Dead: The Mystery of the Tonybee Tiles”

Trackbacks

  1. Lunchtime Quick Hits | Philadelphia Real Estate Blog
  2. Art Thieves Could Help Toynbee Tiles Preservation
Recent Posts
The Physical & Political Importance Of Goldtex

The Physical & Political Importance Of Goldtex

August 29, 2014  |  Morning Blend

Loft District conversion project finally complete, Manayunk parish to preserve historic church, Temple professor talks ’64 riot, major mixed-use for NoLibs, and previewing Greenfest Philly 2014 > more

Ruminating On Lost Columbia Avenue

Ruminating On Lost Columbia Avenue

August 29, 2014  |  Soapbox

In this third installment in our series, Ethan Wallace examines the long term effects the Columbia Avenue riot has had on this weary section of North Philadelphia. Dubbed an "extinction event", Wallace sifts through the ruins of the once vibrant neighborhood while considering the encroaching development of Temple University's campus and the social unrest happening in Ferguson, Missouri. > more

'Scared Half To Death,' Reporter Says

‘Scared Half To Death,’ Reporter Says

August 28, 2014  |  Vantage

Today marks the 50th anniversary of the Columbia Avenue riot. For the second installment of our series, we have a first person account by Philadelphia Evening Bulletin reporter William Naulty, who was sent in to cover the mayhem on the night of August 28, 1964. > more

Roxborough Sawmill Preserves An Old Industrial Aesthetic

Roxborough Sawmill Preserves An Old Industrial Aesthetic

August 28, 2014  |  Morning Blend

One man's mission to preserve the physical history of industrial Philadelphia, groundbreaking for Rodin Square, street mural requested for Triangles Plaza, the genesis of JFK and 30th Street Station, and this weekend's Made in America Fest > more

Bridesburg, Riverfront Neighborhood Now With Riverfront Access

Bridesburg, Riverfront Neighborhood Now With Riverfront Access

August 28, 2014  |  News

With a land swap championed by Councilman Bobby Henon, Philadelphia gained a win-win scenario with the expansion of Dietz & Watson's facilities and a new riverfront park. Plan Philly's Jared Brey and Hidden City's Brad Maule explore the future park in Bridesburg—the riverfront neighborhood which will finally have access to the riverfront > more

Rodeph Shalom As A Beacon On North Broad

Rodeph Shalom As A Beacon On North Broad

August 27, 2014  |  Morning Blend

A look at the historic Jewish synagogue’s expansion, the economic importance of bike lanes, Suzanne Roberts Theater gets $2.5 million boost, remembering the Philadelphia Trades School, and approvals from the Historical Commission > more