For The Future Of Ph.ly

 

Chris Wink, Brian Kirk, and Juliana Reyes of Technically Philly | Photo: Theresa Stigale

Editor’s Note: This spring, Technically Philly founders Chris Wink and Brian James Kirk launched the URL shortener Ph.ly, a project with a decided civic edge: to get young, well-educated Philadelphians to participate in the dialogue about the city’s future. Each Friday Ph.ly subscribers–presumably young professionals–receive links to three stories that Wink and Kirk believe will make them better informed (you can sign up HERE and read back issues HERE). We catch up with Wink to learn about what motivated the project and how it’s going.

Nathaniel Popkin: I’m an old-timer. So I go to the Ph.ly website and I see “Long URL:” with a space for entering information and “Vanity Keyword:” with another space for entering info. What am I supposed to do with that? What’s it for? How can, to paraphrase the site, Ph.ly be integrated into my workflow?
Chris Wink: Ph.ly is two things, and one of them is a URL shortener. So, like bit.ly or ow.ly or tinyURL.com or any of the URL shorteners, this is one that keeps Philly in mind. You can use “vanity keyword” to do fun things like ph.ly/weekly or ph.ly/newsweekly and then track metrics by adding a + sign, like ph.ly/techdoc+. You could use these links to shorten URLs for Twitter or even for print/marketing materials to make them prettier. If you auto-tweet from an RSS feed using something like Twitterfeed, you can auto import using Ph.ly.

Chris Wink and Brian Kirk | Photo: Theresa Stigale

NP: Each Friday, Ph.ly News Weekly sends links to the three “best, most important” journalistic stories to its subscribers. What motivated the idea?
CW: Center City added some 17,000 25-34 year-olds with college degrees from 2000 to 2009, the third highest total in the country. Knowing many of them made me realize that while they tended to genuinely like Philadelphia, there was no acceptable pipeline to get them into the civic dialogue anymore. Many of my peers read stories from NYTimes.com and CNN.com that they find on Facebook, but there isn’t enough of a dialogue about local issues. Without that, I believe it’s harder to retain these brilliant young people and get them involved in civic life. So I decided to do the hard work for them: digesting as much local news as I can and picking out the three most important, most interesting big stories of the week and spoon-feeding them in a mobile-friendly e-mail.

NP: How does it relate to the function of URL shortening?
CW: Both are in the spirit of celebrating Philadelphia. If you wanted to get super detailed, I’ll say that if we ever really scaled the use of Ph.ly we could do fun automation of the News weekly by listing the most shared local stories that week.

NP: The News Weekly seems to us an incentive for news outlets to produce quality stories that matter–competition used to be what drove the news business, after all. Is that the intention, or is it mostly to build a community of engaged readers?
CW: Nope, you have it. I have this entire line of thinking around the idea that there are fuzzier and fuzzier lines between journalism and information providers. Both valuable but there’s something different and important about celebrating the harder work and trying to get it in the hands of all Philadelphians, regardless of age.

NP: Has something like this been done elsewhere?
CW: Eh, there are no original ideas ever, I’m the first to say that. Still, we called for newsletter sign-ups before we started (like a Kickstarter for emails) and got more than 1,000, so we decided it was worth it and went forward. That seems novelish. Have people curated journalism stories locally and tried to scale civic dialogue? Probably, I don’t know of specific examples.

NP: How have news outlets reacted?
CW: We do have other submissions and some excitement by other niche outlets (and actually a couple times legacy media have sent stuff over) but there are two hurdles for news outlets to know or care: (1) the traffic we push to them will just read in their analytics as normal e-mail traffic so I doubt many are savvy enough to know, (2) though the engagement level is high, the list is still somewhat small, less than 1,500, though growing each week, so it’s still early to have the kind of big impact I’d really like–with a list of 10,000, 20,000, or more.

NP: Is there any way to measure the effectiveness of this? How will we know if the issues that matter to the city are getting such good coverage that the civic climate changes?
CW: The web is really good at telling us if something is a good idea. Each new subscriber is a vote of confidence, particularly because the engagement is usually high–about a third are opening the e-mail on any given week. If we can grow the list to a larger size that can have more documented impact (read: more clicks), I think the effectiveness would be instilling a sense of urgency for more important and thoughtful stories because audience is being sent there and not just for top 10 lists and churn (which are important in other ways). That could be tracked by outreach to be included, but the most important success would never be able to be tracked because there are so many factors: a more civicly engaged population, starting with our newest residents.

NP: Who chooses the stories each week? What’s the criteria?
CW: Who has two thumbs and chooses the stories for Ph.ly? This guy, though my colleague Brian Kirk has filled in for me. To be honest, by tracking engagement (clicks), we’re still evolving what should be included. We want to help create a narrative about the city that is both challenging and reflective of a more positive tone pushing for change. So in the past few weeks, we’ve tried some balance–the important, investigative, public-affairs-type story that will always have a home here, but also stories that are news-hooked just by virtue of being published–last week we shared a story about Philadelphia’s role in the history of pretzels because it was good, it helps create a cultural identity, it was from a new source that many people may not know yet (Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia), and we thought it should be getting more attention. The long and the short of it is that we want this to be part of a common set of facts for the city, a shared narrative, but to do that honestly, we’d need to bring in a lot more people. So that’s the experiment: can we? We’ve built niche audiences in other ways, but this is a new challenge because many of the people we want to reach aren’t already engaged locally.

NP: I take it your love of Philly is behind this. How did that develop? What was the trigger?
CW: Philadelphia is complex and conflicted and has more inner turmoil than any character history or fiction has ever given us. Why wouldn’t someone who loves history and community and impact be anywhere else in the world? In more practical terms, I wanted a big city college experience–like so many of my age at this point in history–and Temple University served as a gateway to Philadelphia, like it does when it’s at its best.

Brian Kirk and Chris Wink | Photo: Theresa Stigale

NP: What story you’ve chosen has had the most impact–why do you think?
CW: One story comes to mind for strange reasons: a few weeks ago we pushed to a straightforward Bart Blatstein profile by Philadelphia magazine. It was likely already well-trafficked, but it was a nice, relevant piece, so we included it. Though completely anecdotally, I have had no fewer than five people in this demographic I’m most interested in (25-34 year-old new, educated Philadelphians who may not yet be Hidden City or Technically Philly or, even, NewsWorks readers but should be) told me some variation of “I didn’t know Philadelphia magazine did stories like that,” “I’d never heard of Bart Blatstein,” “I consume this stuff and still didn’t see that story.” Now think about this: this is one of the oldest, most celebrated publishers in our market that put out a very big profile on someone who we take for granted to be this overwhelmingly well-known figure. There is a disconnect. I don’t think we’re building evenly a common set of facts, though we’re doing our best. This is something that can help. Still, I should add for Hidden City readers, we also try to uncover totally new sources, so there will be value there for you too.

About the author

Hidden City co-editor Nathaniel Popkin’s latest book is the novel Lion and Leopard (The Head and The Hand Press). He is also the author of Song of the City (Four Walls Eight Windows/Basic Books) and The Possible City (Camino Books). He is senior writer and script editor of the Emmy-winning documentary series “Philadelphia: The Great Experiment” and the fiction review editor of Cleaver Magazine. His essays and book reviews appear in the Wall Street Journal, Public Books, The Kenyon Review, The Millions, and Fanzine.



2 Comments


  1. Abbey Road photo is the Best photo ever!

  2. I love the idea of increasing civic dialog, and I love the shortener. Got my own when they first started! http://ph.ly/jrussell

Recent Posts
New Delaware Avenue Development Proposals Put Maritime Supply Warehouse In A Corner

New Delaware Avenue Development Proposals Put Maritime Supply Warehouse In A Corner

April 17, 2015  |  News, Vantage

Time bought for the former Edward Corner Marine Merchandize Warehouse in a zoning meeting Wednesday night. Fishtown neighbors shot down developer Michael Samschick's large-scale mixed-use proposals for the three adjoining lots along Delaware Avenue. Contributor Stephen Stofka was there and has a few take-away recommendations for a less sprawling, more conscientious treatment of the blocks > more

The City Of Neighborhoods, For Better Or Worse

The City Of Neighborhoods, For Better Or Worse

April 17, 2015  |  Morning Blend

A look at the decentralized state of affairs in Center City, Live Nation announces plans for reuse of Fishtown factory, and distressed parkers fight South Philly proposal > more

Broad, Market, And The Wholesome City

Broad, Market, And The Wholesome City

April 16, 2015  |  Morning Blend

Reflections on the laying of the cornerstone to City Hall, short film eavesdrops in on Philadelphians in motion, Samschick’s Delaware Avenue projects not too popular with residents, Rebuilding Together Philadelphia celebrates milestone, and community input for West Philly plan > more

In Strawberry Mansion, Making The Case For Adaptive Reuse

In Strawberry Mansion, Making The Case For Adaptive Reuse

April 15, 2015  |  Soapbox

The 100-year old Metropolitan Garage in Strawberry Mansion is as unique as it it is oddly charming. Located right across the street form the entrance of East Fairmount Park, with a great view of the city skyline to boot, Hidden City contributor Oscar Beisart thinks that a bold reuse of the building just might be the kind of creative investment the neighborhood needs. Though, demolition permits are already in place and another opportunity to keep our historic, industrial fabric intact may soon be lost > more

“Air” Installed By The Schuylkill

“Air” Installed By The Schuylkill

April 15, 2015  |  Morning Blend

Famed sculptor’s 1979 piece back on public display, storefront improvement program reportedly strangled by federal regulation, northern concrete City Hall apron to be repoured, and using co-working spaces as a reinvigorator of East Market Street > more

Original Design Of Courtyard Gates To Be Installed At City Hall

Original Design Of Courtyard Gates To Be Installed At City Hall

April 13, 2015  |  Morning Blend

New gates for City Hall were designed in 1869, the mixed blessing of the South Philly refinery, Guinn to design mural for Wissahickon train station, Brandywine Realty moves into Old City, and Squilla promotes valet parking as solution for waterfront clubs > more